• We should now be fully online following an overnight outage. Apologies for any inconvenience, we do not expect there to be any further issues.

Acura TSX within my means to purchase?

Page 4 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

BarneyFife

Diamond Member
Aug 12, 2001
3,875
0
76
I would not spend money that I don't have. Buy a cheap car for now, work 6 months, and see how things are going, and then buy it. What kind of job are you starting at $65k a year? That is some good money... I'm just hoping for mid 40's as an engineer next year.
 

mugs

Lifer
Apr 29, 2003
48,920
46
91
Originally posted by: ones3k
Originally posted by: spidey07
ones3k,

I am trying to relate to you my own experiences. Especially after seeing many of my young friends starting out.

I've posted before on here about how I wished I would have listened to those older and wiser than I. If I would have listened to them I would be a millionaire by age 33. But I didn't.

Do the math. That car is too expensive for you. By every stretch of fiscal responsibility/good decision that car is too expensive for you. You're debt to income ratio is too high. I know that being so young that seems like a lot of money for you, but truth be told - it isn't. That is just your income.

Do the math.

Or don't listen (like I did) and find yourself way behind the curve. It's your choice and I can't tell you what to do. All I can do is tell you it's a bad idea.

The purpose of your money is to make more money for you. Income is just income.

And all this coming from a guy who loves nice cars.

Do the math man. I just wish I would have listened to those older/wiser than I when they told me "spidey, that's too much car for you and you will kick yourself later"

I didn't listen and I'm kicking myself. go figure.

So what should i do with this money i'll be saving by now purchasing the TSX? I'm assuming you think i should invest heavily? How should i invest my funds?

That's a whole other thread man. But since you probably don't know much about investing, your best bet is probably to stick with no-load mutual funds. Let someone much more knowledgeable than you invest your money.
 

spidey07

No Lifer
Aug 4, 2000
65,469
5
76
Originally posted by: ones3k
So what should i do with this money i'll be saving by now purchasing the TSX? I'm assuming you think i should invest heavily? How should i invest my funds?

Make it work for you.

20% year over year is a good thing.

Whatever you do don't put yourself into the cycle of debt as you will be by buying this car. Do the math. Fiscally you are in a bad spot by buying this car, you're debt to income ratio is too high.

repeat after me....
"I do not earn enough nor do I have the wealth to afford a 30K luxury automobile. I now earn a lower middle class wage but yearn for a champagne lifestyle. I don't want to not work when I'm 50."

you're all set.

-edit- quick story...one of my good friends making 60K a year came to me and said "spidey it sounds like a good deal, I can do it" and I said "no you can't, don't do it"

He has his acura and he just filed bankruptcy a few months ago. Good guy, but dumber than a box of bricks.
 

jaedaliu

Platinum Member
Feb 25, 2005
2,670
1
81
Originally posted by: mugs
Originally posted by: ones3k
Originally posted by: spidey07
ones3k,

I am trying to relate to you my own experiences. Especially after seeing many of my young friends starting out.

I've posted before on here about how I wished I would have listened to those older and wiser than I. If I would have listened to them I would be a millionaire by age 33. But I didn't.

Do the math. That car is too expensive for you. By every stretch of fiscal responsibility/good decision that car is too expensive for you. You're debt to income ratio is too high. I know that being so young that seems like a lot of money for you, but truth be told - it isn't. That is just your income.

Do the math.

Or don't listen (like I did) and find yourself way behind the curve. It's your choice and I can't tell you what to do. All I can do is tell you it's a bad idea.

The purpose of your money is to make more money for you. Income is just income.

And all this coming from a guy who loves nice cars.

Do the math man. I just wish I would have listened to those older/wiser than I when they told me "spidey, that's too much car for you and you will kick yourself later"

I didn't listen and I'm kicking myself. go figure.

So what should i do with this money i'll be saving by now purchasing the TSX? I'm assuming you think i should invest heavily? How should i invest my funds?

That's a whole other thread man. But since you probably don't know much about investing, your best bet is probably to stick with no-load mutual funds. Let someone much more knowledgeable than you invest your money.

this is a good idea, but i disagree somewhat. Yes on the no-load mutual funds.

then take a finance course or 3, learn how to read stock charts, learn to understand market cycles, and hope you don't get unlucky with your analysis. Nobody's perfect, and you should make your own decisions with your money (if you have a broker that recomends stocks and gives you advice, make sure that every purchase and sale is still your decision)
 

Reckoner

Lifer
Jun 11, 2004
10,851
1
81
To be honest, asking this question here is not a good way to find the answer.


Only you know your monthly expenses. What you need to do is sit down, and create a budget for yourself. If you have enough disposable income floating around after calculating your expenses, then go for it. If you want a nice car and can afford it, then do it. You only live once. Why wait until you're in your 50s/60s to enjoy life?
 

SouthPaW1227

Golden Member
Aug 4, 2004
1,863
0
0
I'll just give you my opinion:

I'm 21, just outta college, but will be married in August (she's graduating & working as well) and we've purchased our first home (not a fan of renting, personally). I've always been a very frugal person, not spending lots of stuff I don't honestly need.

But I love cars, I absolutely love vehicles in general, and I felt like going for it. I bought a brand new '05 Grand Cherokee Limited loaded to the hilt in Nov. '05 when they were pushing '05s off the lot to make room for '06s and got 14k off the sticker plus $2k over KBB value for my trade-in vehicle, so I went for it. Sure, new cars aren't a smart "financial" decision, but if you make sure your other finances are in order and you're willing to sacrifice video game spending or some other hobby in favor of your vehicle hobby, GO FOR IT!

There's just something about owning and driving a brand new vehicle that nothing else can match; the pleasure you can get from driving that new car really is incredible for vehicle lovers. For those who just see cars as a mode of transport, a new car isn't smart. For someone who loves every mile they drive in a new car, it's a great hobby to spend on.
 

ones3k

Banned
Aug 21, 2005
444
0
0
Originally posted by: spidey07
Originally posted by: ones3k
So what should i do with this money i'll be saving by now purchasing the TSX? I'm assuming you think i should invest heavily? How should i invest my funds?

Make it work for you.

20% year over year is a good thing.

Whatever you do don't put yourself into the cycle of debt as you will be by buying this car. Do the math. Fiscally you are in a bad spot by buying this car, you're debt to income ratio is too high.

repeat after me....
"I do not earn enough nor do I have the wealth to afford a 30K luxury automobile. I now earn a lower middle class wage but yearn for a champagne lifestyle. I don't want to not work when I'm 50."

you're all set.

-edit- quick story...one of my good friends making 60K a year came to me and said "spidey it sounds like a good deal, I can do it" and I said "no you can't, don't do it"

He has his acura and he just filed bankruptcy a few months ago. Good guy, but dumber than a box of bricks.

How is 65k/yr lower middle class for a single person?
 

ones3k

Banned
Aug 21, 2005
444
0
0
Also, how in the world can i earn 20% on my investments consistently? That doesn't seem like a realistic figure.
 

OS

Lifer
Oct 11, 1999
15,581
1
76
Originally posted by: ones3k
Also, how in the word can i earn 20% on my investments consistently? That doesn't seem like a realistic figure.

20% isn't realistic, not even for loan sharks. :p
 

ones3k

Banned
Aug 21, 2005
444
0
0
Anyone know what the distribution of salaries are in the united states? What percentile would 65k/yr fall in?
 

LegendKiller

Lifer
Mar 5, 2001
18,256
68
86
Wow, 20%. Not even Harvard's endowment head could earn 20% net of fees. Perhaps 1-year gains, or maybe as much as 2-3 years, but over 20 years 20% is not going to happen, unless you have access to millions of dollars and are able to get into private equity. Anybody who says otherwise is just blowing smoke.

65k is pretty good money for a 22yr old.
 

DBL

Platinum Member
Mar 23, 2001
2,637
0
0
Originally posted by: LegendKiller
I don't believe you fully appreciate the market we are in. I work in the captial markets, and I do appreciate the situation. Lets run down the past 10 years.

Sure I do, which is why I said it would be a perfect time to start saving for purchase in 2-4 years. If nothing else, it's a much more sound financial decision than wasting money on an entry level luxury car, guaranteed to lose 25-30% of its value after the first year.

1. Housing prices have gone up more than 50%, inflation adjusted, in the past 10 years, according to some of the best financial researchers.

2. The housing market, adjusted for inflation, went up 20% from 1890 to 1995. So, in 1/10th the time, the market appreciated 2.5x as much. That means we have deviated from the mean by a huge amount. What happened to the last deviation from the mean (99/00 anybody?). When it comes down to it, there are two ways you can regress to the mean, stay even or go down. If we stayed even, houses wouldn't appreciate for more than 100 years. So we gotta go down!
I know plenty of people who were bitten in the late 80's and early 90's by the real estate market. Guess how the ones who did not over-leverage themselves are doing today?
My point is that saving for a house/apt as well as maxing 401K matching is a much wiser financial choice than purchasing an entry level luxury car, which was the OP's question.
3. Since 1995, personal debt has more than doubled

4. More than 1 TRILLION dollars of hybrid mortgages are going to become unlocked in the next 3 years. That means that ARMs expire, and IO unlocked. This means that for many people, payments are going to go up 30%+.
Considering recent record low mortgage rates, ARMs were always a significant gamble. However, this could very well help the OP in 3-5 years when he is ready to buy.

5. Once the slowdown starts (it has) people will try to unload overstocked inventory at lower prices (they are now), developers will be left holding the bag (10k's (annual financial statements) from major housing developers show huge cancelled orders and larger inventories). They will then drop the price to get rid of excess inventory (they are doing so now). THis in turn squeezes speculators and investors, as it is happening now.

Since the prices will level off, many people who took IO or ARM mortgages to "squeeze" into their houses, or keep them just for appreciation will be flipped. They will have 2 options, forclosure, or selling for a loss. Once they sell, prices will go down further.
All valid but this applies in no way to the OP current situation, other than to possibly make housing more affordable for him.
The economy has been growing on debt, once the housing market pops, the economy stops growing as much and debt gets called.

If you look at your current area, the price of a place should only be 100-200x monthly rent. So, for my place, that means that it should cost, at most, 300k, my place (which I am renting) costs 475K. According to all analysis, the DC area is overpriced by 37%, which is, ironically, about the amount my placed is overpriced.

Assume that I spend 10k extra than a homeowner and I do so for 3 years (the term of my lease). Within those two years, if my place goes down more than 20k, then I have *SAVED* money. Consider the fact that it might go down 150k, that means I have made 130k over my landlord.
Ouch.

Seems to me that would be the perfect spot for the OP to purchase.
Don't believe me? Warren Buffet spoke of it last weekend. If you don't believe the Oracle of Omaha, and his uber-returns for the last few decades, than you are a loon. Fitch Ratings (It was either them, S&P, or Moody's) released a report that more than 40% of Apartment -> condos will go under in the next 5 years due to poor debt management, poor build quality (they are apartments), and other problems.

The mortgage industry and the realtors have kept pumping housing as the superior investment. Sorry, but it isn't.

People think realty is a safe bet, but it isn't. People think it always goes up, but it doesn't. People think it's a good return, but .3% inflation adjusted sucks, you are much better off going to the diversified market.
We are talking about a place to live, not where to park the rest of your savings for the rest of your life. You post fails to factor this in. IMO, saving to purchase your own place to live rather than rent and to deduct mortgage interest while building equity is one of the best early steps you can take in order to become truly financially independent later in life. I know some people coming up to retirement age who still rent an apartment. It's not an envious position to be in.
save your money. Don't be a miser, but don't be foolish.
Exactly.
 

Gunslinger08

Lifer
Nov 18, 2001
13,234
2
81
Buy it. I'm 22 (21 when I purchased) and I bought a 2006 Mustang GT about 4 months ago. 4 year loan = $700 payment, but it's not really difficult to make when you have no other expenses except for lunch, gas, insurance, and cell phone.
 

DougK62

Diamond Member
Mar 28, 2001
8,035
6
81
Originally posted by: joshsquall
Buy it. I'm 22 (21 when I purchased) and I bought a 2006 Mustang GT about 4 months ago. 4 year loan = $700 payment, but it's not really difficult to make when you have no other expenses except for lunch, gas, insurance, and cell phone.

Ouch. You'll end up hating your choice soon...

 

ones3k

Banned
Aug 21, 2005
444
0
0
Originally posted by: DougK62
Originally posted by: joshsquall
Buy it. I'm 22 (21 when I purchased) and I bought a 2006 Mustang GT about 4 months ago. 4 year loan = $700 payment, but it's not really difficult to make when you have no other expenses except for lunch, gas, insurance, and cell phone.

Ouch. You'll end up hating your choice soon...

But in my case i'll be able to max my 401k, roth, and invest an additional 10k while still paying 500/mo for the TSX. That car will easily last me 10 years.
 

Strk

Lifer
Nov 23, 2003
10,197
4
76
How on earth is $65k a year lower middle class? Unless ones3k has four kids and an ex-wife or two to pay for, he is starting very well for himself. Even in Massachusetts he is making an above average salary (we have one of the highest averages in the country).

I still think you should wait a few months. By the end of summer, you should have over 10k in your bank account. You would also be able to get a last year's model (if you don't want to go used, a last year's model will give you a least a bit better deal). In which case, you'll have a better idea of how well you're doing at your job and how much you like it.
 

iamwiz82

Lifer
Jan 10, 2001
30,772
13
81
Originally posted by: ones3k
Originally posted by: DougK62
Originally posted by: joshsquall
Buy it. I'm 22 (21 when I purchased) and I bought a 2006 Mustang GT about 4 months ago. 4 year loan = $700 payment, but it's not really difficult to make when you have no other expenses except for lunch, gas, insurance, and cell phone.

Ouch. You'll end up hating your choice soon...

But in my case i'll be able to max my 401k, roth, and invest an additional 10k while still paying 500/mo for the TSX. That car will easily last me 10 years.

If you enjoy the car and you want it, then get it. Many people here will tell you that you should live a life of squalor and save every penny you make. I prefer to be in the middle. I max out my 401k and also we spend our money on things we enjoy.

If you can find a happy median between living life for today and for the future, I think you will find the best mix of enjoyment now and later.

 

CrazyDe1

Diamond Member
Dec 18, 2001
3,089
0
0
Just buy a used one. A friend of mine just got a 2004 with 30k miles on it for 22k. It looks and drives brand new...I dont' think too much has changed since then.
 

CrazyDe1

Diamond Member
Dec 18, 2001
3,089
0
0
Originally posted by: LegendKiller
I'll pm you tomorrow. However, if you buy an 18k car as opposed to a 28k car with 5yrs and 7%, you are looking at about 200/mo difference in payments. That will be ~2,600/yr or more in payments and interest.

It may not strap you financially, but it's still a bad decision.

All you gotta do is delay gratification for a few years. Then go and buy a nice car, heck, with the money you have saved and gotten returns on, you can go buy a nice TL.

I have nothing to gain by suggesting you just delay and wait it out for a bit. It's a wise move and something you will *never* regret. If anything, your delay leads to a much better life down the road. However, the flip side of that is that you can end up with plenty of regrets if you buy.

That's great and everything but I don't think you're going to be 30, look at your 401k and be like damn, I coulda had 30k more in here. Especially since he's probably going to be able to max out his 401k and IRA regardless making 65k a year and having 0 obligations. Like yeah, it doesn't make the most financial sense in the world but it's plenty affordable on his salary and I'd rather make good financial descisions while having fun.

If the market turns and he really needs to buy a house you can withdraw your money from an IRA penalty free for a first time home purchase.

Also, the time to enjoy this car is now. You're getting the car not only for transportation, but because it's a great looking car and a kid your age in a car that nice makes a statement. It makes a statement when you go out to the bars, it makes a statement when you take a girl on a date. Yeah, you can delay gratification until you're 30 but then you're now the weird guy at the bar and it doesn't make as much of a statement because there's lots of 30 year olds with nice cars.

My buddy, never fails, whenever we go out and meet new girls he takes his cell phone and his keys out (he drives an A4 1.8T). Inevitably he gets a girls # or a conversation gets started because of a car and they're instantly interested. The conversation then goes "how old are you", wow you bought it in cash at 20? I can't tell how many times he's met a girl and used his car keys as an icebreaker.
 

ones3k

Banned
Aug 21, 2005
444
0
0
Originally posted by: PaulNEPats
Originally posted by: ones3k
What do you guys think about a used TSX for low 20's ?

Why do you like the TSX so much?

best combination of price, reliablity, features, comfort, performance, and gas milage
 

Reckoner

Lifer
Jun 11, 2004
10,851
1
81
Originally posted by: ones3k
Originally posted by: PaulNEPats
Originally posted by: ones3k
What do you guys think about a used TSX for low 20's ?

Why do you like the TSX so much?

best combination of price, reliablity, features, comfort, performance, and gas milage

I disagree, test drive a Legacy GT and then come back and tell me that