AMD Develops NUC-Like Systems with Partners [XBL]

VirtualLarry

No Lifer
Aug 25, 2001
56,587
10,225
126
Sweet. I would much rather have an AMD APU in a NUC-like box, than an Intel with IGP. Well, I think so. I was slightly disappointed with my E-350 rig(s).
 
Last edited:

aigomorla

CPU, Cases&Cooling Mod PC Gaming Mod Elite Member
Super Moderator
Sep 28, 2005
21,087
3,595
126
No A6-5200? That's annoying.

the point in these boxes are minimal...

The A6 would put too much strain on the board and power supply brick.
Or make the power supply brick just too massive.
 

crashtestdummy

Platinum Member
Feb 18, 2010
2,893
0
0
I'm intrigued. If the Kabini models are priced low enough (say, $150), it might make a really nice streaming/playback-oriented HTPC.
 

aigomorla

CPU, Cases&Cooling Mod PC Gaming Mod Elite Member
Super Moderator
Sep 28, 2005
21,087
3,595
126
it might make a really nice streaming/playback-oriented HTPC.

really?

im thinking people are gonna run around and build hackinstation 4's.... or possibly... hackbox one more so then use it as a HTPC with windows.

:sneaky:
 

tential

Diamond Member
May 13, 2008
7,348
642
121
Gigabyte is working with intel and AMD on these. The intel boxes though are using extremely expensive processors though. I'm not really looking to spend more than $400, built on a box like this. Best used for HTPC type stuff.

The NUC is better IMO than the Gigabyte intel box. I'm sure the AMD based box will be extremely reasonable though. I'll wait for that.
 

cyrusfox

Member
Jun 12, 2010
91
0
66
The A6-5200 is rated at 25W. The original Intel NUC i3 (17W) had thermal problems.

Gygabyte will using APUs up to a maximum of 15W: A4-5000

The intel version is a two chip solution, the i3 (17W) and the panther point chipset (6.3W). Kabini is one chip with all those features. They could easily fit an A6-5200 (25W) in there. Its pretty comparable to the two chip solution.

I just want an itx board, I sure wish they were on the market already, I can buy Haswell, but I am still waiting for kabini, I guess with Sony and Microsoft using up every chip they can for next gen consoles, supply is going to be constrained for a little while.
 

galego

Golden Member
Apr 10, 2013
1,091
0
0
The intel version is a two chip solution, the i3 (17W) and the panther point chipset (6.3W). Kabini is one chip with all those features. They could easily fit an A6-5200 (25W) in there. Its pretty comparable to the two chip solution.

I just want an itx board, I sure wish they were on the market already, I can buy Haswell, but I am still waiting for kabini, I guess with Sony and Microsoft using up every chip they can for next gen consoles, supply is going to be constrained for a little while.

NUC had heat problems with a total of 23W. It seems reasonable Gigabyte is not using a 25W APU.
 

Vesku

Diamond Member
Aug 25, 2005
3,743
28
86
First shown at Computex. It is called BRIX and includes several APUs: A4-5000, E3-3000, E1-2500 and E1-2100

http://www.anandtech.com/show/7011/computex-2013-kabini-in-a-brix-haswell-too

"Clearly the ideal chip in this form factor would be a GT3e/Crystallwell part."

Uh, not based on the TDP of announced GT3e parts. Should have plugged the next version of Atom instead. ;p

I'd be wary of buying a unit like this with anything over a ~15W TDP APU, as has been mentioned Intel's first try at the NUC has heat issues.
 

Abwx

Lifer
Apr 2, 2011
11,896
4,878
136
Continuous dissipation of such boxes is barely 10W ,
hence the lowish power APUs as only acceptable
solution , numbers in the 15-20W range as in the NUCs
are already overkill.
 

galego

Golden Member
Apr 10, 2013
1,091
0
0
"Clearly the ideal chip in this form factor would be a GT3e/Crystallwell part."

Uh, not based on the TDP of announced GT3e parts. Should have plugged the next version of Atom instead. ;p

I'd be wary of buying a unit like this with anything over a ~15W TDP APU, as has been mentioned Intel's first try at the NUC has heat issues.

Yes. As Nvidia claims:

OEMs don’t seem all that impressed with GT3e, as it’s power hungry and expensive. We expect only a tiny number of notebooks will come with GT3e.

If Gigabyte rejected Haswell GT3e for its notebooks how would be using it in something smaller and with poor dissipation capabilities like its new BRICK?


Continuous dissipation of such boxes is barely 10W ,
hence the lowish power APUs as only acceptable
solution , numbers in the 15-20W range as in the NUCs
are already overkill.

I don't know any 15W NUC. Without considering chipset the minimum I know is already rated at 17W. I think NUCs are well over 21W.
 

aigomorla

CPU, Cases&Cooling Mod PC Gaming Mod Elite Member
Super Moderator
Sep 28, 2005
21,087
3,595
126
NUC had heat problems with a total of 23W. It seems reasonable Gigabyte is not using a 25W APU.

no they didnt.

they had a problem with the wifi module heating up after long useage, which caused the mSATA to freeze up.
Intel fixed this by not allowing the fan to ramp lower the 30% even on idle usage with wifi on.

I have a NUC... there great little boxes for HTPC.
I dont have any problems yet minus trying to get h.264 to play correctly due to the 30fps bug that thing has with audio sync.

Anyhow that htpc got replaced to by the zotac ID88.
Screw video card acceleration on H.264 .... the zotac has a 2.8 turbo 3.6 processor which can handle h.264 on the processor itself and not depend on the HD4000.

The case frame on the zotac feels a lot cheapish, however these boxes are VESA mounted behind the TV directly, so no one ever see's them again after install.
 
Last edited:

sm625

Diamond Member
May 6, 2011
8,172
137
106
I hope I can get one for $50 like one of those celeron 847 deals.
 

aigomorla

CPU, Cases&Cooling Mod PC Gaming Mod Elite Member
Super Moderator
Sep 28, 2005
21,087
3,595
126
I hope I can get one for $50 like one of those celeron 847 deals.

a entire system barebone system?

keep dreaming... 50 dollars wont even get u the processor, or the APU unit as a stand alone.

Expect minimum 250... with a top price of arround 400.
NUC's are also going up in price once the haswell refresh comes out.
 

fusion238

Member
Feb 6, 2009
49
0
0
"Clearly the ideal chip in this form factor would be a GT3e/Crystallwell part."

Uh, not based on the TDP of announced GT3e parts. Should have plugged the next version of Atom instead. ;p

I'd be wary of buying a unit like this with anything over a ~15W TDP APU, as has been mentioned Intel's first try at the NUC has heat issues.

Computerbase reviewer indicates Intel Haswell has heat problems:

Our test of the new " Haswell "processors has revealed that under maximum load, extremely high temperatures are reached . While this glaring weakness in the desktop user can still easily conceal, the options are limited for micro PC quickly, like a visit to Gigabyte Computex show.

At an event the day before Computex 2013 on the 36th Floor of Taipei 101 were members of the press not only enjoy the beautiful view of the city, but also examine gigabytes of new products. In addition to countless Haswell motherboards also a micro-PC was issued, in which the latest technology was installed. When trying to take a closer look at the computer, we inevitably came into contact with the model and have reflexively directly let it fall again, so hot was the device. The product manager confirmed thermal problems with the model, but did not want to get carried away with the statement that these are also partly due to the partner Intel.

http://www.computerbase.de/news/2013-06/gigabytes-micro-pc-mit-intels-haswell-cpu-glueht/
 

T_Yamamoto

Lifer
Jul 6, 2011
15,007
795
126
i like how one troll has made 3 of the 4 comments to that post
Well look at his comments, he is clearly stupid
But then Again I have an ancient Intel Sandy Bridge System that is old and slow as heck so if I was in your position I might recommend the same thing. I have An AMD radeon 5570 that doesn't perform anywhere where it should and thus makes MY PC suck!!! I new to buy a new PC ASAP!!!! No really any good suggestion to start me in the right direction?
lol

No i am not an IDIOT just a troll and I like to spice things up. This an AMD fanboi website and I don't like AMD so everyone bashes on me and its lots of fun. Something I noticed about AMD fanbois they don't look into reality they only hope they Think AMD Kaveri is good when it will only have a 30% CPU and 30% GPU improvement. NOT good ENOUGH AMD.

I don't think xbit is a amd fanboy site to be honest.
 

galego

Golden Member
Apr 10, 2013
1,091
0
0
Computerbase reviewer indicates Intel Haswell has heat problems:

Our test of the new " Haswell "processors has revealed that under maximum load, extremely high temperatures are reached . While this glaring weakness in the desktop user can still easily conceal, the options are limited for micro PC quickly, like a visit to Gigabyte Computex show.

At an event the day before Computex 2013 on the 36th Floor of Taipei 101 were members of the press not only enjoy the beautiful view of the city, but also examine gigabytes of new products. In addition to countless Haswell motherboards also a micro-PC was issued, in which the latest technology was installed. When trying to take a closer look at the computer, we inevitably came into contact with the model and have reflexively directly let it fall again, so hot was the device. The product manager confirmed thermal problems with the model, but did not want to get carried away with the statement that these are also partly due to the partner Intel.

http://www.computerbase.de/news/2013-06/gigabytes-micro-pc-mit-intels-haswell-cpu-glueht/

And that space-heater model is not using the power hungry GT3e/Crystallwell. Right?