• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

AMD vs. Intel

Page 4 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.
Originally posted by: Bad_Dude
I would think that Intel Northwoods has the advantage over AMD XP b/c of the 512 cache. If I am wrong please explain why?
Thanks.

Amd has 384kb cache on there Xp line of processors (128kb L1, 256kb L2). As for the pentium 4 it has exactly 532kb total cache (20kb L1 512kb L2) so there is a advantage the pentium 4 has with cache size. And the 20kbs of L1 trace cache is very fast and doesnt need to be massive compaired to the L2. With the upcoming prescott with 1042kb cache (20kb L1, 1024kb L2) it will be even more of a performance boost because the cache is a quick way to store small memory that runs at the cpu speed instead of storing it in the system memory, and then fetching it. So cache is a big deal in adding performance, sh!t look at the wonderful 1GHz Itanium 2 with 3MB (3072kb) L3 ondie cache. Most benefits ive seen is in photoshop or other multimedia programs where cache and system memory help a bunch, hope that helps man 😉

SSXeon
 
i have been runnin a 1.8 p4 and soyo p4s dragon motherboard. costs about 250$ today

i just put a xp 1800+ and a refurbed k7s5a and they both have geforce 4 cards.

on default run she almost beat my p4. my p4 was overclocked to 2 gigs. and video was overclocked.

her computer wasnt overclocked 1 bit.

at my computer running 1.8 gig her computer outscores mine at xp1000+ default speeds. and hers cost 100$ compared to my 250$

yes yes yes i know my stuff can overclock nicely...but i dont need it to.

if i had a choice i would trade my p4 for AMD anyday.
 
Just to mention, the P4 has 512KB of cache. It's inclusive caching system means that data in the L1 is written on the L2 as well. It doesn't add up. And it has 8 KB of L1 d-cache and a 12k-entry trace cache which we have no idea how it corresponds with data size so simply adding the two up is insufficient as well.
 
Originally posted by: imgod2u
Just to mention, the P4 has 512KB of cache. It's inclusive caching system means that data in the L1 is written on the L2 as well. It doesn't add up. And it has 8 KB of L1 d-cache and a 12k-entry trace cache which we have no idea how it corresponds with data size so simply adding the two up is insufficient as well.

In the words of Johnny Carson "I did not know that" lol thanx dude for cleaning up my mess 😉

SSXeon
 
Everything else being equal, I would go with AMD because of the possibility of compatibility with the future Barton core. You don't get that with the Intel camp. Not sure if the memory will still be good then, but at least the mobo is rumored to still be useful for Barton. Course, only time will tell if this will come to be.
 
Originally posted by: DivideBYZero
There should be an 'auto-lock' on threads with this Title.....😉
LOL ~ but then wed miss out on all the "comic relief" that finds its way into these threads to cool them down 😉
 
Originally posted by: THUGSROOK
Originally posted by: DivideBYZero
There should be an 'auto-lock' on threads with this Title.....😉
LOL ~ but then wed miss out on all the "comic relief" that finds its way into these threads to cool them down 😉

AMEN TO THAT SIR! ahah yeah anandtech is a chill place and really doesnt get out-of-hand so thease threads dont get to messy 😉 So all is well in the anandtech world 😀

SSXeon
 
Uhhggghh!!! D@mm|t!!!! I did it again! I read thru it again!!! Ugh! 😛
rolleye.gif
😱:disgust:
 
Originally posted by: mike123
Whats with all this AMD and Intel stuff? I'm still getting along fine with my Commodore 64.
LOL, nice! How about your Commodore 64 vs my Casio watch? 😛😀
 
Back
Top