• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

A diet that works, FINALLY

wyvrn

Lifer
I am 35 years old, currently overweight, and had serious health issues. For years my doctor warned me about being pre-diabetic and at major risk of heart attack. I tried everything he suggested, from lowering fat intake to exercising like a mad man.

But my blood work always came back horrible. My cholesterol / HDL ratio was 6, which is really bad. I had triglycerides double and sometimes triple the recommended amount.

I cut out virtually all saturated fats, ate lots of whole grains, fruits, and vegetables, with vegetable oils, and it just got worse and worse.

I ran 3 miles 4-5 times a week. I played sports. I lifted weights. I also yo-yo'd up and down with my weight and would gain anything it took me 2 months to lose back in two weeks if I stopped.

So recently a co-worker of mine turned me on to a very good book, Good Calories, Bad Calories: Fats, Carbs, and the Controversial Science of Diet and Health by Gary Taubes. In addition, I did a massive search of hundreds of articles on nutrition studies which overwhelmingly supported Taubes research. (Note: I ignored any study based upon opinion or any 'quoted' fact that lacked a corresponding supporting scientific study).

After reading the book, I cut carbs by about 80% and sugar by 90%, by my estimate. I ate as much of any kind of meat I wanted, and also green veggies (prevents colon cancer in guys). I cut high sugar fruits such as bananas and grapes, and ate berries instead (higher in antioxidants as well). I avoided starches like potatoes and corn. I shunned bread, and occasionally ate tortillas because I love tacos. I left one day in the week to eat whatever I wanted, within reasonable sizes and calorie limits. I did NOT reduce calories, but increased my total caloric intake by a bit.

The results are:

Total Cholesterol down 8 points
Good Cholesterol up 7 points
Trigycerides cut in half (or third if you consider two years ago I was triple recommended level)
Chol / HDL ratio down to 5 from 6

All of my other blood markers, including glucose, are well in line with recommended levels

I also lost 10 pounds, including the most weight loss over the holiday season, and have kept it off without any exercise other than occasional running, about once per week.

I am no longer considered pre-diabetic or at major risk of heart attack. I am buying new clothes and feel a lot better. I haven't gotten sick a day since I started, and my allergies have actually gotten better as well.

I have only been doing this for a few months, but the transformation is astounding. After 15 YEARS of trying the recommended diet of my doctor (and my wife who is a PA) and not having luck, I am completely shocked at the short term results of this approach.

It goes against everything that conventional medical teaching tells me to do. Yet it has worked like a charm. My wife will not admit that it is a good idea. At first she warned me that my cholesterol would go higher and I would have a heart attack. And she kept getting me to switch to a rice, wheat, and chicken diet 🙂 Thankfully, however, I stuck with this and got the results. Her response to my blood work was "Hmm...." and nothing else. I haven't talked to my doctor yet, but it should be an interesting conversation.

I know these type of diets have been discussed before, and there is likely to be a lot of argument on this topic. However, I just wanted to point out that I did a shit ton of research on the topic and found no solid SCIENTIFIC refutation for it. I just found lots of opinions, politics, and money trails leading to the grain and vegetable companies.

Whats up next? I am cutting all vegetable oils, including Olive oil, and using coconut and palm oils in my home-cooked food instead. I am also switching off of cows milk, and gonna drink mostly water with some coconut milk to the medium chain fatty acids.

If anyone requests, I will post images of my blood work for proof. I can't prove the weight loss so you will just have to take my word on it.

Cliffs:

-Health sucks, doc says I am gonna die soon
-Dropped carbs and sugars
-Ate as much meat as I wanted
-Veggies? Who cares! Just ate occasional green one
-Dropped 10 pounds
-Blood work came back really good, I am now healthy
 
From the cliffs, it sounds like atkins. Have you calculated your maintenance caloric intake? Eat balanced and you won't be back with a thread about not being able to feel your arm.
 
Calorie counting and exercise work so long as you modify them to match your actual progress and don't just rip a page out of a diet book to follow.

That said, I'm glad you found success using the diet you're on.
 
isn't that just a modified Atkins diet?

I ran across Dr. Atkins research. If you want to label it that, then go ahead. But for the record, he is one of hundreds of doctors worldwide who come up with the same results in their research. I didn't just jump on a Dr. Atkins or any other diet plan, on purpose. I just went straight to the actual medical research and based my diet on those findings.
 
Atkins FTW. It's the only thing that works for me. I love it. The more fat you eat, the more you lose. It's counterintuitive..but if you follow the diet correctly (NO violations on carb limits), it is completely true.
 
Calorie counting and exercise work so long as you modify them to match your actual progress and don't just rip a page out of a diet book to follow.

That said, I'm glad you found success using the diet you're on.

You didn't read what I wrote. I didn't take a page from any diet book. I read just about every diet and nutrition study produced in the past century.
 
dropping the sugars is probably what dropped your weight, and your pre-diabetic. Everything else is mostly coincidental.

You would have probably gotten similar results from eating nothing but rice.

*edit* Edited for the ass clown that is stalking me.
 
Last edited:
Holy shit man, it took you that long and a book to realize dropping all those carb rich crap like breads and sugars would help?

I mean seriously, if you're a guy, drink skim milk, eat something that doesn't involve mostly carbs, get a salad once in a while, keep your protein up with lean meats, fish etc, and go work your ass off at the gym. It really is not rocket science.

P.S. - Eating all those whole grains and fruits are hilarious. What did you think was in them, besides huge amounts of sugar, calories, and energy?
 
wrong forum.

and that is a horrible diet for a temporary solution, good luck!

Thanks!

It's not a temporary solution, but a life change. A lot of people think I am crazy, but when I quiz them on it, they cannot refute my approach with actual science. They just say it's supposed to be bad for you without having done their own research. Because I am basing my lifestyle change on the best scientific research and not opinion, I tend to ignore those comments.
 
Thanks!

It's not a temporary solution, but a life change. A lot of people think I am crazy, but when I quiz them on it, they cannot refute my approach with actual science. They just say it's supposed to be bad for you without having done their own research. Because I am basing my lifestyle change on the best scientific research and not opinion, I tend to ignore those comments.

You should ignore them. The official government food pyramid is insane. People have been trying to follow it for decades and they are FATTER TODAY THAN THEY HAVE EVER BEEN. This should tell you something about conventional wisdom.
 
Holy shit man, it took you that long and a book to realize dropping all those carb rich crap like breads and sugars would help?

I mean seriously, if you're a guy, drink skim milk, eat something that doesn't involve mostly carbs, get a salad once in a while, keep your protein up with lean meats, fish etc, and go work your ass off at the gym. It really is not rocket science.

P.S. - Eating all those whole grains and fruits are hilarious. What did you think was in them, besides huge amounts of sugar, calories, and energy?

Disagree on several points. First, cows milk is not good for you in any incarnation. Drink something with medium chain fatty acids, such as coconut milk, if you must. The body burns those off faster than the long chain fatty acids found in cows milk.

I did the lean meat thing, and had disastrous results. I started eating saturated fat, and the proof is in the pudding, as they say. Hint: find a proven scientific study that links intake of saturated fat with blood cholesterol levels and incidence of heart attack. Good luck!

I won't disagree that exercise is healthy, just that it was not required for me to get the results that I did. Exercise by itself did nothing for me when I was on my previous diet, which flatly did not work. I would have died early no matter how much I worked out.

Calories in does not equal calories out. The body has different metabolic pathways for different foods. Note I increased slightly my caloric intake, not decresed it.
 
Disagree on several points. First, cows milk is not good for you in any incarnation. Drink something with medium chain fatty acids, such as coconut milk, if you must. The body burns those off faster than the long chain fatty acids found in cows milk.

I did the lean meat thing, and had disastrous results. I started eating saturated fat, and the proof is in the pudding, as they say. Hint: find a proven scientific study that links intake of saturated fat with blood cholesterol levels and incidence of heart attack. Good luck!

I won't disagree that exercise is healthy, just that it was not required for me to get the results that I did. Exercise by itself did nothing for me when I was on my previous diet, which flatly did not work. I would have died early no matter how much I worked out.

Calories in does not equal calories out. The body has different metabolic pathways for different foods. Note I increased slightly my caloric intake, not decresed it.

There's no fucking FAT in skim milk! Protein, Calcium, & Vitamin - D, ALL critical components to fat loss.
 
I'm really thinking this won't last. Especially with minimal exercise.

Dropping the sugars alone will yield a tremendous loss in weight, but eventually it'll just stop. It's a known fact that you need to be at a caloric deficit to lose weight. If you're consuming more calories than you're burning, you'll start putting the weight back on.

These weird diets confuse me. Just eat unprocessed foods, drink lots of water, eat your veggies, eat your fruit (berries are certainly great in this case), eat meat (chicken is great, fish is great, any lean meat, really). You'll lose weight, and you won't feel tired as shit.
 
Thanks!

It's not a temporary solution, but a life change. A lot of people think I am crazy, but when I quiz them on it, they cannot refute my approach with actual science. They just say it's supposed to be bad for you without having done their own research. Because I am basing my lifestyle change on the best scientific research and not opinion, I tend to ignore those comments.

http://www.cnn.com/2009/HEALTH/03/23/healthmag.red.meat.lifespan/index.html
http://www.forbes.com/2009/03/24/eating-red-meat-lifestyle-health-red-meat-study.html
http://archinte.ama-assn.org/cgi/content/abstract/169/6/562

Again, cutting the sugars is most likely what caused your to lose weight. Eating meat doesn't contribute to weight, but it does contribute to a lot of other things (too much IS bad for you)
 
Thanks!

It's not a temporary solution, but a life change. A lot of people think I am crazy, but when I quiz them on it, they cannot refute my approach with actual science. They just say it's supposed to be bad for you without having done their own research. Because I am basing my lifestyle change on the best scientific research and not opinion, I tend to ignore those comments.

Yeah it can be backed up... although it means you weren't eatting that well at all to begin with. What everyone says definately has merit though. Don't overindulge and eat crap. Eat some healthy fats such as nuts... they offer great fat content with no cholesterol. Eat some complex carbs and a shitload of lean meat if you need.
 
You should ignore them. The official government food pyramid is insane. People have been trying to follow it for decades and they are FATTER TODAY THAN THEY HAVE EVER BEEN. This should tell you something about conventional wisdom.

You are right. It has been proven in many studies that incidence in the US of obesity, Type II diabetes, and heart attack have risen with the food pyramid diet. This also translates to other countries who adopt our western diet, and have disastrous long term results.

One of the causes for this was Ansel Keys, low fat diet biggest proponent. His research in the 60s, highly controversial at the time, has since been proven wrong. He tried to do a multivariate study without a computer, and messed up quite badly. However, our current national diet recommendations are based largely on his flawed research.
 
There's no fucking FAT in skim milk! Protein, Calcium, & Vitamin - D, ALL critical components to fat loss.

WTF? is the OP serious? I thought he actually did research based on his two first posts... milk is bad.....
 
I am completely shocked at the short term results of this approach.

That sentence was in your post. Unfortunately, unless you are ridiculously disciplined, and supplement appropriately, this is not a viable long-term dietary solution. I'm glad you're seeing some positive results, but I'd talk to a dietician about something more sustainable going forwards.

Good luck!
 
dropping the sugars is probably what dropped your weight, and your pre-dietetics. Everything else is mostly coincidental.

You would have probably gotten similar results from eating nothing but rice.

mr. anti-education... what are pre-dietetics?
 
Back
Top