A common misconception about Christians.

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

EpsiIon

Platinum Member
Nov 26, 2000
2,351
1
0
Emperor Nero

and who is to stay all christians devote their life to god? in fact, I don't think even 1/4 do devote their life entirely to god. allow me to elaborate: whenever I go to church, I see familiar faces, most being students at my school. in church, they all look so holy and touched by god, at school, they are the biggest assholes...ignoring all christian teachings from the minute they step out of the church. then later on, they preach. I have seen too much hypocrisy that it has become too disgusting.


****
:) -- Christians (by Christian I mean followers of Christ) are, by defintion, called to surrender their lives to God. That's not to say all do, but it's what God wants of us. And, I believe, those who truly want to follow Jesus endeavor to hand their lives to God.

I'm very sorry about that. We Christians are anything but perfect. In fact, my mom was recently VERY hurt by some prominent members in our church, but does that mean they aren't Christians? I don't think so. The fact is, nobody knows the heart of anybody else. We can make as many assumptions as we want, but we JUST DON'T KNOW.

As for those who claim to be Christians and ignore God and His teachings, I really wish they wouldn't do that. It really is a horrible witness to the world. The thing is, these people may actually THINK they ARE saved, and that's an extension of their imperfection. (Of course, now I'm sinning by judging those people. But does that make my viewpoint invalid? Again, I don't think so -- it just goes to show that I am imperfect, just like them.)

On a quick side note, I want to make it clear that I DON'T think I'm perfect at all. I SIN all the time. Everybody does. It's a fact of life. Now, you may ask, "Who desides what sin is?" The only heartfelt way I can answer is, "God."

Grr... I'm drifting from topic to topic. There are too many things to address. Understand that I am not defending those who claim to be Christians but don't live like it. They will have to answer to God for their actions, like the rest of us. But even so, being a Christian isn't about actions. In my eyes, the poll you brought up has at least one fatal flaw: it doesn't take into account the fact that the popular opinion doesn't determine who goes to heaven and who doesn't. God does.

Here's something important to remember: If you believe Christ is the the Messiah, it all fits into place. Everything. All the arguments, when taken from a logical perspective and the assumption that God exists, work together to form an impermeable quilt (to me). The thing is, the same thing can be said for the other side. If you assume that God doesn't exist and/or that Christ isn't the Messiah, then your arguments will make complete sense to you. So, I don't think either one of us is going to change the other's mind, but I think it is important to maintain open discussion about these topics so that we, as falty human beings, don't get into the brainwashed position of, "My way's true and you just suck so STHU." The fact of the matter is that I do believe my way is true and that you can't persuade me to change my mind, but I'm still willing to hear what you have to say and discuss it with you in a calm, reasonable manner. Because nobody was ever truly converted to Christianity by having Christ shoved down their throat.
****


most people claiming to be true followers of christ are hypocrites...some truly try and some are successful; most give a half-assed job of trying to be like christ and think it's good enough. I bet many of you are offended right now because you're doing a quick self-assessment and came to the conclusion that you really do try to follow in god's footsteps. here's a very interesting statistics my psychology teacher told me about for those who are offended: 60% believe bill clinton is going to heaven; 95% believe mother theresa is in heaven, and 99% believe they are going to heaven. do you really believe those 99% have a better chance in getting into heaven than mother theresa? people who are ignorant or intentionally ignoring their own flaws really get to me. they think they are god's gift to the world and they think they're very close perfect so they sneer and judge their neighbors. I realize many of my own faults so that is why I do not claim I devote my life to god, nor do I claim to be a true christian. sadly, there are people out there who do claim such things while there are absolute scums.

****
I'm sorry, but I have to disagree with the generalization at the beginning of this last paragraph. Just because people are beyond imperfect doesn't make them hippocrites.

*weak smile* Um, seriously, no offense here, but it's almost hippocritical to call them hippocrites... I understand that you freely admit that you aren't perfect, but I seriously doubt that these people believe they are perfect. And, just like you, that's what keeps them from being hippocrites. They know they're screwing up, but they're trying to fix it (I would certainly hope! :)).

And: Anybody who seriously calls himself perfect immediately admits that he isn't, right? ;)


Do we have to be perfect to devote our lives to God? And I didn't (mean to) say that my life is completely devoted to God. I (should have) said I want it to be, and that I'm struggling immensely with giving God every part of my life. You don't know how hard it is to be self-sufficient and then relinquish control to God.

In all honesty, I suspect that their isn't a single person on this Earth who can say that they have honestly given God every part of their life. It's too hard; we're too self-serving and sinful. But God says that he loves us anyway. "All" he asks is that we develop a relationship with him, and live as similarly to Christ as we can. Even if you don't make it (and none of us truly do), you can still go to heaven. But it's not supposed to be about getting to heaven -- it's supposed to be about pleasing God.

Again, who am I to say whether or not somebody is going to heaven? I don't know their heart. What I can say is that Jesus has said, "I am the way, the truth, and the life." Take that as you will, but understand that I believe God will hold you accountable...
****

there's this guy in my history class who thinks he is religious and devoted to god. he believes in the absolute strict interpretation of the bible so he preaches like crazy, not to mention has very little respect for other religions and think all non-christians are immoral. he even specifically told some of my hindu friends their religion is "laughable" and they are "heathens." he had done other things which I do not care to talk about (since it involves person details about people I love), but just know that those actions are prohibited in the bible, which he claims to abide by.

****
Again, I'm sorry that this young man (Sounds funny to say that -- I'm only turning 18 on Saturday :)) is not living up to the standards set forth in the Bible. Like I said before, I really wish he wouldn't do that because it paints Christianity in a bad light.
In reality, he MIGHT be saved. I don't know. His actions would indicate that he is not but, like I said, I am not his judge and I don't know his heart.

I certianly don't think he should call anybody's religious beliefs "laughable" (no matter how much he or I disagree with them) but (umm, heh), by one definition, the word "heathen" would be appropriate:

First definition from Dictionary.com:
---
hea·then (hthn)
n., pl. hea·thens or heathen.

1)
a)One who adheres to the religion of a people or nation that does not
acknowledge the God of Judaism, Christianity, or Islam.
b)Such persons considered as a group; the unconverted.
---

Honestly, though, I don't want to get into an argument about this, because it's entirely semantics...
****

IMO, there two real misconceptions:
1) christians are moral people who devote their life to god. granted, there are some people who absolutely love god and try their best to abide by his teachings, but sadly, they are in the extreme minority. most THINK and CLAIM they are religious but they are either ignorant to or purposely ignore their own faults, and these people are in the majority. for those of you who are offended at the latter statement, be reminded of the statistics - there are more people who think they are going to heaven than people who think mother theresa, who I believe to be a true christian, is in heaven. I'm sorry to say I don't have actual first hand sources of that statistic besides from what my teacher told me, but if you poll an unsuspecting crowd, you will come up with similiar results...and the larger the crowd, the more accurate the results (ex. asking 2 people if they think they're going to heaven won't be very accurate since one could say yes, anoter could say no - the results would be 50%). my point? people are ignorant to their own faults so it's rather hard to trust somebody who claims to be an adament christ follower.


****
:) I must admit I am a little offended by that generalization. And I'm not saying that because it does or doesn't apply to me. I'm saying it because you are making the same assumption that many people crucify (excuse the pun -- it wasn't intended) Christians for (presumably) making. That you know these people's hearts... Nobody truly knows the heart of anybody else, but we can all think we know.

I'm sorry to say that there is a big misconception that Christianity says works will get you to heaven. Because that's not true. It's not something we earn -- it's a gift.
****[/b]

misconception number 2: non-christians are immoral. take the guy I was mentioning ealier for example. although many may not be as bad as him, I still believe many christians have slight prejudices in thinking at least non christians are not as moral as themselves.

****
Well, here we have to define what immoral means. To me, immoral means living or acting in a way that God doesn't want us to. By that definition, every one of us is immoral. But the amount of immoraltiy in each individual, according to God, doesn't matter.

You said:
"I still believe many christians have slight prejudices in thinking at least non christians are not as moral as themselves."
And, unfortunately, that is all too true. It sounds smug and self-serving to say it (I know), but, as Christians, we are not perfect, just forgiven.

It's hard for many Christians (including me) to understand but one sin is not more sinful than another. Me being proud and bragging about my GPA is just a sinful as a murderer killing somebody. I know, logically, it doesn't make sense and, to us, they are completely different acts. But, in the eyes of God, a sin is a sin is a sin. Fortuanately, according to Christianity, He offers a way for EVERYBODY to be forgiven no matter how many sins they've committed. And that is through Jesus' death on the cross.
****

from my experiences, I am wary of anybody who claims to devote their life to god - this isn't a personal attack on you epsilon, but a general statement of christians...I don't know you and you could be the nicest, most loving person in the world or you could be the biggest asshole who claims to love god dearly. my priest said that if you tell a truly humble person he's a bigot, he will not deny that or he will ask why do you think that. but if you accuse a bigot of being a bigot, he will viciously lash out at you. apply that in this situation: true christians will rarely ever claim to be one since they realize they are not perfect and that they still have room for self improvement while people who put on the facade of true christians will get intensely offended when you point out they are not following christ's teachings.

****
Phew, I've been on the computer for nearly two hours, and your last paragraph could lead to another two hours of typing, but I'll try to simplify as much as possible (for my body's sake :)).

I agree completely with your statement about the bigot. :) And I can tell you how I'd react. I'd flatly deny that I'm a bigot, but then I'd ask you why you thought so. *grin* So that puts me somewhere in the middle. I really don't think I'm a bigot, but I won't lash out at you for calling me one. I'll try to understand where your (what I think is a) misconception of me comes from.

Quote:
"true christians will rarely ever claim to be one since they realize they are not perfect and that they still have room for self improvement while people who put on the facade of true christians will get intensely offended when you point out they are not following christ's teachings."

First, I have to say that I see that quote as making the mistake of thinking Christians equate themselves with perfection. An intelligent Christian will never claim to be perfect. But neither will any type of intelligent person.

In fact, I believe that a true Christian will never flaunt his or her Christianity in the face of another and will try (I say try because we're all human -- he or she would have to get past the pride of being criticized) to listen carefully when you tell them you don't think they are living up to their own standards.

There, that's the last part in a nutshell (nine minutes :)). Now I need to take a break. :D

I really hope you took to heart what I said here and that you'll earnestly reply.

Thanks a lot for even reading this far. :D

Epsilon
 

jsm

Banned
Oct 11, 1999
971
0
0
Hi Palad.

If your god was truly perfect, he would not need to create hell. Hell is not created to rehabilitate people, but rather to punish them unendingly. If god were truly one of love, he would never need to punish for he would be an enlightened being who would simply understand why simple creatures do simple things.

As a creature that can be hurt, you decide what is right and wrong because you are vulnerable to a number of things. You do this to protect yourself. Truly, though - nothing is right or wrong. Things just ARE. Humans are the ones who are responsible for labeling actions and applying punishment and guilt. If you were an asteroid that was sentient and you watched humans kill eachother, you would not care - it would simply happen. But, because you are emotionally enslaved, you perceive it as either right or wrong. Do you flip out everytime an animal is killed?

The christian god demands love or he will kill. The very fact that your god desires means their is a lack inside of him. The fact that it lacks means that it is imperfect. Your christian god states that it is perfect, but it is obviously not which makes it a liar. If god were indeed perfect as you state, it would simply be.. and it would demand nothing and get involved in nothing. It would simply exist.

The difference between science and god is that science constantly seeks new answers and attempts to progress constantly. Christianity is a stagnant religion that relies on aged dogma that is out dated and much too simplistic to be viewed as a perfect word from a perfect and divine entity.

If the word of god was true, it would be unquestionable and immutable. The very fact that it is overcome by human logic is proof that the christian god is not what it claims to be - but rather a flawed human construction.

And here are a couple questions:

- Which specific interpretation of the christianity is correct? Jehovah's Witnesses? Mormons? Catholics? Protestants? Davidians?

- Why is the god of the old testament so violent? If this god is indeed one of love, then why does it kill so much? Why does the christian god choose violence as a solution?

Thanks, friend!
 

PistachioByAzul

Diamond Member
Oct 9, 1999
5,132
0
71
Do you go to a doctor when you are sick or injured? What? You do? You hypocrite!

Your argument is seriously flawed. I have a basis for going to the doctor, it's benefits are proven. What's my basis for believing in your imaginary God? His existance can't be proven.
 

PistachioByAzul

Diamond Member
Oct 9, 1999
5,132
0
71
I'm just getting my 2 cents in like everyone else.

For the record, I'm not Republican. Maybe when they drop the Christian Coalition and stop acting like pussies, but until then, the GOP can bite me.
 

AMDJunkie

Diamond Member
Dec 6, 1999
3,431
5
81
Woohoo, down and dirty religious debate.


A few points to be made from jsm's last post.

1.)A large group of Christians believe that God did not create Hell, but Hell was created by the devil. I personally believe the farther and farther you move away from God, the closer you move towards the devil. The more evil deeds you do, the more you become the devil's possession. You can choose in this life to have eternal life in God's Heaven or Beezlebub's Paradise. Your choice, not God's.

2.)

<< If god were indeed perfect as you state, it would simply be.. and it would demand nothing and get involved in nothing. It would simply exist >>

If God, the Creator, did exist and only existed, doing nothing, we would not be here. Why should the artist not be able to alter his own work, the work he lovingly crafted and labored over?

3.)

<< If the word of god was true, it would be unquestionable and immutable. >>

The Word of God is totally true, full of religious truth, the truth that God shows to man through the words written to find God's lesson.
 

Zucchini

Banned
Dec 10, 1999
4,601
0
0
1.)A large group of Christians believe that God did not create Hell, but Hell was created by the devil. I personally believe the farther and farther you move away from God, the closer you move towards the devil. The more evil deeds you do, the more you become the devil's possession. You can choose in this life to have eternal life in God's Heaven or Beezlebub's Paradise. Your choice, not God's.

I'm just going to pick at this point:p An all powerful god would not have allowed this to happen, or continue to happen. An all knowing god would have seen it coming. Either way for there to be a hell makes for a feeble god. Allowing even evil people ot suffer for eternity is in itself evil.
 

jsm

Banned
Oct 11, 1999
971
0
0
AMD Junkie said:
&quot;1.)A large group of Christians believe that God did not create Hell, but Hell was created by the devil. I personally believe the farther and farther you move away from God, the closer you move towards the devil. The more evil deeds you do, the more you become the devil's possession. You can choose in this life to have eternal life in God's Heaven or Beezlebub's Paradise. Your choice, not God's.&quot;

If god were truly a being of love, he would not have let the chance for negativity to occur. He has created the chance for negativity and for &quot;bad things&quot; to happen to people. Again, there is no such thing as an evil deed. There simply is a deed that you do not like because of how it negatitely effects you.

Anyhow, there is no such thing as free will if you believe in christian doctrine, despite what they may claim.

And regarding God's choice:

God is holding an election and running for president. He says:

- Vote me and you will live.
- Vote for another candidate and you will die.
- Vote for no one and you will die.
- And no matter who you vote for, I will become president.

Does that sound like a fair scenario to you?


AMDJunkie said:
&quot;If God, the Creator, did exist and only existed, doing nothing, we would not be here. Why should the artist not be able to alter his own work, the work he lovingly crafted and labored over?&quot;

Exactly. Therefore, we can ascertain that there is a source of existence, but we cannot ascertain exactly what it is. We KNOW it is not an emotional god (ie: christian deity). Also, you should go about proving your god is alive and has indeed created us before making such sweeping statements.

AMD Junkie said:
&quot;The Word of God is totally true, full of religious truth, the truth that God shows to man through the words written to find God's lesson.&quot;

Hmm.. unfortunately, with my above illustration concerning god and the election, it would seem that your god lacks logic and his &quot;truth&quot; would actually be lies. Remember - he said he was perfect but I have easily displayed it to be otherwise - therefore he has established a track record of bearing false witness and is not to be trusted. He kills yet says he is a being of pure love. He cannot decide the order of creation and his words are full of sexism (read the OT sometime). It is obvious to myself that this is a construction of man - it has so many holes that only a simple, outdated man with simple logic would create. A modern day man could easily create a deity that is much more complex and has more understanding of all things and, more importantly, IS NOT VIOLENT.

You neglected to respond to my other questions.

- Which specific interpretation of the christianity is correct? Jehovah's Witnesses? Mormons? Catholics? Protestants? Davidians?

- Why is the god of the old testament so violent? If this god is indeed one of love, then why does it kill so much? Why does the christian god choose violence as a solution?
 

NovaTerra

Banned
Jan 15, 2001
229
0
0
hzl: His statement, when taken apart, shows his bigotry. First he states that people think Theists are &quot;brainwashed morons&quot;.

Then he says that he &quot;came to God of my own accord&quot; from a &quot;very liberal background.&quot; If you know anything about logic he is stating that persons of a liberal background are separated from God. Since the only persons that I know that are truly separated from God are Atheists or Satan Worshipers, I must conclude that he is making that reference.

Either way he is making sweeping statements about groups of people. This means that he is, at the very least, a bigot. Of course, he will tell you that he is not.
:)
 

syzygy

Diamond Member
Feb 5, 2001
3,038
0
76
i know there must be lots of answers to these classic questions. the best i understand
them is that the god (the judeo-christian one specifically) has three aspects: all
knowing, all powerful, and absolutely good.

the trouble ofcourse is the existence of evil.

therefore, if god is absolutely good, knows all, and can do all, why does he allow evil,
knowing full well that innocents will suffer and die. god has the power to not allow
evil or to stop evil before harm can be done to perfectly innocent people, yet
he doesn't act (or he chooses to act selectively as recorded in the bibles).

also, humankind has free will. therefore humankind has the choice between opting for good
or for evil. this has been the traditional counter arguement why god with all his power
and infinite knowldedge and absolute goodness must allow humankind to make their own
decisions utlimately.

hope this helps any. time to go to sleep. cheers.

 

reitz

Elite Member
Oct 11, 1999
3,878
2
76
jackass,

Liberal:

1. Not limited to or by established, traditional, orthodox, or authoritarian attitudes, views, or dogmas; free from bigotry.

2. Favoring proposals for reform, open to new ideas for progress, and tolerant of the ideas and behavior of others; broad-minded

3. Generous in amount; ample:

4. Not strict or literal; loose or approximate

How can anyone be so stupid as to immediately take his background statement as &quot;...equating liberals with Devil Worshipers or Atheists?&quot; You are an idiot; maybe you should get in the habit of looking up the definitions of big words before you make an ass out of yourself.
 

SuperTool

Lifer
Jan 25, 2000
14,000
2
0
That's the problem with Christians. You try and have an intelligent discussion with them, and they kinda try too for a while, but once you beat them into a corner, they just start quoting the Bible. Here is a hint for all of you. You can't use the Bible to prove that the Bible is true. That's kind of like using a theorem to prove itself. Just some flawed thinking to watch out for.
 

Zucchini

Banned
Dec 10, 1999
4,601
0
0
reitz,

Yes we know the dictionary definition of liberal, but on this board it is almost never used in that context.
 

FrontlineWarrior

Diamond Member
Apr 19, 2000
4,905
1
0
Misconception 1: Believing a god in your life makes your life much easier.

That's what I understand some of the arguments to be when people say Christianity or any type of theism is a crutch. Yes, in many ways it's easy to say &quot;it's beyond my understanding, so I'll just do what this Good Book says.&quot; However, what many of you fail to notice is that our everyday lives aren't constantly bombarded by questions of purpose or worth. Rather, they are bombarded by our desires and decisions.

For example, when you wake up in the morning, you don't ask yourself, &quot;do i have a purpose in my life?&quot;. Rather, we decide between &quot;i'm too damn tired to wake up now... snooze button looks nice&quot; or &quot;i have to wake up to go to school/work&quot;.

What's my point? Well in many ways our lives are consumed with desires and decisions. A lot of our desires aren't necessarily morally correct according to some belief systems. Therefore, the everyday lives of people are more about self-control and religious struggle, rather than the peace of mind of God's purpose in your life.

So my point is that religion is not the easy way out that people think it is. Yes, in many ways a lot of the mysteries and uncertainties are easily dealt with, but with that is the everyday struggle to live along the guidelines of the religion's values, which I think is, realistically, what makes religion the tougher choice rather than the easy way out.
 

reitz

Elite Member
Oct 11, 1999
3,878
2
76


<< Yes we know the dictionary definition of liberal, but on this board it is almost never used in that context. >>

And it only takes an intelligent person one moment to realize that EpsiIon is not a regular poster. My first clue was the &quot;member&quot; status under his username.
 

Tib

Banned
Dec 18, 2000
602
0
0
I saw this thread on the &quot;popular threads list&quot; or whatever it is...anyway, i don't have much to say - couple things.

1) people should worry about their own problems. if you have problems with christ, worry about it yourself. if other people have problems and you know about it, and they don't, tell them about it. if they don't listen, who gives? who cares? worry about your own problems, and about making yourself better, and try to help other people - if they listen. if they don't, they're on their own! &quot;God helps those who help themselves.&quot; - Ben Franklin.

2) in the Bible, it says that when the time comes that there will be much confusion between right and wrong, the end will be near.

Well....if you ask me, we have passed that point already! shoot....there are so many debates going on these days....1) &quot;who should be the leader of our country? is he/she a 'moral' enough person, and will he/she make the right decisions?&quot; ... 2) &quot;is ebortion right or wrong?&quot; ... 3) &quot;legalize drugs or no?&quot; ... 4) &quot;is it OK to be gay?&quot; ... 5) &quot;should parents be able to 'beat' their kids as discipline?&quot; ... 6) &quot;is it ok to take prayer out of school?&quot; ... 7) &quot;how old do you have to be to be allowed to....???&quot;

My answers:
1) no one is good enough anymore to lead our country. we simply need to accept who we have and pray for him/her, hope for the best.
2) ebortion is wrong. since the world is so messed up, we need to have it. what to do about it? i dunno, wait until the world ends. hopefully we won't need ebortion in heaven.
3) yes. <period> - people should make their own decisions, not have other people make it for them.
4) no, homosexuality is wrong <period> - there is a verse on this in the bible but i dunno where it is...anyway, that's a personal belief, you make your own. i'm homofobic too....so if yur gay, STAY AWAY PLEASE! I might hurt you if i ever meet you .... seriously :) - and I won't be able to control myself either.
5) yes, unfortunately, some parents take this too far, and that's why we need those dumb laws we have these days.
6) nope. one of the main reasons our youth (teens) is so messed up these days, is because we've taken prayer out of school, and aloud other types of harrassment. this ruins teens' self esteem, and makes them make wrong decisions and do stupid things.
7) as long as the child is still a child, the parents should make the call. when they're no longer a child, they should be allowed to. personally...I think that any law that has ANY mention of age is worthless...some 15 year olds are more mature than some 35 year olds...I have references, no kidding.

Anyway, my 2 cents. that's what i think about christianity and why our world is so screwed up....

i love talking about why the world is so screwed up....our world is so helpless. think about it....we only live for average 80 years, and heaven lasts forever. i don't understand how people can pass this up.

Tib
 

Tib

Banned
Dec 18, 2000
602
0
0
In reply to JSM...

really, debates over christianity make me feel disgusted, and indeed sorry for the party going against christ. i really don't know what to do but make my piont. here's my last reply tonight before i go to bed. i'll reply to each of your statements one by one.

&quot;If your god was truly perfect, he would not need to create hell. Hell is not created to rehabilitate people, but rather to punish them unendingly. If god were truly one of love, he would never need to punish for he would be an enlightened being who would simply understand why simple creatures do simple things.&quot;

God created hell for the devil, not for people. the reason why people are sent there is because they allow the devil to confuse and control them, thus, making them &quot;possessed of the devil&quot; or at least influenced by his teachings and wrongful pressures he places on people. also....God does not hurt people, he may &quot;punish&quot; or &quot;discipline&quot; them, the same way as a father would for his kids. God simply allows the devil to hurt us if we do not seek him (Jesus Christ).

&quot;As a creature that can be hurt, you decide what is right and wrong because you are vulnerable to a number of things. You do this to protect yourself. Truly, though - nothing is right or wrong. Things just ARE. Humans are the ones who are responsible for labeling actions and applying punishment and guilt. If you were an asteroid that was sentient and you watched humans kill eachother, you would not care - it would simply happen. But, because you are emotionally enslaved, you perceive it as either right or wrong. Do you flip out everytime an animal is killed?&quot;

Once again, God doesn't hurt, he allows the devil to do so. Hell was made for the devil and his followers, not for people, and not for people who have faith in God.

&quot;The christian god demands love or he will kill. The very fact that your god desires means their is a lack inside of him. The fact that it lacks means that it is imperfect. Your christian god states that it is perfect, but it is obviously not which makes it a liar. If god were indeed perfect as you state, it would simply be.. and it would demand nothing and get involved in nothing. It would simply exist.&quot;

This is because God wants heaven to be a perfect place. God will allow people to be sent to hell, but he will first give us all a chance here on Earth, first. If there were any blemish in heaven (sin), would it be perfect? That's why God said that only people with love (and nothing else) in their hearts can make it to heaven.

&quot;The difference between science and god is that science constantly seeks new answers and attempts to progress constantly. Christianity is a stagnant religion that relies on aged dogma that is out dated and much too simplistic to be viewed as a perfect word from a perfect and divine entity.&quot;

Christianity isn't a religion - it's a relationship with christ. Point made...I'll continue and tell you why. all religions were made up at some point in time by a person who was &quot;enlightened&quot; - Christianity was not. Christianity was brought here by Christ, and before him, there was God himself, who was here forever. In all religions, that one &quot;enlightened&quot; person died...and never came back to life. only Christians have the ability to worship &quot;a living God&quot; - no other God lives. They were all created, and they are all fake.

&quot;If the word of god was true, it would be unquestionable and immutable. The very fact that it is overcome by human logic is proof that the christian god is not what it claims to be - but rather a flawed human construction.&quot;

Simply put..like i said in my reply earlier....when there is much confusion about what is right and what is wrong, the end will be near. well...that's confusion right there. all of these &quot;new&quot; beliefs that came to us only a few decades, maybe a couple centuries ago. i don't have much to say about this, but i do believe that the word of God is &quot;unquestionable and immutable.&quot;

And here are a couple questions:

&quot;- Which specific interpretation of the christianity is correct? Jehovah's Witnesses? Mormons? Catholics? Protestants? Davidians?&quot;

The &quot;King James Version&quot; of the Bible was written by King James himself, and is a direct copy of the manuscripts, which make up the Bible, in Hebrew. It's the best way that we can learn of &quot;the correct way to live life.&quot; However, there is no 'correct' version of 'christianity' - you make up your own. whichever way you think is right is the way to live. i go to a church that is pentecostal / gospel, but i personally would go to any church with any name bearing &quot;Christian&quot; on it, so long as it allowed me to express my beliefs, live by them, and feel comfortable about it.

&quot;- Why is the god of the old testament so violent? If this god is indeed one of love, then why does it kill so much? Why does the christian god choose violence as a solution?&quot;

In the old days, people had to sacrifice actual animals to wash away their sins. In the new testament of the Bible, Christ died for us, being the indefinate sacrifice. God took his wrath out on people to show his power. now...he still does the same thing. certain nations are cursed, certain nations are blessed. God allows a curse to hang above a family or a nation for up to 4 or 5 generations (about 1 to 2 centuries). God is now holding back his wrath for the last days, the 7 days of tribulation....by the way....that's just a personal belief, make of it what you want. personally, i think God has been very easy on the world since Christ...life has been easier (although not EASY at time, but 'EASIER')

Goodnight...I hope you don't take some of my answers as offensive...i simply wanted to make my point and let people know what i believe - maybe some day i'll be able to help someone...i hope i can help myself first, though :)

BTW...i admit it....i'm a hypocrite....but at least the people who read this won't be able to say after they die &quot;But God....no one ever told me THAT.&quot;

My 2 cents' worth reply :)

Tibor
 

limsandy

Golden Member
Jan 6, 2001
1,554
0
0

Hmmm, many people who posted in this thread are intelligent people whom I should learn from. EmperorNero, jsm and SuperTool have explained the situation well.

For EpsiIon:
By the way, I was laughing as I read your words......
&quot;I feel indebted to the living God who gave his life for ME&quot;

Were you born by your mother or were you directly born by God?



 

SinnerWolf

Senior member
Dec 30, 2000
782
0
0
I'm agnostic, which in case you're deluded, means i believe in god, but do NOT associate him with ANY singular religion or form of church. I choose this path because it feels right for me. But, i think that religion is a good thing. If you're going to believe in something you should believe in it wholeheartidly and passionately. Anything less then your all is not worth the effort or time. I think that you are however confusing two things....religion and faith. Faith is what is difficult to acheive, and sought after by many. Religion is the organization of a common form of practice/system of belief. Religion can be obtained with a mere proclamation of membership...while faith can only be gained and continued from a true heart. And you don't need one to have the other.
 

sandorski

No Lifer
Oct 10, 1999
70,825
6,374
126
Non-Christians often have many objections to Judeo-Christian thought. Some of these are legit, others based on false assumptions and/or generalizations, and yet other objections are just misunderstandings. But I don't want to address these things. What I would like to address is something I'll call, &quot;Common misconceptions about Christianity by Christians&quot;

1) You must be &quot;born again&quot;. [IMO]What Jesus was talking about was a process and/or moment in one's life where they actively seek God. It is not a Church/denomination that proclaims being &quot;born again&quot; as important, though such a Church/denomination isn't necessarily wrong, it's just that many Christians can't see beyond a &quot;born again&quot; type Church/denomination as having any redeeming value. It would not surprise me if at the final judgement that many JWs, Mormons, and other looked down upon organizations are deemed &quot;saved&quot; or &quot;born again&quot; as well. In short, one doesn't have to know that they are &quot;born again&quot; to be &quot;born again&quot;, they need only change their direction.[IMO]

2) Every Christian either does or should believe the following things:
a) Prayer in schools
b) Abortion is wrong
c) It used to be better in the past and/or it's getting worse each day
d) Creation Science
e) God is a Republican(mostly a US issue). This often is evidenced by many Christians supporting Republicans for moral stance reasons, but eventually and almost without fail many Christians replace God with &quot;God's party&quot;. Of course, they don't realize it, but they are easy enough to spot.

3) Your Pastor/Minister/Denomination/Club/Organization that is Christian can be trusted without question. [IMO]Any good Pastor will encourage his/her congregation to test his/her words against the scripture. A Christian should![IMO]

4) Christian &quot;speak&quot; is cool and a sign of Christianness.
 

EpsiIon

Platinum Member
Nov 26, 2000
2,351
1
0
Sorry, but you guys completely missed the point. I didn't mean to say that liberals were Godless Satanists and, honestly, I don't think that what I said indicated that. In reality, though, most liberal thinkers are not Christians. But there are exceptions to the rule -- like my mother. She is fairly liberal but also has faith in God. I didn't say that the two couldn't co-exist, just that they usually don't.

Honestly, I never meant to judge or offend anybody. If I did so anyway, I owe you an apology. In which case, &quot;I'm sorry.&quot;

Now, I probably won't be able to respond again to this thread, but I hope you'll read what I've written in the manner it's intended.

Gotta go,
Epsilon
 

jsm

Banned
Oct 11, 1999
971
0
0
?God created hell for the devil, not for people. the reason why people are sent there is because they allow the devil to confuse and control them, thus, making them &quot;possessed of the devil&quot; or at least influenced by his teachings and wrongful pressures he places on people. also....God does not hurt people, he may &quot;punish&quot; or &quot;discipline&quot; them, the same way as a father would for his kids. God simply allows the devil to hurt us if we do not seek him (Jesus Christ).?

I completely disagree. Using your bible we can see that your god is the one who hurts unendingly. One rather popular example is the flood, where he killed nearly all of the population of the earth. Or how about when Moses wrote up the 10 commandments? When Moses returned, he found people worshipping a golden calf, so he ordered all worshippers killed ? we are talking women, children ? you name it. After that, god was still not appeased so he unleashed a plague killing 20,000 more people. So.. he doesn?t hurt people, eh? Death is something more than just ?punishment? or ?discipline?.

OR, since you want to blame everything on the devil ? we must ask: Who does more killing in the bible? Satan or god? Well, the bible clearly displays Satan only killing once ? and when god said he could. Job was tested and Satan was allowed to kill Job?s children. BUT, that is the only time that Satan ever killed in the bible. Of course, I can come up with countless other times that the Christian mythological deity killed in the bible.

It would seem your god punishes humans for following his design. Here is a quick story to explain this better:

A scientist creates a race of robots. He designs them to do very specific things. One day, he sees them doing the things he has programmed them to do. He gets mad at the robots for doing what he designed them to do so shoots himself in the spine.

?Once again, God doesn't hurt, he allows the devil to do so. Hell was made for the devil and his followers, not for people, and not for people who have faith in God.?

I disagree ? or else your god would prevent all people from going there if he truly loved them. Also, please see the above point.

?This is because God wants heaven to be a perfect place. God will allow people to be sent to hell, but he will first give us all a chance here on Earth, first. If there were any blemish in heaven (sin), would it be perfect? That's why God said that only people with love (and nothing else) in their hearts can make it to heaven.?

There already is a blemish in heaven ? a lying, deceitful, bloodthirsty deity is up there just itching to come down and kill, kill, kill. Since your god is all, he is both pure love and pure hate. He has designed suffering, pain, death and dismay. He created all the negativity that you have ever witnessed and more. If he has not, then he is limited and therefore cannot be god.

?Christianity isn't a religion - it's a relationship with christ. Point made...I'll continue and tell you why. all religions were made up at some point in time by a person who was &quot;enlightened&quot; - Christianity was not. Christianity was brought here by Christ, and before him, there was God himself, who was here forever. In all religions, that one &quot;enlightened&quot; person died...and never came back to life. only Christians have the ability to worship &quot;a living God&quot; - no other God lives. They were all created, and they are all fake.?

You cannot prove this. I think that Zeus is real and therefore he is, at least, using your logic. He rules on top of a mountain watching over us and supplying us with the mighty electron. Your point is pathetic and is at best laughable since you present no verification to back up your fantastic claim.

?Simply put..like i said in my reply earlier....when there is much confusion about what is right and what is wrong, the end will be near. well...that's confusion right there. all of these &quot;new&quot; beliefs that came to us only a few decades, maybe a couple centuries ago. i don't have much to say about this, but i do believe that the word of God is &quot;unquestionable and immutable.&quot;

People have been proclaiming the end for what seems like forever. People are not confused at all.. in fact, the world is becoming more enlightened as we speak ? which is why the number of Christians will diminish. People have this idea that the world is getting worse seem to lack any understanding of history. In fact, the world is at peace moreso than ever. It seems that this perspective that the world is so bad seems to be a foolish Christian theory that stems from the fact that their numbers are dropping.

?The &quot;King James Version&quot; of the Bible was written by King James himself, and is a direct copy of the manuscripts, which make up the Bible, in Hebrew. It's the best way that we can learn of &quot;the correct way to live life.&quot; However, there is no 'correct' version of 'christianity' - you make up your own. whichever way you think is right is the way to live. i go to a church that is pentecostal / gospel, but i personally would go to any church with any name bearing &quot;Christian&quot; on it, so long as it allowed me to express my beliefs, live by them, and feel comfortable about it.?

That?s bizarre.. most of the Christian churches I have gone seem to think their religion is absolute and supreme and that others are wasting their time. Why so much chaos in the house of jesus?

?In the old days, people had to sacrifice actual animals to wash away their sins. In the new testament of the Bible, Christ died for us, being the indefinate sacrifice. God took his wrath out on people to show his power. now...he still does the same thing. certain nations are cursed, certain nations are blessed. God allows a curse to hang above a family or a nation for up to 4 or 5 generations (about 1 to 2 centuries). God is now holding back his wrath for the last days, the 7 days of tribulation....by the way....that's just a personal belief, make of it what you want. personally, i think God has been very easy on the world since Christ...life has been easier (although not EASY at time, but 'EASIER')?

Wow, I would sure would love to see your proof of nations being blessed and cursed. Do you have any scientific evidence to back up your claims? Also, why would god meddle in human affairs? There are so many other things he could be doing .. like trying to understand the big bang theory or maybe even reading up on some basic understanding of the solar system since he failed to mention to his people that the Earth rotates around the sun, not the other way around like Joshua thought (?Sun, stand still!?).

Actually, that specific situation makes me laugh. Why? Because god will waste an entire book foretelling the end of the world and going into great detail, but never once will he mention anything about how the earth revolves around the sun.

Here is my theory on why your Christian mythological deity is so violent:

1. The Israelites used to have power, so they killed any tribe standing in their way.
2. Then they lost their power and had to make an ideological 180 in order to survive.

Honestly, if the Romans had never adopted Christianity, your religion would be have even smaller numbers or be non existent.

Christianty has been sooo watered down since it's origin. It used to be about war and destruction of all your foes. Now, since it has thoroughly ripped off Buddhism, it is about peace and love.. with death and killing somewhere in the near future (hopefully!).
 

SirFshAlot

Elite Member
Apr 11, 2000
2,887
0
0
jsm
The Christians are elitists as just like Nazis and Black Panthers

of course you aren't stereotyping are you?
that would stink too much of ignorance for a smart fella like you, eh?