ATI vs. NVidia / AMD vs. Intel

Orbs

Member
Mar 25, 2004
97
0
61
It seems like there are no clear winners with either video card or cpu / mobo choices right now.

On the video card side, ATI has a really fast option for apps with pixel shader 2.0 and it's possible that next gen games might need the bandwidth that native pci-e will offer. But nVidia's best performs on par or better than ATI's and pixel shader 3 support may speed things up with next-gen games (maybe not, who knows). So far, it seems like the bridge to pci-e is plenty fast for nVidia as well.

On the CPU / Mobo side, Intel has offered some interesting new technologies (pci-e, ncq, etc) that AMD doesn't yet offer, but the Athlon 64 (especially FX line) is really fastest of the fast for gaming (and once 64 bit windows + drivers that are mature come out, there will be a speed bump for nothing).

So once again, there are two good choices with no clear winner.

Which would you buy right now?

Video: ATI X800 or nVidia 6800 Ultra (or Ultra Extreme)
CPU: Intel Prescott or AMD 64 (you can also argue P4 EE vs 64 FX)

Let the discussion begin!
 

DAPUNISHER

Super Moderator CPU Forum Mod and Elite Member
Super Moderator
Aug 22, 2001
32,485
33,563
146
The discussions have been conducted ad nauseam already, we don't need another ;)
 

Markfw

Moderator Emeritus, Elite Member
May 16, 2002
27,427
16,294
136
I agree on the video cards that they are close, but I think that the Athlon64 has shown its strength over the P4 in everything but encoding, end then it depends on the software you are using. AMD wins some and the P4 wins some. There was a thread on this before, do a search.
 

DAPUNISHER

Super Moderator CPU Forum Mod and Elite Member
Super Moderator
Aug 22, 2001
32,485
33,563
146
Originally posted by: GreatBarracuda
Originally posted by: DAPUNISHER
The discussions have been conducted ad nauseam already, we don't need another ;)

Oh the flammability!
Fixed that for you ;)
 

Steg55

Member
May 13, 2004
96
0
0
Personally I would wait for nForce4 + 939 A64, combined with 6800 GT

Agreed. Add some of that nice XL Corsair RAM and you will be laughing all the time until Doom 3 comes out - then you will be too busy gaming :D.

nForce 4 detailing here. Please note this is the Inquirer - so take a salt grinder with you

Steg