Originally posted by: GrantMeThePower
Macro photography:
What are the plusses and minuses of 1. Macro lens, 2. Lens revers ring, 3. Extension tubes, 4. Closeup filters?
1. Extension Tubes
Extension tubes are GREAT for an emergency macro or a portable/light macro setup. If you don't want to or don't have the space to or can't carry the extra weight of a dedicated macro lens, extension tubes are your answer. Also, they are great for decreasing the focusing distance of lenses. Say that your 50mm has a minimum focusing distance of 5 inches, but your subject that's behind glass is 4 inches in front of you. You could move back an inch, but then your magnification of the subject gets messed up. Just plop on a 13mm extension tube and you should now be able to focus to 4 inches.
http://fuzzybabybunny.smugmug.com/gallery/1645619
That day I totally forgot to bring my macro lens. Good thing I always have a set of lightweight extension tubes in my camera bag, so I just plopped them onto the 50mm and was good to go. A nice, light 50mm macro.
I personally use the Pro Optic Auto Extension tubes:
http://www.adorama.com/MCAETEOS.html
I know people swear by Kenko, but I find it hard to justify the price of the Kenko's when there's Pro Optic (Adorama's house brand). These extension tubes do not work too well however when they're attached to a heavy lens (180mm+) and then rotated in the portrait orientation, as the metal contacts between the tubes sometimes tends to disconnect, giving your camera an error.
2. Dedicated Macro Lenses
ALL macro lenses are incredibly sharp. I seriously doubt you will be dissappointed by the sharpness of a macro lens, regardless of if it's from Sigma, Canon, or Tamron. You have to think about working distance though. A shorter focal length macro lens means you have to get closer to your subject to get that 1:1 magnification, which may disturb your subject or even anger it. A longer focal length macro lens means you have greater working distance.
Short focal lengths (~60mm, Canon 60mm): short working distance, but lighter and easily hand-holdable, meaning you can get more refined focus when you're handholding and manually focusing by moving your body back and forth until you get fine focus.
Medium focal lengths (~100mm, Canon 100mm, Tamron 90mm, Sigma 105mm): medium working distance, still pretty light and easy to hand-hold. Works great as a portrait lens too.
Longer focal lengths (~150mm+, Sigma 150mm, Sigma 180mm, Tamron 180mm): longest working distance, won't disturb your subjects. Handholding is hard because the lens is heavier, making hand shake more pronounced. Expensive. Doubles as a really sharp telephoto prime.
3. Reverse-mounted Wideangles
literally taking a wide-ish lens and mounting it in reverse on your camera body. Requires a cheap reverse mount adapter and possibly some cheap step up/down rings.
http://fuzzybabybunny.smugmug.com/gallery/1702772
Pros: Can get insane magnification, much more than 1:1. A reversed 50mm is actually a little less than 1x magnification. A reversed 30mm is about 2x magnification. A reversed 20mm is about 3x. A reversed 10mm is about 6x.
Cons: Limited aperture control. There is no electronic contact between the lens and body, so you have to stop down the lens to the desired aperture before reverse mounting. Looking through a stopped down lens means a dimmer viewfinder image and greater difficulting in determining when something's in focus. The depth of field is also razor thin. Expect a lot of attempts to get a subject in focus. Working distance is about an inch or less. It's also difficult even
finding your subject in the viewfinder when you're at such high magnifications.
4. Shorter lens reverse mounted on a longer lens and then mounted on the camera
Ex. Reversed 50mm + Sigma 150mm + camera body
Will need to buy the coupler for the two lenses. Large, unwieldy, but can get great results with the right combination. Magnification is determined by the longer focal length divided by the shorter focal length, so in the above setup it would be 150mm / 50mm = 3x. I personally have no had success with this, but others have.
Search for Jody Melanson on the Fred Miranda Macro forums. He uses the above setup. He is a macro god. So is Tom Hicks.
5. Close Up Filters
Pros: Relatively cheap, hardly any loss of image quality, light, portable, can be used on my lenses, can be stacked onto existing macro setups for even more magnification, good working distance on longer lenses.
Cons: May have vignetting if you're using a 62mm filter on a lens with 77mm thread. Magnification depends on lens' minimum focusing distance. If the lens has a very long minimum focusing distance, you may not be able to get the magnification you want.