Asus N6200 128/256M, Radeon 9600PRO/XT, help me please!

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

mickoz

Junior Member
Dec 20, 2005
19
0
0
NVIDIA GeForce2 MX/MX 400 [Display adapter] (I found this because I helped him long-distance not long ago and I make him run a program to know all the part of his computer, hihihi).

He has also an integrated one on his board (Board: Seanix Technology Inc. GA-8S661FXM-775) -- but I doubt integrated video card is that good and I guess that is why he installed the mx 400 one.

IMHO, all I want is a card that will allow him to get all the newest game playable (30fps+ I guess is what is required) for 1y/1.5y+. If the r9600 stuff are not up to do that in your opinion (or in practice) then it is not really worth it, especially if the gf6600 will scale for 1/1.5y+

Unless you want the ultimate experience with all the effects and max resolution (not sure that always allow you to enjoy the gaming more, but I guess it depends the person).

Paying 2x more for a card that will be half price next year and that you won't use to its full capacity, might be a waste of money.

Example:

card1, performance = 100%, price = 100$
card2, performance = 200%, price = 200$

But for year1, all you need is performance of card1. Then in one year, you begin to need card2. But in 1y, card2 will be 100$. Then you pay 100$ each year... but the 2nd year, you can resell your card1 for some buck too. So that decrease your cost. Maybe it doesn't always work that way.

Anyway I think if the 141$ deal I can get still persist tomorrow, that will be a good buy.

And I doubt he need all this TV Tuner, VideoIn (like the MSI with VIVO that would have attracted me more). He will play games and use his computer for do non-intensive stuff (chat, homework, watch video, etc.). So that will do the job and well I believe.

Unless now that I say this you tell me, with the 9600 pro, you will be able to do the job for at less 1y and a good job, but I think I understood that the 9600pro is a little bit behind now. (http://www.gpureview.com/show_cards.php?card1=191&card2=75 -- most difference are in chip detail)

Yeah and I compare let's say the 9600pro vs. 6600 on the 3Digest (http://www.digit-life.com/articles2/digest3d/) the 6600 seems sometime similar, but always upper (I only check lowest resolution without special effect) and sometime way upper. Not that I know what all benchmark number mean but I try to figure out how it looks like compared to other.

If that is fps in the number, then I guess 6600 is a good choice for the buck. It seems to scale a little, and I don't want to go too high in price. I think that will be very benefit compared to what he used to have and I guess all newest game will run on a 6600.

Now last thing I go check is if the asus board that I can get is good enough and has no hidden stuff. ;-)
 

mickoz

Junior Member
Dec 20, 2005
19
0
0
Hi,

I finally settled for that:

http://cgi.ebay.com/BFG-Geforce-6600-gt...13QQcategoryZ40161QQrdZ1QQcmdZViewItem

(I get it for 150$ CAD, he is a local and I will get it in hand and in a timely manner. I tried to get it at lower 125$, but I think 150$ is not bad. Apparently it is new, but I saw that even on eBay some sold at 140$ USD when not new).

6600 GT is gonna be way better for him I bet and I would have had to pay maybe a little more for a 6600 in store.

I also heard BFG was really good and had lifetime warranty, so what can be wrong.

I had time against me, else I would have probably been able to fetch a better deal, even thought I think that one is still a good deal.

(The guy was selling it for a friend of his. He had a buy it now of 150$ USD, however I asked him to call and he said he was gonna try to get cheaper 120-130$ CAD from his friend, but apparently he said 150$ and I wanted to think and see if I cannot get better deal, but I think that would only have made me more worry, improve the chance that I don't get it on time, etc. etc.) And he mights add some games! I hope they are good ones. (Not that this matter much but if it is cool game, that make it even more fun!)

I also saw a EVGA card:
http://cgi.ebay.com/NEW-EVGA-Nvidia-Gef...92QQcategoryZ40161QQrdZ1QQcmdZViewItem

I have noticed the guy sold a couple at 110$ BIN not long ago (if you are interested). I was gonna contact him today and coincidence he put an auction. His probably have more chance for it to be really new since he has a lot (or else he gets them from factory?! who know). Maybe he won't want to deal to lower. However 110$ + 13$ shipping * 1.2 (approximate exchange rate) + maybe time it could get late... it is not as fun as give the gift on xmas. I would have waited for a better card however the one I got if really new is a very good deal, don't you agree? ;-)

What you would have done? Take the BFG or EVGA? (look the auction too for your own judgement.)
 

mickoz

Junior Member
Dec 20, 2005
19
0
0
I would also like to thanks everyone who helped, especially Matthias99 who has been really helpful and enlighted my choice. He somehow gave me the will to try to find a better deal for a better card.

I really hope I did the right choice (I think I did, ho ho ho) and that he will be happy :)

Merry Christmas and Happy New Year in advance to everyone! :)