Originally posted by: FeathersMcGraw
Originally posted by: BooneRebel
I don't get it. I quite watching cartoons when I was 8 or 9 (well, except for the occassional Simpsons episode 😀). What makes anime so popular? Because it's a cartoon from another country? Do you watch Spanish soap operas, too?
So you don't watch Disney films?
Pigeonholing anime because it's a cartoon is like saying that you don't watch "dramas" or "comedies". The fact that it's animated and originates from Japan is pretty much the only common thread to a genre which includes sci-fi, romance, "kid's cartoons", and, yes, pornography. While there are certainly entries which contain cultural elements that most Western audiences don't quite understand, it's a sufficiently huge pool of entries that there is likely something that falls under the blanket that will appeal to someone unless they're biased against animation in general. A lot of it
is garbage, but Sturgeon's Law always applies.
Well said, Feathers. However, you didn't point out that originally, cartoons in the U.S. were targeted at adults, not kids. It was some time after they were first introduced that they became associated with children. I think much of the main reason for American culture automatically associating cartoons with children is because of the Disney cartoons. Not that Disney was bad, but
BooneRebel should understand that animation in other parts of the world is not necessarily aimed at children.
A side effect of this is that anime in Japan is HUGE compared to animation in the West. As I understand it, "SuperDimension Fortress Macross" (the Robotech Macross Saga in the U.S.) in Japan was almost as big as Star Wars was in the U.S. And it spawned more sequels.
I would also like to point out that much of the early anime that was translated to English from Japanese was "kiddified." In other words, it was chopped-up, simplified, and made as non-violent as possible, which resulted in them being just plain stupid and virtually unwatchable by anyone over the age of 10. An example would be the conversion of Mazinger-Z to the English version Tranzor-Z. Or the horrible "Battle of the Planets."If
BooneRebel is basing his point of view on these pieces of crap, then I certainly understand his misunderstanding.
Even today, the English version of Dragonball Z is apparently heavily censored (e.g. People don't die, they go to another dimension).
Back to
BooneRebel's question: What
I like about anime:
1. Japanese animation (until recently) visuals blew American cartoons away. Totally. No comparison. If you like special effects in movies, you HAVE to appreciate anime.
2. Violence. I always thought American cartoons sucked because they never portrayed violence realistically. Some of the first Japanese cartoons I saw had people dying left and right. In Voltus V, in the 2nd episode, Mom dies flying a kamikaze plane into the enemy in order to save her kids. Contrast that with G.I. Joe. Every episode: 5000 shots fired, no one killed.
3. Actual plots. Starblazers (Space Battleship Yamato in Japan) was the first cartoon I ever saw that actually had a long-range plotline. You actually had to watch the episodes in order, or the series made no sense.
4. Creativity. Lots and lots. I wonder if drugs are as popular with the "creative" crowd in Japan?
5. The chicks in anime are really cute.
😛