All in one printers?

mlk3454

Senior member
Jan 9, 2003
301
0
0
I am searching for a good printer/scanner/card reader/etc and I am having trouble finding a good comparison article. I am aiming at HP or Epson but I can't seem to find anything to further educate myself before I drop a couple hundred bucks. Any help is appreciated! :D
 

wisdomtooth

Golden Member
Dec 21, 2004
1,155
0
0
I've used two of those HP multifunction printers... A 3100 Laserjet and 1350 inkjet.

Do they print well? Yes.

How's the support? SUCKS. No XP drivers available for the 3100.

How's the software? SUCKS. Both requires you to install HP's resident drivers and monitoring software which makes my system slow as all heck.

HP printers are now banned from my household.

 

mlk3454

Senior member
Jan 9, 2003
301
0
0
thanks for the info, I picked HP since I have heard their printers are pretty good and they have some cheap ink available online
 

akira34

Golden Member
Jun 26, 2004
1,531
0
0
Originally posted by: tranceport
HP for printing.. All the way.

Used to like HP for laser printers. While they are ok when in a corporate environment (when you're buying >$500+ printers) they are not so good in the home/home office type environment. When you go after printers priced in that range (sub $100 printers) they have dropped the ball for a while now. I have had excellent luck with Epson printers over the years. Typically, I would sell my old model in order to upgrade to a newer one (with higher resolution or another feature I wanted). Right now I have an Epson R200 printer that prints everything I could want (for color). It prints directly onto cd/dvd's as well as photographs that are out of this world (thanks to the 6 color printing).

For my black and white documents, I use a Samsung ML-2151N printer. It does full duplex printing (right out of the box) and has a high duty cycle. Plus, you can fit an entire ream of paper into the default tray (the one it ships with). Every other printer I looked at in the same price range couldn't handle over 250 sheets in the tray (input). I was originally looking at HP printers when I was going after a laser printer, but ultimately, the HP models just couldn't offer the same features for even close to the same money (HP was at least $100 more).

All that being said, I am NOT a fan of the multifunction devices. From everything I've seen, they very, very rarely do more than one thing well. Even then, it has issues doing it well on a regular basis. Plus, when one aspect fails, you have to either send it out for repair or junk the entire thing and replace it. With dedicated printers and scanners (can be paired to act as a copier) you can replace either part easily and without incident. I've kept the same scanner for going on 4 years now (it does THAT well) but I've gone through more than a few printers since then. I have one of the wire mesh shelving units that holds my printers, scanner and more. Makes it so that all of that takes up very little floor space (plus I can fit even more things on the shelves). I'd consider that a minor amount of organization to get the most out of the floor space available.

Bottom line, I don't advise anyone that asks to get the multifunction devices. If they have even a moderate amount of space available get individual devices. Maybe at some point in the future the multifunction devices will mature to the level where they can be trusted for the long term. That time is not yet here.
 

mlk3454

Senior member
Jan 9, 2003
301
0
0
I am in a tiny home/office for the rest of this year and the first quarter of next so it has to last until then. I would ideally like to get individual units but dont have the room for it. Another reason I was leaning towards the HP is because their cartriges have the print heads in them so you dont get worn heads or print problems like I did with my lexmark. I know canon heads are not covered under warranty and the epson ones are...does anyone have a link to some good reviews of all-in-ones?
 

beverage

Senior member
Aug 24, 2001
411
0
0
if you go hp, get above that 1200/1300 series. get at least a 5510 ~$180 if you need a flatbed scanner/copier, if not the 4215 ~$150 is a nice choice for an HP sheetfed all in one. The new 7310 ~$400 is also very nice and has been quite popular so far.
 

mlk3454

Senior member
Jan 9, 2003
301
0
0
Thanks for the heads up beverage! I am looking at the HP 2355. Of the ones you selected I would choose the 5510 but the 2355 seems a bit faster and not so bulky. Granted I am tight on space but wont be using it as a fax so no need for that feature.
 

beverage

Senior member
Aug 24, 2001
411
0
0
ok, the 2355 would be a good choice, i didn't know if you would need the fax or not. yeah the 5510 is a bit older, so the speeds are not quite the same