Originally posted by: GagHalfrunt
Originally posted by: Pacfanweb
The armor on an M1 is very strong.
There was once a comparison argument of a company of M1's vs. a Battleship over on Warships1.com.
General consensus was, the battleship's 16" AP shells would not penetrate the Abram's armor. They would flatten the tank, and the concussion would ruin it an everyone inside, but they said the armor would not yield to the 2700lb shell.
Then they said that the Abram's gun COULD penetrate the turrets on the BB. Even though they're around 18" thick.
I found it hard to believe, but if true, that means the M1 has some tough armor.
Oh, and this scenario was at a range the tanks would be able to reach the battleship.....obviously the BB would never get in close enough to expose itself to tank fire. But if it was, its shells would have a flat trajectory, therefore they'd have to defeat the Abrams' armor where it is the toughest.
So as far as the A10's gun, I don't think it would SHRED an M1, but it would penetrate enough to kill it. Only takes one round getting inside the tank and everyone in there is pulp.
Important info for the many exciting battleship vs tank tactical situations that every commander must face. In the real world high explosive rounds like those fired by the battleship are essentially useless against tanks. The problem with conventional explosives is that a huge majority of the explosive force is wasted. Far more of the power explodes away from the target than into it. That is exactly the reason why the A10 was even built. It's EXTREMELY difficult to knock out a tank with explosives. Modern tank killing weapons are mostly kintetic-energy penetrators like the depleted uranium slug or the sabot round. Even the best shaped charge explosives are fairly ineffective against modern tanks and can be defeated with reactive armor. The way to knock out a tank is to pierce the skin rather than blow it up, a pinprick rather than a punch.
I am quite convinced that a direct hit from a battleship maingun would utterly destroy an M1 series tank. Having said that, that will never happen. Even if the battleship hit the M1 with high explosive rather than armor piercing munitions, the tank would be gone. A training round from a BB would be enough to destroy a tank if it ever made a direct hit.
Tanks, by design don't float and battleships are not land vehicles. An engagement between the two is pure fantasy. Oh well, I am a big fan of BB history and a former M1 tanker.