fbrdphreak
Lifer
I've not driven a Cobalt, but one thing to consider is safety features. My gf's sister (17) is getting her first car and her Dad made a big deal over safety features, so we've researched this a lot. Side impact airbags apparently make a huge difference in safety according to all the tests. To my knowledge, but I haven't checked, no GM cars feature the side impact airbags and overall less safety features than the 06 Civic. The Civic gets top marks in all safety tests, I think the Subaru Legacy is one of the only other cars to get the same top marks.
Check out http://www.iihs.org for more information on the safety tests.
Check out http://www.iihs.org for more information on the safety tests.