Are Cup of Noodles bad for your health?

Imported

Lifer
Sep 2, 2000
14,679
23
81
My mom says they are. Apparently, she heard from a friend that someone had Cup of Noodles on a daily basis and he died from them, since they supposedly caused a lining of wax in either his kidney or liver. Just wondering if it's possible, because my mom has practically banned me from eating them.. :disgust:
 

JaiKnight

Senior member
Feb 6, 2000
958
0
0
I heard the same story, and looking at the stuff I'd say it could probably be true....wouldn't be packing too much of that stuff in my stomach if I were you....
 

prodigy

Lifer
Oct 9, 1999
14,822
1
0
bigsmooth is right. It might not be BAD for you persay, but it surely ain't healthy.
 

Imported

Lifer
Sep 2, 2000
14,679
23
81
I don't eat that much, probably once every three months if I can't find anything else to eat. I know their loaded in salt. My friend used to eat them on a daily basis at school since they provided hot water. Just seemed interesting that a wax build up could be caused by them. :)
 

Namuna

Platinum Member
Jun 20, 2000
2,435
1
0
Another story I heard was that a College Student decided to live on Cup-o-Noodle alone, since he was so dead poor.

Like a month or so later he was hospitalized for Scurvy...From lack of proper vitamins.
 

WombatWoman

Diamond Member
Feb 19, 2000
5,439
1
0
Here is what Barbara Mikkelson, of Snopes.com, (an excellent online reference for urban legends) says about this rumour:

Claim: Cups of instant noodles pose a danger thanks to the wax used to line the cups.

Status: False.

Example: [Collected on the Internet, 2000]

For our health concern, pls pass on the msg to those you know who loves Instand Noodles.
This is what I heard from a fellow colleague. Her nephew, who was studying in UK for about one and a half years, likes to eat cup-a-noodle. And guess what!

His doctor has found that there is a layer of wax lining the walls of his stomach. Seems that instand noodles that comes with foam containers contain an edible layer of wax. However, regular consumptions make it hard for our livers to clear the toxic.

This person died when he went for an operation to try to remove the layer. Pls do not boil the noodles in the container. Transfer to a glass bowl before you put the hot water.


Origins: Who dreams up these wild-assed scares anyway? This latest caution against a non-existent lurking threat made its Internet debut in early October 2000.

Styrofoam does an excellent job all on its own in keeping a hot liquid hot, and the thicker "heat 'n' serve" containers made of it stand up very well to microwave heating. There'd be no need to use wax on such a container, because any use it could possibly serve is already well handled by the styrofoam.

Besides, coating with wax the interior of a styrofoam container one knows would be used to heat a product would be rather pointless, because heat will melt wax, thus incorporating what was supposed to be part of the package into the foodstuff. Manufacturers of instant foods have a hard enough time convincing folks that their stuff tastes good enough to eat without introducing melted wax into the equation.

Even if wax were used in the styrofoam containers, and even if some of it did get into the food, it wouldn't adversely affect the average person. (It might possibly cause a problem for infants or those with damaged or impaired digestive systems, but not ordinary, healthy adults.) Though it's not generally known, a number of candies routinely contain wax products. (Rowntree's "Smarties" and Just Born's "Peeps" immediately come to mind -- carnauba wax is used in these products, as it is in candy corn.) In some confections, the wax is more upfront, as countless children who've indulged in wax lips and wax "soda" bottles will happily attest. To the best of our knowledge, none of the indulgers in these products have had to have the wax scraped out of their stomachs (including my husband, who in the Octobers of his childhood happily ate several pieces of wax a day).

This badly-constructed scare would have us believe someone's unnamed nephew in the United Kingdom died from a buildup of wax in his stomach. Wax, like just about anything else one swallows, is pushed through the digestive system and exits the body as part of a bowel movement. Nothing inherently special in wax would turn it into a permanent coating clinging forever to the stomach lining.

Use your noodle, and don't pass this silly scare on.

Barbara "looking for a few good ramens" Mikkelson

 

C'mon guys and gal, it's SALTED PASTA. THAT'S IT! If it's all you eat, of course you're going to be sick. Just like if you ate only apples for a month. You'd suffer from terrible malnutrition.

That's why I make 2 packs of Ramen Noodles part of my balanced daily diet;). Yeah, I guess the "Cup'o'Noodles" are probably worse, with the plastic cup you radiate in the microwave.

Mix it up, folks.
 

Bling Bling

Banned
Dec 16, 1999
1,279
0
0
EngineNr9: i love your name (if we're on the same pace here). out of curiousity, did EngineNo9 not work?
 

goog40

Diamond Member
Mar 16, 2000
4,198
1
0
It's ok for you, outside of the sodium. Still much healthier than a lot of teh stuff out there.
 

The Wildcard

Platinum Member
Oct 31, 1999
2,743
0
0
Well Cup of Noodles has an insane amount of sodium and it also has alot of preservtives as well since it's precooked. It's not horrible for you, but it isn't exactly good for you too, so i wouldn't recommend eating so many of them every week.
 

Spindler

Senior member
Oct 3, 2000
381
0
0
its cheap tho! cup o' noodles 5 for 1.00

ramen noodles 12 for 1.00

if you're gonna die, its gonna take at least 40 years.
 

Spindler

Senior member
Oct 3, 2000
381
0
0
lol yah, how come? you'd think since msg is a preservative, it'd make you last longer! ;)
 

prontospyder

Diamond Member
Oct 9, 1999
6,262
0
0
My mom told me they are bad too...

about some Japanese college student who ate instant noodles throughout his 4 years in college...then died on his graduation day.
 

Zucchini

Banned
Dec 10, 1999
4,601
0
0
Like any processed food, it can be bad if abused. Eat tv dinners for your every meal and you'll turn out the same. :p No food is purely evil:p All things in moderation.. blah blah blah
 

lowtech1

Diamond Member
Mar 9, 2000
4,644
1
0

You can read the ingredient for your self. Some of the package/cup noodles does contain MSG, but you can find a tone of them that doesn?t.

Personally I don?t think it is that bad for your nor it is that good for you. The noodles contain almost no nutrition value except for the starch that will take no time to go through your system...You get hungry quicker eating them noodles, than a sandwich. And, if noodles is that bad as some of the claims that we saw here, the Asian population wouldn?t be as much as problem that we have now :)