A Couple Questions for my friend's build

cakes

Junior Member
Jan 21, 2006
12
0
0
My friend has 3K and wants to get a very nice computer, I told him that he can have top of the line which is basically true. This is what I have decided on so far and nothing is final so all suggestions are appreciated, thank you.

So my questions are how does the cooling look and can somone recommend me good 5.1 headphones? How does the build look in general? What is a good brand for optical drives?

Opteron 175
DFI LanParty Ultra-D
2GB G Skill HX
X-FI Extreme Music
Lian Li Case
eVGA 7800GTX
PCP&P 510w
Viewsonic VX922
(2) WD 250GB 16mb Cache

G5 mouse
Saitek Eclipse
SteelPad S&S
Thermaltake Hardcano 13
Logitech Z-5500

Cooling:

Thermaltake Big Typhoon
Zalman VF-700LED
Arctic Silver 5



Thank you in advance!
 

Bobthelost

Diamond Member
Dec 1, 2005
4,360
0
0
What is the machine for, if it's gaming then the graphics card looks pretty weak to me. Also for sheer speed a Raptor 150 is hard to beat.

Good optical brands are BenQ, NEC and liteon. BenQ are pretty much the best at the moment, but the difference is tiny.

See if he can't wait till the new range of GPUs are out.
 

cakes

Junior Member
Jan 21, 2006
12
0
0
Yes, the build if for gaming. The 7800GTX looks weak?

Doesn't the 7900 series come out in 3 months? When are they due?
 

Bobthelost

Diamond Member
Dec 1, 2005
4,360
0
0
Unless you're thinking of the mythical 512 version, yes.

I don't know when they are due out, but i suspect much sooner than that, check out the video forum.
 

navecko

Junior Member
Dec 15, 2005
16
0
0
um if he has $3000 and it's a gaming rig then you definately want sli. two 7800gt's @ $560 or two gtx's @ $900. also why not an a8n32-sli so you get 2x16x sli instead of 2x8. psu looks good. two 150 gb raptors would be faster unless you need 500gb.
 

TraumaRN

Diamond Member
Jun 5, 2005
6,893
63
91
All things considered only the X1800XT and X1900XTX are faster video cards....so I dont think it's 'weak' on the video card....what games will he be playing mostly?
 

hurtstotalktoyou

Platinum Member
Mar 24, 2005
2,055
9
81
I haven't checked prices in a while, so they may be slightly off. Not much, though.

$400 a nice 17" or 19" LCD display
$352 Opteron 165
$300 eVGA 7800GT
$216 two Raptor-150s in RAID 0
$152 2GB dual PC3200
$108 Epox EP-9NPA+ Ultra
$100 any M-Audio card
$97 HP Scanjet 4370
$93 Windows XP Home OEM
$89 Antec NEOHE 430
$60 any decent ATX case
$59 ADS Instant TV FM tuner/capture
$50 any decent stereo speakers
$49 HP Deskjet 3745
$20 wireless keyboard
$20 wireless mouse

$2165 total

There's no need to spend $3K on a home build. The above system is close enough top of the line.
 

TraumaRN

Diamond Member
Jun 5, 2005
6,893
63
91
Well then navecko made a good point, SLI two 7800GTs that'll sustain him....yes people will say wait for new cards but for bang for buck the two GT's for 600 bucks....when you figure ONE X1900XTX will cost that....is a hell of a deal.
 

cakes

Junior Member
Jan 21, 2006
12
0
0
I would rather pay an extra $100 and get the 512MB 7800GTX rather than another motherboard and 2 7800GTs, I am almost positive the GTX would perform better.

I was under the impression that the DFI Ultra-D is the best overclocking board out there. I do think the Raptors are a good idea though and I will look into them, the problem is, I don't know how to do RAID 0.
 

TraumaRN

Diamond Member
Jun 5, 2005
6,893
63
91
Originally posted by: cakes
I would rather pay an extra $100 and get the 512MB 7800GTX rather than another motherboard and 2 7800GTs, I am almost positive the GTX would perform better.

I was under the impression that the DFI Ultra-D is the best overclocking board out there. I do think the Raptors are a good idea though and I will look into them, the problem is, I don't know how to do RAID 0.

Good luck actually finding a 512 GTX

EDIT: My Epox board will OC stable up to 310HTT
 

cakes

Junior Member
Jan 21, 2006
12
0
0
True, but SLI doesn't show that much of an improvement so I would rather go with one card.

Is it hard to RAID 0 two hard drives?
 

hurtstotalktoyou

Platinum Member
Mar 24, 2005
2,055
9
81
Originally posted by: cakes
I would rather pay an extra $100 and get the 512MB 7800GTX rather than another motherboard and 2 7800GTs, I am almost positive the GTX would perform better.

I do believe you're right. One GTX would be better.

I was under the impression that the DFI Ultra-D is the best overclocking board out there.

It's tough to say. DFI, Epox and Asus are all great choices, and offer up near identical performance. Depending on the features you need, Epox or Asus usually offer the best bang for your buck.

This is sort of how it works:

extreme budget build (integrated video or PCIe x16): Biostar GeForce 6100-M9 $64
budget build (integrated video or PCIe x16): Biostar TForce 6100-939 $75
mid-range build, minimal features (PCIe x16): Epox EP-9NPAJ $73
mid-range or high-end build, more features (PCIe x16): Epox EP-9NPA+ Ultra $108
mid-range or high-end build, with SLI (2 PCIe x16): Asus A8N SLI $125

I do think the Raptors are a good idea though and I will look into them, the problem is, I don't know how to do RAID 0.

I don't know, either, but I'm sure you could figure it out with a manual.
 

cakes

Junior Member
Jan 21, 2006
12
0
0
I've heard ASUS boards are buggy. I've heard some good things about the A8N32 though...Haven't heard much on Epox at all. At my other forum everyone raves about the DFI LanParty and MSI Neo4 Plat
 

TraumaRN

Diamond Member
Jun 5, 2005
6,893
63
91
Epox boards are quite good, especially the board that I have and their SLI board, they do/did have an issue with connecting external HDDs and transferring large data amounts but other I've had only one problem with it, my first board came DOA, apparently it was Epox's fault that they let a few bad boards slip but the issue was fixed. my second and current board which I'm running now and as I've said no problems at all, has good OCing options in BIOS etc etc...and the diagnostic LED is the sh!t especially when you get an unstable OC you know before windows even boots most of the time :)
 

cakes

Junior Member
Jan 21, 2006
12
0
0
Okay, I'll research some motherboards.

Back to my original questions though, what's some good 5.1 headphones and how does the cooling look?
 

hurtstotalktoyou

Platinum Member
Mar 24, 2005
2,055
9
81
Originally posted by: cakes
I've heard ASUS boards are buggy. I've heard some good things about the A8N32 though...Haven't heard much on Epox at all. At my other forum everyone raves about the DFI LanParty and MSI Neo4 Plat

All boards have issues. Bugs, compatibility, DOA rates, etc. Epox, Asus, DFI, MSI, Biostar--these are all trusted names, and enjoy similar reliability. Is one brand more reliable than another? Sure, but since that can't be accurately quantified, you can't very well determine which is best.

DFI has strict PSU requirements. If you do choose that board (which is great, by the way--although personally I wouldn't spend any more than I had to) make sure your PSU will work with it.
 

navecko

Junior Member
Dec 15, 2005
16
0
0
Originally posted by: cakes
I would rather pay an extra $100 and get the 512MB 7800GTX rather than another motherboard and 2 7800GTs, I am almost positive the GTX would perform better.
Hmm. Assuming you can find a 512mb gtx I would still recomend 2 gt's in sli. If you must have the 512 gtx wait til march 9th when G71 comes out on 90nano with 32 pipes doing 700mhz core and 2ghz memory.

1 512 gtx has 24 pipes and 8 shaders @ 580mhz/1800mhz for $750 newegg
2 gt's have 40 pipies and 14 shaders @ 470mhz/1200mhz for $560 newegg

Originally posted by: cakes
True, but SLI doesn't show that much of an improvement so I would rather go with one card.
~80% with bridge and 2*16x
I have the a8n32-sli mobo and it is rock solid [8 phase power]. There are so many overclocking options in the bios. Can tweak vcore by .125 and fsb by 1mhz. And memory options that I have yet to research. Oh and 512mb of vid ram seems nice on paper but the benchmarks say that it doesn't help much right now [well I guess it would with fear @ 2048x1536 4xAA].
 

BOLt

Diamond Member
Dec 11, 2004
7,380
0
0
Originally posted by: cakes
My friend has 3K and wants to get a very nice computer, I told him that he can have top of the line which is basically true. This is what I have decided on so far and nothing is final so all suggestions are appreciated, thank you.

So my questions are how does the cooling look and can somone recommend me good 5.1 headphones? How does the build look in general? What is a good brand for optical drives?

Opteron 175
DFI LanParty Ultra-D
2GB G Skill HX
X-FI Extreme Music
Lian Li Case
eVGA 7800GTX
PCP&P 510w
Viewsonic VX922
(2) WD 250GB 16mb Cache

G5 mouse
Saitek Eclipse
SteelPad S&S
Thermaltake Hardcano 13
Logitech Z-5500

Cooling:

Thermaltake Big Typhoon
Zalman VF-700LED
Arctic Silver 5



Thank you in advance!

Looks great. Go for it!
 

i1o0i

Senior member
May 20, 2005
262
0
0
Opteron 175
DFI LanParty Ultra-D
2GB G Skill HX
X-FI Extreme Music
Lian Li Case
7800GTX 512mb
OCZ 520watts power supply
Viewsonic VX922
Raptor 150gb

G5 mouse
Saitek Eclipse
SteelPad S&S <- dont need such expensive mouse pad :laugh:
Thermaltake Hardcano 13 <- its nice but does your friend need it?
Logitech Z-5500

Cooling:

Thermaltake Big Typhoon
Zalman VF-700LED
Arctic Silver 5

fixed. :D
 

mwmorph

Diamond Member
Dec 27, 2004
8,877
1
81
Originally posted by: cakes
My friend has 3K and wants to get a very nice computer, I told him that he can have top of the line which is basically true. This is what I have decided on so far and nothing is final so all suggestions are appreciated, thank you.

So my questions are how does the cooling look and can somone recommend me good 5.1 headphones? How does the build look in general? What is a good brand for optical drives?

Opteron 165(looks like you'll be ocing.) if you arent ocing, just go regualt amd64 x2.
ASUS A8N Sli(regualr version)
2GB Corsair value ram(2x1gb)
X-FI Extreme Music(ehh, whatever)
Antec Sonata 2
eVGA 7800GTX SLI(will prbably cost less) or X1900xt Crossfire(faster)
PCP&P 510w is too weak for slied or crossfire andso many drives and accessories, go for this
Dell 2405FPW
(2) WD 250GB 16mb Cache

G5 mouse
Saitek Eclipse
SteelPad S&S
Thermaltake Hardcano 13
Logitech Z-5500

Cooling:

ZALMAN CNPS7700-CU 120mm(quieter and cools basically just as well.
Zalman VF-700(LED is stupid, worthless, decreases reliability[yet another part ot burn out] and uses some electricity])
Arctic Ceramique(not as deadly to electric components as silve, better for newer builders, no removal issues like silver.



Thank you in advance!
fixed

weak build.
x1900xtx comes out on tuesday.
performance ram is worthless

a gtx512 is worthlessly overpriced. a 780gt sli system will cost less and be faster, a 7800gtx 256 sli system will cost about as much and be much faster.
 

cakes

Junior Member
Jan 21, 2006
12
0
0

Originally posted by: cakes
True, but SLI doesn't show that much of an improvement so I would rather go with one card.
~80% with bridge and 2*16x
I have the a8n32-sli mobo and it is rock solid [8 phase power]. There are so many overclocking options in the bios. Can tweak vcore by .125 and fsb by 1mhz. And memory options that I have yet to research. Oh and 512mb of vid ram seems nice on paper but the benchmarks say that it doesn't help much right now [well I guess it would with fear @ 2048x1536 4xAA].[/quote]

nvidia says it is an 80% increase but it really isn't that much at all. 512MB Ram can be used for DOOM3 and probably most of the newer games coming out.

It is looking like I might wait until they introduce the G71.




Originally posted by: i1o0i
Opteron 175
DFI LanParty Ultra-D
2GB G Skill HX
X-FI Extreme Music
Lian Li Case
7800GTX 512mb
OCZ 520watts power supply
Viewsonic VX922
Raptor 150gb

G5 mouse
Saitek Eclipse
SteelPad S&S <- dont need such expensive mouse pad :laugh:
Thermaltake Hardcano 13 <- its nice but does your friend need it?
Logitech Z-5500

Cooling:

Thermaltake Big Typhoon
Zalman VF-700LED
Arctic Silver 5

fixed. :D

PCP&P are the best PSU suppliers, why did you change that?

Everything else looks fine that you change.




Originally posted by: mwmorph
Originally posted by: cakes
My friend has 3K and wants to get a very nice computer, I told him that he can have top of the line which is basically true. This is what I have decided on so far and nothing is final so all suggestions are appreciated, thank you.

So my questions are how does the cooling look and can somone recommend me good 5.1 headphones? How does the build look in general? What is a good brand for optical drives?

Opteron 165(looks like you'll be ocing.) if you arent ocing, just go regualt amd64 x2.
ASUS A8N Sli(regualr version)
2GB Corsair value ram(2x1gb)
X-FI Extreme Music(ehh, whatever)
Antec Sonata 2
eVGA 7800GTX SLI(will prbably cost less) or X1900xt Crossfire(faster)
PCP&P 510w is too weak for slied or crossfire andso many drives and accessories, go for this
Dell 2405FPW
(2) WD 250GB 16mb Cache

G5 mouse
Saitek Eclipse
SteelPad S&S
Thermaltake Hardcano 13
Logitech Z-5500

Cooling:

ZALMAN CNPS7700-CU 120mm(quieter and cools basically just as well.
Zalman VF-700(LED is stupid, worthless, decreases reliability[yet another part ot burn out] and uses some electricity])
Arctic Ceramique(not as deadly to electric components as silve, better for newer builders, no removal issues like silver.



Thank you in advance!
fixed

weak build.
x1900xtx comes out on tuesday.
performance ram is worthless

a gtx512 is worthlessly overpriced. a 780gt sli system will cost less and be faster, a 7800gtx 256 sli system will cost about as much and be much faster.

Corsair VALUE? No, We want to OC, and won't I have to use a memory divider if I get VALUE.

ASUS boards are known to be buggy, why not get the best overclocking board out there? The DFI Ultra-D or Expert?

Can you tell me what the response time and contrast ratio is on that monitor?

I will look into that Zalman but I've heard the Big Typhoon is the best.

Thanks for the info on the X1900XT.
 

mwmorph

Diamond Member
Dec 27, 2004
8,877
1
81
[/quote]
nvidia says it is an 80% increase but it really isn't that much at all. 512MB Ram can be used for DOOM3 and probably most of the newer games coming out.

It is looking like I might wait until they introduce the G71.[/quote]

SLI and Crossfire does help a lot
see here
http://www.guru3d.com/article/content/231/5/
here
http://www.driverheaven.net/reviews/X18Crossfire/hl2.htm

Sli is generally more mature and slightly faster but once some higher aa levels(like 8x and 14/16x) are turned up, crossfire leads by a lot.
http://www.firingsquad.com/hardware/ati_super_aa_vs_nvidia_sli_aa/

also, once you turn up the settings to high, which you will do(you wont be playing low quality settings and teextures on that monster rig will you?) 1gb and 2gb help a lot.
also, you want to have enough for the future, There are already some games that need 2gb to run well now like BF2. The numbers dont look that bad, bbut remember, a 60fps verssu a 50fps difference means that both systems ran at around a usualy 60fps but the lower rram system dropped framerates lower and for longer periods than the higher ram system so both will have relativel the same fps but the smoothness of play on the lower ram will suffer incredibly. Hitching on high settnigs is horrible unless you have at least 1.5gb of ram on battlefield 2.

http://www.tomshardware.com/2005/12/13/...much_ram_do_you_really_need/page4.html

Conclusion

The bottom line is that there is not just one single answer to the question of how much system memory you need. However, to help you decide for yourself, we put together the following criteria:
512 MB

There are a few situations where having just 512 MB system memory in your computer can be enough.

* If you run your games at low quality settings (small texture size) because you have an outdated CPU and graphics card, or because you prefer FPS over visual quality.
* If you only use one application at a time.
* If it is your grandmother's computer.

If you are buying a new computer, even if it's a laptop, opt for more than 512 MB - you will never regret it.
1 GB

Indeed, 1 GB of system memory will most likely be enough for the average user and for people.

* It will allow you to play new games at their highest quality settings, given that you have an adequate processor and a powerful graphics solution.
* You won't have to shut down non-critical applications when you want to play a game.
* You can (accidentally) press the Windows button while in a game without dying from a stroke during the seconds it takes to read Windows back into system memory from the swap file.
* If you go from 512 MB to 1 GB, you will notice the difference all the time. Starting up Photoshop while working with Word, an Internet browser, e-mail client and Acrobat Reader will go so much faster, and switching between the applications is a breeze.

2 GB

Still there are situations where more than 1 GB is what you want.

* If you are a professional user, you might need more than 1 GB for really heavy applications.
* If you intend to do heavy multitasking, especially if you have more than one CPU or CPU core. Running RAM intensive games such as World of Warcraft, downloading files via high speed FTP or encrypted protocols, Bittorrent or any P2P program; decompressing large archives and playing large size video files in a window or on second monitor all at the same time can max out your system memory pretty fast - if your CPU can handle it.

PCP&P are the best PSU suppliers, why did you change that?

Everything else looks fine that you change.

PC&P will not hold up all those components, i recommend the fsp 700w. you need more amps and the fsp delivers 60a over 4 12v rails. The 850 is horribly overpriced and the 510 isnt powerful enough.



Originally posted by: mwmorph
Originally posted by: cakes
My friend has 3K and wants to get a very nice computer, I told him that he can have top of the line which is basically true. This is what I have decided on so far and nothing is final so all suggestions are appreciated, thank you.

So my questions are how does the cooling look and can somone recommend me good 5.1 headphones? How does the build look in general? What is a good brand for optical drives?

Opteron 165(looks like you'll be ocing.) if you arent ocing, just go regualt amd64 x2.
ASUS A8N Sli(regualr version)
2GB Corsair value ram(2x1gb)
X-FI Extreme Music(ehh, whatever)
Antec Sonata 2
eVGA 7800GTX SLI(will prbably cost less) or X1900xt Crossfire(faster)
PCP&P 510w is too weak for slied or crossfire andso many drives and accessories, go for this
Dell 2405FPW
(2) WD 250GB 16mb Cache

G5 mouse
Saitek Eclipse
SteelPad S&S
Thermaltake Hardcano 13
Logitech Z-5500

Cooling:

ZALMAN CNPS7700-CU 120mm(quieter and cools basically just as well.
Zalman VF-700(LED is stupid, worthless, decreases reliability[yet another part ot burn out] and uses some electricity])
Arctic Ceramique(not as deadly to electric components as silve, better for newer builders, no removal issues like silver.



Thank you in advance!
fixed

weak build.
x1900xtx comes out on tuesday.
performance ram is worthless

a gtx512 is worthlessly overpriced. a 780gt sli system will cost less and be faster, a 7800gtx 256 sli system will cost about as much and be much faster.

Corsair VALUE? No, We want to OC, and won't I have to use a memory divider if I get VALUE.

ASUS boards are known to be buggy, why not get the best overclocking board out there? The DFI Ultra-D or Expert?

Can you tell me what the response time and contrast ratio is on that monitor?

I will look into that Zalman but I've heard the Big Typhoon is the best.

Thanks for the info on the X1900XT.[/quote]


alright, yes you will ahve ot use a divider but performance difference will be very low. it is much better to save money on ram and use it on a video card since the perfoamance gain with a video card will be exponentially higher per dollar than a ram upgrade. Async ram is fine. A amd64 cares not for latencies or speed very much( the difference between cas3 pc3200 value and cas 2 pc 4000 is usuall below 5% in most games.

obviosuly you'vew been misinformed on the asus board.
http://anandtech.com/mb/showdoc.aspx?i=2661

specificalyl read this:
http://anandtech.com/mb/showdoc.aspx?i=2661&p=4

We were able to overclock the fsb to 340 at the 9x multiplier, which resulted in CPU operation of 3066MHz, but we had to reduce the memory ratios to reach this level. The test system was able to boot into Windows at a setting of 350fsb x 9, but was not stable enough to complete our testing. At the settings listed, our test system was able to complete the entire benchmark suite three times without any reported issues.

and here
http://anandtech.com/mb/showdoc.aspx?i=2661&p=13

While the Asus A8N-SLI Premium did overclock better than the Albatron board in the stock multiplier section, it required relaxed memory timings. However, in internal testing, the Asus still performed better than the other two boards in the PCMark and game benchmarks, leading us to believe that the BIOS optimizations are significantly better on this board.

notice the graph for stock multiplier where the asus a8n sli got 255x12 while the DFI can olny achieve 238x12. The asus is better for overclocking period. The memory latency issues is minimal because the on die memory controller dosent care about memory speeds and latencies.

The 2405FPW is 12ms response time, but all the published specs for every company are chock full of bs. Spend some time in the video forum. Some measure grey to grey response times, many measure black to black, contrast ratio factory measurements are bs too, a 800:1 will many time not measure up to a 500:1 monitor that was measured more intensively. But i can say this, almost no one notices ghosting on the 2405fpw and contrast is not a issue for the high quality Samsung panel used in this screen.

here's the memory matrix for 939 systems.
http://forums.anandtech.com/messageview...atid=28&threadid=1475190&enterthread=y
Only one area seemed signifigant was winrar. The couple game tests which slow slight inprovement with bandwidth or LL, I think you're much better of upgrading to the next tier of video card if on a budget instead of investing with overpriced ram. Investing in expensive Ram probably offers to poorest bang for the buck of any computer part. What's intesting was Ballistix's async 166 and LL the performance faired a little better than TCCD 1:1. Seems A64 prefers LL rather than bandwidth? Also shows that running async is'nt to be shunned.

 

ribbon13

Diamond Member
Feb 1, 2005
9,343
0
0
The Asus A8N32-SLI is superior to the DFI's for high multiplier overclocking.

Seasonic S12-600 PSU all the way.

No lian-li! they cheaper ones use the crappiest snap in motherboard standoffs. They suck. The more expensive ones that don't mount the motherboard upside down, which doesn't work with the A8N32, so screw that.

Getting a 1280x1024 LCD is a bad idea for a gaming machine. The Samsung 214T is a much nicer panel.

The RAM to get is 2x1GB Mushkin Redline XP4000.

eVGA 7800GTX or the X1900XT. Don't bother with glorified GPU SMP, it would be better to blow the money on an even more badass monitor, because they actually retain value.