imo i've seen too high of a GPA work against a person. If I had to do it again, I'd rather take an engineering GPA of around 3.6;
I say that with personal experience; most people I know with 3.8+ GPAs are really good at being students, but don't necessarily transfer that to the work place well. In one extreme case, the person was super smart, but that person had the worst interview skills ever. 30+ job interviews and the person didn't take a hint that it was interview style that sucked; i think the person switched to teaching...
I also think HR is full of a bunch of shit. Sifting through resumes at the moment, I can say
without hesitation that they are probably filtering out a lot of great qualified candidates that would know what to do; it isn't even about GPA at that point (although, at that point, when I only see 3.9+ GPAs I wonder how many smart kids with 3.5s that we aren't looking at).
How can I say it so emphatically? My resume was filtered right out of HR - it took the right grad student who remembered that I was an insightful student that tried hard and actually did my own work to say "you know what, give me your resume I'll talk to one of my bosses because I think you would do well there". Guess what, I'm doing well there