Let me describe to you a hypothetical situation. I already had something like that and it is not worth my time.
You buy $39 defective item. These people in newegg are not inspecting that, they are just repeatedly sending that around until somebody complains it is dead. You will spend 3-4 hours of your time trying to figure out what is going on with that crapy motherboard, then another 2-3 hours getting RMA, repacking that and sending back. It will cost you $5-10 to send it back and you'll have to fax that bill to them again to get that money back. That all assuming you don't get charged restocking.
I am talking about the whole day wasted for nothing.
Some people will give up and newegg are counting on that too, that is why they have so many returns.
You will very rarely get a defective item from Staples, Dell, and similar. The percentage of defective items from newegg is much higher.
I purchased many things from Staples, not once I received a defective item!
The question for you - is this worth the hassle?
And this is not the worse possible scenario! You could keep the defective board, perhaps one IDE controller doesn't work and you didn't notice, that is exactly what happened to me. Perhaps some sensor doesn't work, something is broke and you are not aware of that. Board will go off few months from now, destroying something else in the process, and again you waste your time and energy to figure out what it is. Plus the warranty is gone, 30 days, that is.
As you see I had enough of newegg **refurbished**. Industry standard is to have the word refurbished for something that was repaired and reconditioned, defective parts replaced. No so with newegg, these are rejects and returns.