Originally posted by: fuzzybabybunny
I'd say that this still has a long way to go. While I am extremely, extremely impressed by the look of e-ink, looking EXACTLY like newsprint with that awesome, natural, non-digital look, I can't get over some points:
1. No backlight. Like Kaido said, some kind of soft glowing white backlight would be nice for reading in the dark. You guys remember Indiglo? The light that illuminates monochromatic screens like watches and small DSLR screens and has been around for over a decade? Such a soft glow would not strain the eyes. Hell, they could even try a red backlight to preserve night vision. Something. Anything.
Yes, Indiglo was exactly what I was thinking of! That or some kind of external lighting system around the borders that added light but not glare.
2. Not a big fan of the EVDO plan and its extra charge. I'd be fine just downloading the files from my regular computer and transferring them to the Kindle via USB or something. Probably easier than surfing the web for a book on the Kindle's screen.
They're really pushing the convenience factor with the EVDO plan. For the average non-technical consumer, it's an extra hassle to have to go to your computer, find the book, buy it, sync it with the e-book reader, and then read it. This is exactly why the Sony reader never took off - it's not convenient, and people don't feel that it's important enough, like say music, to put a little effort into learning and doing. The interest for books simply isn't the same for MP3s. Hence iTunes being huge and Sony's E-Reader being something no one has ever heard of.
3. e-book prices suck. It's just asking to be pirated, and then everyone loses except the pirates.
4. Proprietary e-book format and retailer. Enough said.
These two go hand-in-hand. I'd be happier locked into Amazon if their books were WAY cheaper. Also, if they had a non-dumb conversion tool for PDFs, DOCs, etc.
5. It'd be nice if the screen background was white.
Having used the Kindle 1.0 for awhile, I can honestly say I prefer the light gray. I know it sounds weird, but after you stare at black ink on a white page, versus the Kindle's dark gray ink on a light gray page, you'll realize how nice the lesser contrast level is on the Kindle. It's much more comfortable to read on, plus you can adjust font sizes at will.
6. Of course, color. Some things such as graphs would be impossible to read without color, unless you're particularly good at differentiating shades of gray.
I'm curious as to how the future of E-Readers will look. They're already demoing an E-Ink newspaper in Japan, but it's like the size of an entire newspaper page. And completely stiff. When you're reading the newspaper in the morning, it's nice to have a flexible sheet. The Kindle is fine being a hard design because it's small, but they need like flexible plastic e-ink paper or something for larger applications. I'm not really sure what the best way to solve this would be, for large-format print designs like magazines and newspapers. A flexible plastic reader would be weird and a hard plastic reader would also be weird.
I'm very interested in the price complaint as well. People are saying $359 is too much for a device that can store every book you own with lifetime Internet service, and yet they're more than happy to pay $400 for an iPod that simply plays music. CNET already has a story on the price issue:
http://news.cnet.com/8301-1023_3-10159722-93.html
I think that was the first complain of just about everyone I talked to about the Kindle...over $300? Too expensive. People don't feel reading is as much of a priority nowadays, so if Amazon really wants to get the ball rolling, they either need to lower the price of books (not gonna happen, because it's a huge cashcow for publishing houses - zero overhead + nearly the same price as print books) or subsidize it (this makes more sense).
Considering that this new Kindle is second gen and 2 years in coming, I was expecting more.
I agree. I'm glad they did what they did, but...no colors. Still plain-jane white. They took off the rubber backing, which I think was dumb (was nice to have a grippy surface there). No touchscreen, and from what I've read the tracknub is still kind of lame. It's certainly an improvement, but they could have done better. I thinkt the big problem is that Amazon sells books and doesn't make products, so they don't really have the expertise or infrastructure to make a neat design. They should have hired Ive from Apple
