Best Captain from all the Star Trek series.

[yasha]

Who do you think was the best?
1) Kirk
2) Picard
3) Sisko
4) Janeway

My pick is Picard.

 

[Sluggo]

Kirk, you have to realize he (as well as the whole series) was dealing with a very conservative network in the late 60's. they did a nice job considering.

 

[Doctorweir]

5) Christopher Pike

I personally like his 1 LED wheelchair...

 

[Blayze]

Kirk

 

[yasha]

Ah yes, the very first captain on the series

 

[Phunktion]

I say Sisko for TV and Picard for the movies..

 

[Elledan]

Picard. ST:TNG rules

 

[The Stigenator]

Sisko from DS9.. what!!!

I would say in the order of prefernce:

Pikard, Kathryn Janeway, Kirk

 

[dawks]

2) Picard

he was awesome..

 

[777joee]

Docktorweir,

My you are a real fan!

 

[yasha]

Elleden: I agree with you. I'm a big TNGer

 

[pidge]

Easy...Picard. I liked Zulu as captain alot too, better than Kirk. Kirk is third on my list. Everyone else sucked.

 

[dalnar]

Picard ... TNG all the way!!

 

[ElFenix]

well ha! sisko wasn't a captain! he was a commander!

 

[luv2chill]

<< 5) Christopher Pike

I personally like his 1 LED wheelchair... >>

Bwahahahahah good one!

My vote is also for Picard. The guy is simply bad-ass!!!

l2c

 

[Tank]

Depends on the criteria... if it's a$$-kickin' then I'd definitely have to go with Kirk. But for leadership ability and charisma, I'd go with Picard.

 

[Doctorweir]

Sisko was promoted in Episode #Idunnoexactly

 

[amdforlife]

sisko was DEFINITELY the best captain...make a poll

 

[snakesnfrogs]

Picard

 

[iamfried]

Kirk. All you need to know is 'double fisted arm drop to opponents back'

 

[damocles]

I like Kirk and Picard equally

Only kirk could have played the original role in that campy way that made it popular.

Then Picard added a lot of credibility to what was traditionally regarded as a show only for geeks

I really disliked Janeway, she was a little too much like a primary school teacher in my opinion

edit: i'd like to see a poll too

 

[Aceman]

Kirk. He cheated to better the odds when the odds were against him.

 

[brinstar117]

Picard, end of story...

Too bad Star Trek (spinoffs) are no longer entertaining. TOS was great, TNG was the best, DS9 had its moments, VOY was a waste of airtime (these are my opinions, I have expressed them, you might agree/disagree no need for flames now, if you do not concur with my thoughts, then debate in a civilized manner)

Please please please let Enterprise be at least somewhat okay. If only Roddenberry was still around

 

[Jothaxe]

Picard

 

[xyyz]

picard could beat them all with no legs no arms no eyes... hell with no head either...

sisko is a close second though...