A hypothetical question about a universal book

phisrow

Golden Member
Sep 6, 2004
1,399
0
0
Say I give to you a book, with the following properties(yes, they seem unrealistic. Don't whine, this is hypothetical.):

The book has a beginning, an end, and can be opened at any point in the middle, as you desire.

The book contains all possible texts, of 1,000 pages or less, written in any western language.

These texts are arranged in a fixed pattern. Any page you open to will always be the same.

There is no index.

Any given page you turn to always contains the text that it ought to according to the book's pattern; but any pages you are not looking at may or may not contain text until you are looking at them(Though it is predetermined what text they will contain when you do look).

Question:

The book contains many texts that have never been written or published elsewhere, it also contains historical descriptions, descriptions of the future, and of future scientific advances. Can the book's author be said to have written these?

Does it matter whether or not the author of the book knew all the languages that the book contains?
 

JSFLY

Golden Member
Mar 24, 2006
1,068
0
0
A chicken lives high in the mountains and studies kungfu with a kung fu master. He has lived for centuries and knows every martial art in the world. He can be considered the most dangerous chicken in the world.

Question:

What color is the chicken's feathers?
 
Aug 23, 2000
15,509
1
81
Originally posted by: JSFLY
A chicken lives high in the mountains and studies kungfu with a kung fu master. He has lived for centuries and knows every martial art in the world. He can be considered the most dangerous chicken in the world.

Question:

What color is the chicken's feathers?

He has none, he's old and they all fell out.
 

JSFLY

Golden Member
Mar 24, 2006
1,068
0
0
Originally posted by: JeffreyLebowski
Originally posted by: JSFLY
A chicken lives high in the mountains and studies kungfu with a kung fu master. He has lived for centuries and knows every martial art in the world. He can be considered the most dangerous chicken in the world.

Question:

What color is the chicken's feathers?

He has none, he's old and they all fell out.


Correct! :beer::cookie:
 

Ramma2

Platinum Member
Jul 29, 2002
2,710
1
0
Originally posted by: phisrow

Question:

Can the book's author be said to have written these?

Does it matter whether or not the author of the book knew all the languages that the book contains?

No. He transcribed them.

No. I can transcribe characters from different languages and not know what they mean.
 

Al Neri

Diamond Member
Jan 12, 2002
5,680
1
81
You're traveling through another dimension, a dimension not only of sight and sound but of mind; a journey into a wondrous land whose boundaries are that of imagination. That's the signpost up ahead---your next stop the Twilight Zone
 

Lonyo

Lifer
Aug 10, 2002
21,938
6
81
You can also have books which contain things not written by the editor.
The name on the spine doesn't always relate to who wrote most of the book. Translations also often have 2 contributors at least, one who translated the text, another who edited or wrote other parts of the book, like the introduction.
 

CKent

Diamond Member
Aug 17, 2005
9,020
0
0
An ATer comes up with a ridiculous hypothetical scenario and rather than dismissing it as the brain fart it is, decides to post about it.

Q: How often does this happen?

A: Every 23 minutes on average
 

FoBoT

No Lifer
Apr 30, 2001
63,084
15
81
fobot.com
Old men and comets have been reverenced for the same reason;
their long beards, and the pretenses to foretell events.