I doubt there is a bigger Trekkie out there than me. I can basically speak along with every next generation episode, and I've read a lot of the extended canon stuff, most of which is terrible but some of which is quite good.
Anyways, I beta tested this mmo, and bought it when it came out just because it was star trek. After a while, I even had to admit to myself how terrible it was. Reskinning an mmo cliché in Federation and Klingon uniforms does not make it good, even for the Trek obsessed. Away missions are repetitive and stupid, ship to ship combat gets old real fast, the whole thing is a hack job looking to cash in on other people old ideas. I wouldn't play it for free.