If you are into sports or partying, I think you'd want to go to UF (Or FSU, or UM if you can get a scholarship!). Otherwise, I guess you'd need to figure out what's important to you besides just your major... like campus life, sports, residential living (on or off campus), what's there to do in the area, etc.
I don't know much about UCF or USF, but, they certainly aren't as popular as UF. I went to FAU (Boca Raton) a while back. Not a bad college, but not UF. FAU has grown a lot since I did my time, but they are still mostly off campus students (not a big 'party' atmosphere). Again, That may have changed in the last few years, but, I doubt it.
Anyway, just wanted to let you know there's another State College in the area you may have overlooked.
Good luck.