Asus A8N-E chipset fan - How loud?

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

ChuckF

Junior Member
Feb 21, 2006
1
0
0
I don't have anything very illuminating to add, but for what it's worth can make up the numbers now that I'm on my third A8N-E in less than a week. With number 1, the PC kept shutting itself down before I could even get the OS installed. At first I had no idea why, but after a few hours there was a smell of burning and the inevitable shutdown. With the board removed, something around the area of the chipset fan smelt of burning. With mobo number 2 there was no video. At all. I got number 3 yesterday, a Revision 2 (sorry, dunno what the other 2 were), which ran fine yesterday and most of today - yippee! But now an intermittent whine has started coming from, you've guessed it, the chipset fan. The noise fades in and out very gracefully and sounds like a tiny aeroplane. Btw, when it's working properly the chipset fan is nice and quiet.

Maybe those who haven't yet bought the A8N-E could also consider an Abit KN8 Ultra as an alternative?
 

mechBgon

Super Moderator<br>Elite Member
Oct 31, 1999
30,699
1
0
I was getting ready to leave for work today and my A8N-E-powered rig was actually making a bit of fan noise. It's a lot quieter after hours and I'd just walked into my office, so it was more of a contrast than normal.

mechBgon: curses! :p Now which fan's doing that...?!

*gets down on all fours and opens case... unplugs several fans... and finally discovers it's the 40mm Sunon on the MCX-159A*

mechBgon: blah! :| I should've waited for the model with the heatpipe!


Maybe I'll 7-volt it. Or I could upgrade... :D
 

BernardP

Golden Member
Jan 10, 2006
1,315
0
76
Just thinking about this...Please spare me a little if it makes no sense :gift:

Would there be a way to rig connectors (such as plugging the chipset fan in a case fan connector?) so as to have the chipset fan controlled by the Asus Q-Fan feature?
 

mechBgon

Super Moderator<br>Elite Member
Oct 31, 1999
30,699
1
0
Originally posted by: BernardP
Just thinking about this...Please spare me a little if it makes no sense :gift:

Would there be a way to rig connectors (such as plugging the chipset fan in a case fan connector?) so as to have the chipset fan controlled by the Asus Q-Fan feature?
Yeah, that could work too. On A8N-E's, Q-Fan can control another header besides the CPU_FAN header.

 

walk2k

Member
Feb 11, 2006
157
2
81
Guess I'll add my 2 cents... I got an A8N-E from Newegg just last week (Feb.2006) it is Rev.2, with BIOS 1010. The chipset fan has a silvery(plastic) housing around it, with Asus logo. It's not very loud at all, certainly not audible over the CPU/PSU fan(s). (Amd X2 retail box fan and Antec SP-500 dual-fan PSU). According to the BIOS it runs at about 6200 rpm, not 8k like the original fan (?)
 

BernardP

Golden Member
Jan 10, 2006
1,315
0
76
Originally posted by: walk2k
I got an A8N-E from Newegg just last week (Feb.2006) it is Rev.2, with BIOS 1010. The chipset fan has a silvery(plastic) housing around it, with Asus logo. It's not very loud at all, certainly not audible over the CPU/PSU fan(s).
From reading previous posts and then this one, it seems there is a lottery factor involved in buying an A8N-E. Even if you get a Rev 2 board, you can never be quite sure of the chipset fan you will get.


 

walk2k

Member
Feb 11, 2006
157
2
81
NB fans
The one I have looks like the one on the left. It's not very noisy at all. Some noise, but less than CPU fan, and much less than the GPU fan (Xfx 7800GT) in full-speed (gaming) mode. MUCH less.
 

Mezzanine

Member
Feb 13, 2006
99
0
66
The chipset fan on my A8N-E wasn't too bad for a start, sure you knew it was there but it wasn't offensive. As time went by though it got worse and worse untill i replaced it with a passive Zalman NB47J heatsink.

The silence was beautiful.
 

koitsu

Member
Feb 13, 2004
69
0
76
My MCX159-CU arrived yesterday (purchased from Sidewinder Computers), and I was anxious to install it.

The installation manual is pretty awful (the diagrams are really bad quality: it's hard to read the text, and it's nearly impossible to denote what direction pieces are supposed to go together, etc..).

The actual product is *wonderful*. The installation (once you figure out how to do it) is fairly easy, and isn't messy, nor is it one of those installs which makes you wish you had a third hand/arm to help out.

And of course, the temperatures: the sink is cold, 24x7. I've had the system running for over 24 hours now, and the sink remains cold. Having a 1500rpm fan blowing directly on it really makes a difference.

Some things I encountered during the installation which I'll make note of here for other users:

1) Remove/unscrew the fan completely before doing the installation. Just trust me -- it makes the whole job much easier. Keep in mind item #2 below, however...

2) The installation manual shows a diagram which states the mounting holes for the fan are spaced differently than the mounting holes for the motherboard; it's just a confusing diagram. To understand it, look very closely at where the actual mounting holes are in the heatsink -- look at the spacing between the outside edge of the sink and where the hole is. Then it'll all make sense. :)

I ended up using a permanent felt-tip marker to blacken the areas on the heatsink around the holes which were used for the fan, just so I didn't forget.

3) I used the Ceramique thermal paste which came with the MCX159-CU, rather than Arctic Silver 5. The reason is that, as far as I know, the Ceramique is *not* conductive while Silver 5 *is*. I'd rather not risk shorting out components if some paste decides to leak or during deinstallation (if necessary) ends up touching some traces or other components.

4) The Sunon fan which came with my product is quiet and has that "whoosh" noise instead of a buzzing. However, one piece of bad news: the fan also emits a "clicking" sound, which appears to be coming from the motor or the servo inside of the fan itself. This problem is likely specific to the fan I got and not specific to all of the MCX159-CUs out there.

I called up Swiftech and asked for them to replace the fan. I was transferred from the main number to another person, named Michelle, who seemed very eager to get me off the phone as soon as possible and made absolutely no effort to do an RMA over the telephone. She insisted I Email her with where I bought the product, when I bought it, what model it was, my telephone number, address, and full details of the fan itself. She gave me her Email address incorrectly as well (michelle@swiftech.com -- when it's actually michelle@swiftnets.com). I still have yet to receive a response.


Those things aside...

I've taken some pictures of my installation to show what the end result looks like, and to help out with those who buy the product, see all the little metal pieces, and go "How the HELL does this work!? Where do I mount this? Which direction do the pieces go in?! AAHHH THE DIAGRAM IS HORRIBLE!!" ;-)

http://jdc.parodius.com/a8n-e/mcx159cu_01.jpg
http://jdc.parodius.com/a8n-e/mcx159cu_02.jpg
http://jdc.parodius.com/a8n-e/mcx159cu_03.jpg

People buying the MCX159-CU may find pictures #2 and #3 very helpful, as they show exactly how the little metal doo-dad should be mounted to the sink and the motherboard screws.
 

Old Hippie

Diamond Member
Oct 8, 2005
6,361
1
0
Nice Job!
This problem is likely specific to the fan I got and not specific to all of the MCX159-CUs out there.
Yep, my unit has been running for 6 months with no noise.