Remember when there were NO 3D cards and yet games were so much more fun?
Yes! It was partly because we were kids but the games were still fun.
I've recently discovered Dos Box ( instead of using W7 with an XP emulator) to play Worms from 1995. It is still fun to play, after the shock of the terrible graphics wears off...
GL QUAKE was the first huge jump in graphics quality. I was blown away with how much better the graphics were and how much smoother GL QUAKE was but it wasn't more fun. The only sound your guy makes is "huh" when he jumps. Older 2.5D games like Shadow Warrior or Duke Nukem 3D were more fun. Your character said funny stuff, not just "huh".
"You want to wash Wang or you want to watch Wang wash Wang?"
"Oh ho ho, sticky bomb like you!"