• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

apparently canada is turning americans away in droves

Page 3 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.
Originally posted by: Riceninja
we dont need any americans here. theyre broke and uneducated.

It isn't that hard to move to Canada with a masters degree and work experience in your field.

Super easy if you have an employer lined up.
 
Originally posted by: 0roo0roo
i say we all go there and rush the fence... for the lulz🙂

Don't stop rushing, even if it seems like a long time and it's getting cold. The Fence is just inside the water.
 
The Canadian procedures involved here are that the border guards will refuse entry to someone who has been convicted in the USA of an offense that would have been a CRIMINAL law conviction in Canada, even if it was not part of criminal law in the USA. By far the most common type of these cases is DUI's: that is considered a serious enough offense that it is part of the federal Criminal Code in Canada, but not so in most US states. There are procedures you can follow to solve the problem for many such offenses, but it takes time so it has to be done ahead. Basically it amounts to applying in the USA to an American court for a legal pardon, and that usually involves establishing that it was a rare event not likely to be repeated.

If you check (by website or otherwise) in advance for information surrounding entry into Canada, you most certainly will find notices about these things as warnings. But we are all so used to the easy border between our two countries we almost forget that they are different countries with different laws. Another example of very different laws surrounds carrying weapons with you, so people need to be aware of those laws, too.
 
Originally posted by: sandorski
Did they have Passports?

Passports are a very reliable way of establishing identity and citizenship, so they are always useful when crossing a border. But you don't need one to enter Canada as a US citizen - other documentation will do. The new passport requirements are AMERICAN law. You could enter Canada without one, but just try to get back home to the USA without it! For that reason, Canadian border officials might well ask whether you have one because they don't want to have you stuck in Canada with no way home! But technically Canada does not require an American citizen to produce a passport or a visa for entry.
 
Originally posted by: CPA
Originally posted by: IcebergSlim
Originally posted by: SacrosanctFiend
5 people = droves?

Five ppl I know so multiply out by how many people have been arrested by how many have tried to visit canada....you have your answer. droves.

0 people that I know have been turned away.

To be fair to the OP you have to admit you probably don't meet a lot of people down in your folk's basement.
 
Originally posted by: Paperdoc
Originally posted by: sandorski
Did they have Passports?

Passports are a very reliable way of establishing identity and citizenship, so they are always useful when crossing a border. But you don't need one to enter Canada as a US citizen - other documentation will do. The new passport requirements are AMERICAN law. You could enter Canada without one, but just try to get back home to the USA without it! For that reason, Canadian border officials might well ask whether you have one because they don't want to have you stuck in Canada with no way home! But technically Canada does not require an American citizen to produce a passport or a visa for entry.

That would be the exact reason why they may deny Entry now. Unless those people without one are Immigrating to Canada.
 
Originally posted by: Paperdoc
Originally posted by: sandorski
Did they have Passports?

Passports are a very reliable way of establishing identity and citizenship, so they are always useful when crossing a border. But you don't need one to enter Canada as a US citizen - other documentation will do. The new passport requirements are AMERICAN law. You could enter Canada without one, but just try to get back home to the USA without it! For that reason, Canadian border officials might well ask whether you have one because they don't want to have you stuck in Canada with no way home! But technically Canada does not require an American citizen to produce a passport or a visa for entry.

100% wrong.
 
Originally posted by: IcebergSlim
Originally posted by: Paperdoc
Originally posted by: sandorski
Did they have Passports?

Passports are a very reliable way of establishing identity and citizenship, so they are always useful when crossing a border. But you don't need one to enter Canada as a US citizen - other documentation will do. The new passport requirements are AMERICAN law. You could enter Canada without one, but just try to get back home to the USA without it! For that reason, Canadian border officials might well ask whether you have one because they don't want to have you stuck in Canada with no way home! But technically Canada does not require an American citizen to produce a passport or a visa for entry.

100% wrong.

wtf is wrong with that post? The US changed the border crossing rules, not Canada. Prior to 9/11, if you drove across the border "country of citizenship?" "United States" "Purpose going into Canada today?" "We're heading to the falls/shopping/whatever" "How long will you be staying?" "3 days" "Okay, go ahead. "

The only time I ever had trouble crossing the border was when I had my two sons with me. "Does the mother know the children are with you?" "Yes." "Does she know you're taking them into Canada" "uhh, no, this was just a spontaneous trip; we're camping about 15 miles from here & thought we'd take a ride into Canada."
After that, I was treated like I was abducting my own children & my children were questioned extensively. A few minutes later, we were heading into Canada.

Oh, and in case your point is about passports not being necessary, they're not.
 
Originally posted by: DrPizza
Originally posted by: IcebergSlim
Originally posted by: Paperdoc
Originally posted by: sandorski
Did they have Passports?

Passports are a very reliable way of establishing identity and citizenship, so they are always useful when crossing a border. But you don't need one to enter Canada as a US citizen - other documentation will do. The new passport requirements are AMERICAN law. You could enter Canada without one, but just try to get back home to the USA without it! For that reason, Canadian border officials might well ask whether you have one because they don't want to have you stuck in Canada with no way home! But technically Canada does not require an American citizen to produce a passport or a visa for entry.

100% wrong.

wtf is wrong with that post? The US changed the border crossing rules, not Canada. Prior to 9/11, if you drove across the border "country of citizenship?" "United States" "Purpose going into Canada today?" "We're heading to the falls/shopping/whatever" "How long will you be staying?" "3 days" "Okay, go ahead. "

The only time I ever had trouble crossing the border was when I had my two sons with me. "Does the mother know the children are with you?" "Yes." "Does she know you're taking them into Canada" "uhh, no, this was just a spontaneous trip; we're camping about 15 miles from here & thought we'd take a ride into Canada."
After that, I was treated like I was abducting my own children & my children were questioned extensively. A few minutes later, we were heading into Canada.

Oh, and in case your point is about passports not being necessary, they're not.

Oh really? 2 weeks ago I called and showed up in person to the Canadian Consulate in NYC the day I was supposed to goto Canada to see if anything could be done because my passport had expired in May 2009.

There was absolutely nothing they could do for me.

June 1st it became law entering and leaving canada by car or plane requires a valid passport for Americans.

Passport requirements have been a complicated and everchanging issue for U.S. travellers to Canada for the past few years due to the Western Hemisphere Travel Initiative (WHTI), which was introduced in 2004 by the U.S. government to strengthen U.S. border security and standardize travel documentation.

Visitors from any country other than the U.S. have always needed a passport to enter Canada. On the other hand, because of a friendly border crossing agreement between Canada and the United States, Canada Border Services did not require U.S. citizens to present a passport to enter Canada. This friendly border crossing agreement used to be mutual; however, now the WHTI requires that U.S. citizens have a passport to return home. In this way, passport requirements for Canada and U.S. borders are different on paper, but, are in practice, the same. Canada will not allow a U.S. citizen into the country who does not have the proper documentation to return home.
 
Awwww, poor Iceberg Slim, didn't get to go to Canada. Note that in the bolded section, it doesn't say "passport." I do *not* need a passport to go to Canada. I only need "proper documentation."
 
Originally posted by: DrPizza
Awwww, poor Iceberg Slim, didn't get to go to Canada. Note that in the bolded section, it doesn't say "passport." I do *not* need a passport to go to Canada. I only need "proper documentation."

http://gocanada.about.com/od/c...qt/valid_travel_ID.htm

Correct...nexus card, ehanced drivers liscence or Fast/Expres card whatever those are.

But in any case I spoke to the Canadian Consulate border guard officials they confirmed in no uncertain terms that I need a passport and an expired passport wouldn't be allowed. Which contradicts paper docs assumptions.
 
Enhanced driver's license - since I'm in NY, I pay an extra $10 or $15 when I renew my driver's license & it's good enough to get me into Canada (more importantly - back into the U.S.)

Also, here's something you'll be disappointed to read:
Although U.S. border guards have been lenient so far with travelers who do not have their passports, Joanne Ferreira of the United States Customs and Border Patrol said compliance has been very high.

"Travelers are showing up with their approved documents and those that do not have their approved documents, we're still in that flexible period of time, and we're not denying entry as long as they are admissible and we can confirm their identity and citizenship," she said from Washington, D.C.

So, had you gone to the border, they probably wouldn't have turned you away; just said "what rock have you been living under? Next time, you need a passport."

edit: ooops, I closed the source - http://www.newsday.com/travel-...teep-decline-1.1322570
 
I haven't tried since they denied me entry in the 80s.

Seems I was considered undesirable from a marijuana bust in '74. :laugh:
 
Originally posted by: FuzzyDunlop
who wants to go there anyways?
Same reason Mexicans are coming up to the U.S. in droves.
Only difference is we have actual proof of the Mexican droves as opposed to the OP's story.
 
Originally posted by: shortylickens
Originally posted by: FuzzyDunlop
who wants to go there anyways?
Same reason Mexicans are coming up to the U.S. in droves.
Only difference is we have actual proof of the Mexican droves as opposed to the OP's story.

Err...no.
 
Back
Top