Alright, goldenbear, let me break it down for you.
First, the commercials.
And I quote from one:
"It's easy oh so easy. AOL, so easy to use, it's #1".
Now, think about this for a moment. AOL costs now $24 (the price just went up by $2 IIRC), it is #1 in the world, the software has been proven to be the most buggy, most insecure piece of ISP software possibly EVER built, and it is #1.
Now look at the alternatives. Many ISPs are free if you hack around with them, or you can get a low monthly cost (under $10). You are not bound to any crappy (or as AOL puts it, 'easy') software in these ISPs, and they are as secure as you choose to make them.
So what does this say about a large majority of people, or at least people using AOL? Sh*t, if I need to break it down for you at this point, you're not even worth debating.