• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

*** American Idol 2009 ***

Page 28 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.
Originally posted by: trmiv
Originally posted by: amdhunter
Originally posted by: dennilfloss
Originally posted by: amdhunter
No, not Alexis. 🙁


How the fuck did Alexis go and Megan stay? Alexis looks better, sings better, has better stage presence...

Now I have only Lil left amongst my favourites...

People were probably turned off by the fact that she had a kid.

So does Megan

Wow, what a whorebag. :|
 
Originally posted by: trmiv
Originally posted by: amdhunter
Originally posted by: dennilfloss
Originally posted by: amdhunter
No, not Alexis. 🙁


How the fuck did Alexis go and Megan stay? Alexis looks better, sings better, has better stage presence...

Now I have only Lil left amongst my favourites...

People were probably turned off by the fact that she had a kid.

So does Megan

This.

Megan has better tits.

And she's different. Perhaps also the flu sympathy.

....but mostly the tits.
 
Originally posted by: freesia39
Originally posted by: SmoochyTX
See ya later Alexis. You're out. The judges didn't want to save you.

Peace out Alexis! Michael, You're next!

I knew they'd be tempted to use the save on her, but it's way too early, and they have Adam to protect.

The GF and I assume they are saving the over-rule for Adam, mostly, as too many dipshits out there are likely to vote off the biggest talent on the show, as always happens. I'd say it's either him or Lil that are most worth saving in such an event.

I think Danny is pretty safe, overall; but they'd probably use it for him as well.
 
Disappointed that Alexis went. I think she was far better than Michael and the freaking blind guy. She was crucified by the judges; while it wasn't an amazing performance, I thought they were too harsh.

This "save" format is really tough: you just found out you're about to go home, judges tease you with the possibility of redeeming yourself, and then you somehow have to sing the same song that everyone hated the night before but this time impress people.

My wife and I are both rooting for Scott to go. I think he's been given a pass because of his condition; his performances aren't even in the same league as the top performers.
 
Originally posted by: zinfamous
Originally posted by: freesia39
Originally posted by: SmoochyTX
See ya later Alexis. You're out. The judges didn't want to save you.

Peace out Alexis! Michael, You're next!

I knew they'd be tempted to use the save on her, but it's way too early, and they have Adam to protect.

The GF and I assume they are saving the over-rule for Adam, mostly, as too many dipshits out there are likely to vote off the biggest talent on the show, as always happens. I'd say it's either him or Lil that are most worth saving in such an event.

I think Danny is pretty safe, overall; but they'd probably use it for him as well.

I think it's more of the voting demographic of this show is probably a bit put off by Adam, and may stop voting for him. This week creeped out a lot of people, but I still love him. He sings circles around everyone.

I figure Danny is safe, because the ones too scared to vote for Adam will vote for Danny.
Lil should make it past the point where the save is no longer allowed. She wasn't that great on country night and still made it into the top 10.

No one else is worth it. Except Allison if she's unfairly booted... but I bet they won't use it on her.
 
Originally posted by: BoomerD
I don't generally watch this show, but the wife had it on tonight while I was eating dinner after class.

WTF is up with Randy Travis? He looks almost as bad as Patrick Swazey...and sounded like shit.
A FAR cry from his hey-day of 20 years ago...

Otherwise, the little girl they voted off tonight...DAM! She was a cutie...I think she may have had a decent voice, but that was a bad song for her.
(haven't watched a single episode all year...don't know how she did with other songs...maybe she NEEDED to be sent home)

heh-heh...looks likd VFTW is up to their usual tricks...

http://votefortheworst.com/
holy crap, did Randy Travis sound awful, and he looks like skeletor. it's a good thing they had Carrie Underwood there singing with him.

Michael should've went. Alexis is better than he is. I thought she was going to go far actually.
 
Does anyone think that someone on this show is a TRUE star, I mean at the same level as some past people like Carrie and Kelly cause I don't think there is someone that good, at least not yet.
 
Originally posted by: WaTaGuMp
Does anyone think that someone on this show is a TRUE star, I mean at the same level as some past people like Carrie and Kelly cause I don't think there is someone that good, at least not yet.

At this early point, I think Allison and perhaps Adam might have something. Adam desperately needs a makeover but I don't see that happening.

Lil has a great voice and might have a shot but she hasn't impressed me very much since the finals began. I'm a big Danny fan and think he has a shot at stardom as well. I want to see more personality from him (and Lil) though.

I believe over these next 3-4 weeks we'll begin to really see a few stand out from the others.
 
I'm just glad that Anoop shut up all the haters for at least a week. He was one of the best performances all night. Alexis had a hoooooorrible start to her song...don't know if it was a bad key for her, monitor issues or what, but just fast-forwarded until the last third.

Next week is Motown - should be another good week for Anoop. Scott will once again be like a fish out of water and Michael will need to bring some of that supposed "soul" or he's in the bottom 3 again.
 
Originally posted by: freesia39
Originally posted by: zinfamous
Originally posted by: freesia39
Originally posted by: SmoochyTX
See ya later Alexis. You're out. The judges didn't want to save you.

Peace out Alexis! Michael, You're next!

I knew they'd be tempted to use the save on her, but it's way too early, and they have Adam to protect.

The GF and I assume they are saving the over-rule for Adam, mostly, as too many dipshits out there are likely to vote off the biggest talent on the show, as always happens. I'd say it's either him or Lil that are most worth saving in such an event.

I think Danny is pretty safe, overall; but they'd probably use it for him as well.

I think it's more of the voting demographic of this show is probably a bit put off by Adam, and may stop voting for him. This week creeped out a lot of people, but I still love him. He sings circles around everyone.

I figure Danny is safe, because the ones too scared to vote for Adam will vote for Danny.
Lil should make it past the point where the save is no longer allowed. She wasn't that great on country night and still made it into the top 10.

No one else is worth it. Except Allison if she's unfairly booted... but I bet they won't use it on her.

Those were my thoughts. I think Allison is great, but when they had her up there last night I was thinking they wouldn't use it to save her.

I still think the top contestants are Adam, Lil, Danny, Allison, and now Matt is kinda growing on me. He has some skills.

I wonder how long the sympathy vote will hold out for Scott? previous two weeks blew.
 
Originally posted by: SmoochyTX
Originally posted by: WaTaGuMp
Does anyone think that someone on this show is a TRUE star, I mean at the same level as some past people like Carrie and Kelly cause I don't think there is someone that good, at least not yet.

At this early point, I think Allison and perhaps Adam might have something. Adam desperately needs a makeover but I don't see that happening.

Lil has a great voice and might have a shot but she hasn't impressed me very much since the finals began. I'm a big Danny fan and think he has a shot at stardom as well. I want to see more personality from him (and Lil) though.

I believe over these next 3-4 weeks we'll begin to really see a few stand out from the others.

totally agree. as far as the typical AI type star--Kelly and Carrie, I'd say Allison has the best shot. Maybe Danny, too. Adam will likely be fronting a band within the next year regardless of what happens, and will probably be successful. Of course, he'll always have a Broadway gig if need-be. Yeah, his look sucks....but whatever.
 
Matt has grown on me as well, zinfamous. My top four was the same as yours, but now it's Lil, Adam, Matt, Danny. I like Allison, but I think she's in trouble next week. I can see Anoop or even Megan moving into her spot.
 
Originally posted by: WaTaGuMp
Does anyone think that someone on this show is a TRUE star, I mean at the same level as some past people like Carrie and Kelly cause I don't think there is someone that good, at least not yet.

Megan can be.

She's like a Macy Gray'ish Nora Jones


People just cant get past the quirkiness.

Hope she wins. Just needs one good live song.

Check out her studio version of Put Your Records On here:

http://www.youtube.com/view_pl...ist?p=72723890F124A5D6
 
Originally posted by: deftron
Originally posted by: WaTaGuMp
Does anyone think that someone on this show is a TRUE star, I mean at the same level as some past people like Carrie and Kelly cause I don't think there is someone that good, at least not yet.

Megan can be.

She's like a Macy Gray'ish Nora Jones


People just cant get past the quirkiness.

Hope she wins. Just needs one good live song.

Check out her studio version of Put Your Records On here:

http://www.youtube.com/view_pl...ist?p=72723890F124A5D6

See, I really like Megan, and that performance was good...but she needs to control her weird pronunciations, which got a little excessive this week.

That, and I'd like to see her actually move around the stage once...I wonder if she moves around just as oddly as she stands and sways 😛
 
Apparently they did studio recordings (audio) of each of the 11 contestants doing the songs they sang on country night. That is what I linked.
 
Originally posted by: deftron
Originally posted by: WaTaGuMp
Does anyone think that someone on this show is a TRUE star, I mean at the same level as some past people like Carrie and Kelly cause I don't think there is someone that good, at least not yet.

Megan can be.

She's like a Macy Gray'ish Nora Jones


People just cant get past the quirkiness.

Hope she wins. Just needs one good live song.

Check out her studio version of Put Your Records On here:

http://www.youtube.com/view_pl...ist?p=72723890F124A5D6

Megan is by FAR the worst contestant left...BY FAR. Horrible and I can't stand her and the only reason they keep her is because she is supposedly "quirky" even though she can't sing a lick.
 
Originally posted by: deftron
Originally posted by: WaTaGuMp
Does anyone think that someone on this show is a TRUE star, I mean at the same level as some past people like Carrie and Kelly cause I don't think there is someone that good, at least not yet.

Megan can be.

She's like a Macy Gray'ish Nora Jones


People just cant get past the quirkiness.

Hope she wins. Just needs one good live song.

Check out her studio version of Put Your Records On here:

http://www.youtube.com/view_pl...ist?p=72723890F124A5D6
I like this song by her

link
 
Originally posted by: deftron
Originally posted by: WaTaGuMp
Does anyone think that someone on this show is a TRUE star, I mean at the same level as some past people like Carrie and Kelly cause I don't think there is someone that good, at least not yet.

Megan can be.

She's like a Macy Gray'ish Nora Jones


People just cant get past the quirkiness.

Hope she wins. Just needs one good live song.

Check out her studio version of Put Your Records On here:

http://www.youtube.com/view_pl...ist?p=72723890F124A5D6

Yep, still sucked.
 
Back
Top