You and your nostalgia for old games.
i played
Alice when it first came out. i upgraded my PC to play it better. i did not say that it was awful - i said it
"wasn't that great". It is a platformer.
Alice wasn't overall great. It was way too long and the episodes were stretched out to the breaking point.
Alice is ultimately hack and slash. They took the clever idea of the children's toys as weapons and never ran with it. Another BORING shooter that was cleverly wrapped in fantastic art and level design to distract you from the same elements repeated over-and-over.
Madness Returns isn't much different than the original and the graphics are much better. The artwork and level design is a tie - awesome in both games (for their times).