Option 1: (if somebody were getting me a gift, I would go with something similar to this, however, I already ordered what I am about to suggest.)
Go to Cigars International
Buy him one of the 5 packs that comes with a herfador and a lighter
They are $40.
The Bugatti lighter that comes with them is pretty impressive.
If your friend isn't really a cigar smoker, or if you aren't sure what types of cigars he prefers to smoke, I would recommend the Acid Kuba Kubas, they are infused so he will like the taste even if he's not after a cigar/leathery/earthy type taste. They are manly infused cigars though, so, for a guy who enjoys "real" cigars, these are STILL good.
I'm not going to link it here, but, I believe the deal is "El Gordo #42."
Option 2: What is his favorite saw? Get him some extra blades for his circ saw or table saw or whatever. Or oil and new chains for his chainsaw.
Option 3: Drill Bits!