Originally posted by: alkemyst
Originally posted by: spidey07
CCIE is tops and very difficult to achieve do to the outrageous, never will you see in the real world scenarios you are given in the lab.
Not true. For those scenarios is why you would want to hire a CCIE...esp when seconds are measured in thousands/hundreds of thousands of dollars.
For most people, once you get into your niche you tend to become a master of that skillset.
True field engineers may be in california one night and in Jamaica the next....then sometimes just chilling for a couple weeks for the next big job.
For most people your MCSE, CCNA/NP, A+ and a specialty cert (esp in security or VoIP) will get you in most doors with a few years experience.
Well, no. Just no. The scenarios presented on teh CCIE exam are so bizarre and contain so many goofy configuration spread around a small equipment group ... if you saw something similar in "real life," the person that designed it should be shot, stabbed, drawn & quartered and made to watch political debates (and then the re-runs a few dozen times).
What makes the CCIE Lab difficult is that they ask you to do some task, but (for some of the tasks) not to do it using the correct / conventional method (sometimes they rule out the top couple ways of doing something). The other factor that makes it tough is the number of tasks to be done within the timeframe presented.
Technically, while somewhat of a challenge, it's not that big of a deal. You have to know a variety of methods to accomplish a given goal, and get it done in a short time. You have a complete Cisco library at your disposal for the entire exam ... the issue is that time spent looking stuff up takes away from the config time.
CCIE is absolutely the top cert for networking, no dispute from me there, but I've interviewed CCIEs that didn't know the difference between a POTS jack and a PBX jack (she couldn't get her modem to dial out), and another that couldn't explain the ARPing process (when it happens, where it happens) or explain the MAC/IP address transitions through a series of routers & switches.... so there are more than a few "bootcamp" / Lab Rat CCIEs in the market.
Paper is paper, skills are skills, experience is experience.
Personally, I'll take demonstratable skills and experience over a chunk of paper any day.
FWIW
Scott