Originally posted by: alkemyst
Originally posted by: tontod
Going on Atkins long term will KILL you? WTH did you come up with that nonsense from? Do you have any idea of how the diet works or read any of the books? Many people (thousands) have been on the diet for many years with no adverse effects and have kept their weights off. Please do some homework before criticizing.
Edit: I have been on Atkins since February. I had a checkup last month and all the health indicators (cholesterol, pressure, triglycerides) improved, in addition to dropping weight. And, you can cheat on the atkins sometimes - after you've been on it a while and lost most of the weight you want to lose. I have cheated more than a few times and I have yet to gain any significant amount of weight. So I know it is safe.
I am a Biology major, 7 years of education also 16 years plus training......
If you do the Atkins the right way and keep yourself in Ketosis you will die eventually, fortunately most people cheat enough to lose weight and keep themselves out of Ketosis.
He may have changed his 'plan' recently (well posthumously someone may have)...also doing something for only a year is hardly a complete test across the board.
You can do you own research about the Atkins diet and see it's not new. The thing is today people can usually be saved through medicine and a saved patient does not make headlines.
Quoted and can be verified (this :
The Atkins diet encourages you to drastically reduce carbohydrates, while eating all of the high protein foods you want: eggs, cheese, hamburger (without the bun), steak, and fats to name a few. This is also known as a high protein, low carbohydrate diet. The Atkins diet definitely works and is extremely effective for temporary weight loss, but there are several health related problems that can happen as a result of a low carbohydrate diet.
If someone were to be consistent with the Atkins diet, they may run into the following problems: bad breath, gout (painful inflammation of the joints), high cholesterol (LDL = bad), kidney damage, weakness, bad (acne) or dry skin, thinning hair, increased risk of having a heart attack, yellowish instead of white eye balls, set back or sunken eye balls, muscle loss, frequent urination, vitamin and mineral loss, health related problems due to improper nutrition balance, and attitude or mood changes due to bad nutrition.
Bad breath would be the end result for anyone who eats only fat, oils, and protein. This is what dog food is made of. Items such as eggs and cheese have some of the highest cholesterol content of any food. This is an excellent way to have a heart attack.
Nutritionally, the Atkins diet is terrible. Kidney damage can occur as a result of depleted carbohydrate levels. There are several additional health related problems that this type of diet can cause such as headaches and dizzy spells; both due to a bad nutrition balance. The Atkins diet can kill you! It's an "unhealthy" way to lose weight.
For intense or endurance training, the Atkins diet is not ideal. Because 1) you're depleting your body's primary source of energy, and 2) everything else will literally shut down over the long haul as a direct result of depleted carb levels. Your energy and strength levels while training will suffer!
It is unrealistic to assume that anyone could stay on the Atkins diet for any significant amount of time, given the drawbacks/dangers of this diet. It wouldn't take long for someone to realize that they literally couldn't live without the consumption of carbohydrates.
Now the Atkins system recommends supplements and these are important. However again most people are not following the Atkins Diet to the T....some people gain a lot of weight by doing it wrong.
It appears alot of the heart problems and associated things are being taken care of by the supplements he recommends....the diet has evolved some what.
Now not everyone is going to have all those problems above combined, and some key problems everyone will have....for some they cannot stay on it due to nausea, bowel distress, sexual dysfunction, lethargy, etc. It may work great for some people here, however usually those it doesn't work for do not post (since it'd point out the fact they are still fat and someone has been attacked already here that way).
ATOT is hardly a good sample size, and many will say they are part of something to get on the bandwagon.