• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

Anyone a Marine/former Marine/Soldier in Vietnam?

notfred

Lifer
And seen Full Metal Jacket?

I want to know how accurate the depiction of basic training is. Also, if you went to vietnam, how accurate is the second half of the movie?

I just watched it again last night, and from my pointof view, it seems pretty accurate, but I've never been oin the military, so what do I know.
 
The basic training in the movie was similar to our Army basic...and my Marine Corps friends say it's decently accurate
 
My father-in-law went through boot camp during the timeframe of the movie and he says it isn't too far off.
 
I was a Vietnam-era HospitalCorpsman, I spent some time at Parris Island (East Coast Boot Camp).

I thought it was pretty close.

R. Lee Ermy (the Drill Instructor) WAS a real Drill Instructor in the Marines.

Of course, they focus on the "more interesting" aspects of boot camp. The part that many/most/all movies never show is 2-8 hours a day in classrooms learning procedures, rules, ranks, "Diversity," emergency procedures, and all the other stuff. When you're not in the classroom, then it's the drill hall (marching around indoors), "grinder" (asphalt or grass places to march around on), PT, Mess Hall, Fire-Fighting Training Unit (for the Navy & CG), PT, the shooting range, and all sorts of other activities.

The Drill Instructors / Company Commanders (I was in the Navy, did boot up a Great Lakes..North of Chicago) range from being pretty good guys that yell alot, to real ass-crunchers. With rare exception (if any), the Marine Corps DIs were all hard-ass, hard Corps kinda guys. They pretty much had to be...as it was pointed out...if someone screws up in a hot situation, people usually get hurt or killed, and not just the idiot that screwed up.

As a side note, during boot camp, the two most-often-heard statements are "But my Recruiter said ....." and "When you get out in the REAL Navy (Army, AF, MC, CG)......."

Once you're out of Boot, then life returns to something resembling "Normal."

I like FMJ. I think it was as accurate as any movie can be given the usual time constraints.

FWIW
Scott (HM2, 75-79)


 
Back
Top