Originally posted by: meehawl
Originally posted by: rastakirk
I am not sure why Apple did not design a metal back affixed by 4 screws, thereby making battery changes much simpler.
I think the lack of easy access to the iPod is by design, and integral to Apple's ability to make such a petite unit. Designing a larger unit would compromise their tight integration... and of course the huge fees charged by iPod service centres for battery removal don't hurt their popularity with retailers either. It's part of Apple's strategy: they achieve extreme compactness by sacrificing features and expandability. The iPod range cost around 50% more than equivalently featured MP3 hard drive players. They have no digital line-in recording, no mic facility, no FM radio reception or broadcast, no wireless interface, no memory card interface, and no easy way for users to replace or upgrade the device's batteries or hard drive. Unlike most of the new generation media players they also feature no MPEG 4 video playback or recording. They have a weird, all-or-nothing metadata approach to storing music that forces you to use the moderately featured iTunes freeware to utilise the iPod to its fullest instead of being able to use some other full-featured, non-freeware media jukebox software. Their battery life is shorter than (AFAIK) all other disk-based HD MP3 players. I gather from the iPod usergroups that the new-gen iPods are getting between 5-8 hours of real-world playtime, and this is with new, fully conditioned batteries.
On the plus side, they do look cute, and fit in most pockets easily. Well done to Apple for figuring that a large proportion of potential MP3 player buyers are not interested in advanced features, and will pay a significant premium for compactness and a simple, constrained interface.
In the 90s, AOL similarly spotted that they could capture a large proportion of online users by offering a simple, integrated system. I think iPods are "training wheel" MP3 players for many people. It remains to be seen whether Apple can manage their new users' experience growth and release more compelling iPods using latest technologies so that these maturing users graduate to more fully-featured iPods and do not desert to other manufacturers' offerings.