Originally posted by: SP33Demon
Originally posted by: rh71
Originally posted by: ElFenix
10. He isn't exactly replacing Fernando Tatis
Finally, we might want to mention something here. A-Rod is, no doubt, an upgrade over just about anybody in any team's lineup. But he's not a massive offensive upgrade over the guy he's replacing in the Yankees' lineup -- Alfonso Soriano.
You neglect to mention that ARod will have much more protection in the lineup than Soriano did at the top. Soriano was a great player for that reason. But given ARod's situation and that always-short porch on both sides of his home field, his numbers will be much more huge than they ever were, let alone compared with Soriano's.
<-- watched only about a dozen MLB games on tv for entertainment this year and even knows that much.
It will be harder for ARod to hit at NY than TX... that's a known fact. Plus AROD had protection in the lineup in TX, that's another known fact. He had Palmeiro/Juan Gonzo/and Blalock to protect him. Soriano stole twice as many bases, and scored significantly more runs. Like you said, this was leading off as well.
Maybe you didn't read the full article:
Soriano has more road homers (45 to 44), many more runs scored (133 to 108) and a much higher batting average (.311 to .279) than A-Rod over the last two seasons.
Yes, Soriano's defense isn't as good as ARod's, but you're forgetting that he's 3.5 years younger as well. Not to mention that he could have played the outfield, if NY needed him to. I wouldn't exactly say that NY gained THAT much by losing the best hitting/running 2nd baseman in baseball...