i picked up a 2250 around christmas time. i have used hp for over a decade and thought, what the hell, it is cheap. i am definately not disappointed in my decision. with the 2250 "starter" cartridge i have so far printed out ~2500 pages. the print quality @ 600 dpi is equal to hps. i rarely use 1200 as i rarely print out graphics other than line art on it.
it does make some noise, but i woudn't consider it noisy.
for the price you can't beat it and after all the issues with the lower end hp lines like the 1100x series, i switched, and glad i did. a toner cartridge every ~3000+ sheets is not too bad imo.
i would definately buy another one and for the price the 2010 looks good too. also, most toner cartridges run between $50-$70 anyway.