5200 Ultra, got yesterday, my opinions enclosed.

mrbuddylee

Member
Jul 28, 2003
66
0
0
Well, I ordered a eVGA Geforce 5200 Ultra last week. I got it brand new on Ebay for $70 including shipping. I figured at that price, I couldn't really pass it up. Last night I put it in my computer, and installed the latest drivers from NVidia. I downloaded some benchmarking tools, and here are some results:

3D Mark 2003: 1692
http://service.futuremark.com/compare?2k3=1210391

3D Mark 2001: 7742
http://service.futuremark.com/compare?2k1=6922938

That's without me doing any overclocking or anything to the card. Not too great.

The board came with Ghost Recon, so I installed that and fired it up. I turned all the settings on high, and I did get some low fps on some of the terrains. I was a little disappointed. However, when I messed with the setting a little bit, I was able to get the game to run pretty quick and it looked really good.

I fired up Neverwinter Nights and cranked up all the detail there. Was able to run at 1024x768 with no problems, and the game looked really good.

I'm also beta testing the MMORPG Horizons. I loaded it up, and it ran pretty smooth, and looked very nice.

Anyways, just wanted to post this because I was really on the fence about this card. I originally started out hoping to find a card for about $75. I looked at the GeforceFX 5200 and was thinking about the Ti4200 64MB card. When I found this card, I was thinking that it would be close with the 4200 or even the 4400, but it doesn't look like it's going to be. It just doesn't have the power to get things rendered. In 3D Mark 2003, all the tests looked absolutely stunning, but in the Nature test, I was down to like 6 fps...

Anyways, if anyone reads this and wants my opinion, I would suggest getting a 4200. For $100, a 4200 is well worth it I think (my friend has one and has a nearly identical setup as I do, thats what I base the comparison on).

I know this might not be news to anyone, but I was thinking that most of the people that were against the 5200 were that way because it was new and some people fear change. But, after a little research and first glances, I'm not terribly impressed. However, I do think it was worth $70, but definately not worth more than $100.

If anyone has any request for benchmarks or anything, I'll be happy to run them and share. I know there are more gamers on tight budgets out there than just me.
 

mrbuddylee

Member
Jul 28, 2003
66
0
0
why dont people read reviews before they blindly buy a video card???

I did read reviews.

http://www.extremeoverclocking.com/reviews/video/Albatron_FX_5200_Ultra_1.html
http://www.anandtech.com/video/showdoc.html?i=1797&p=15
http://www.hardwarezone.com/articles/articles.hwz?cid=3&aid=792

And a lot of the reviews match the fx5200 with the ti4200. These are all kinda on the fence, and don't really have a clear winner. So, I was just letting people know what they could expect out of a 5200 Ultra. Like I said, I'm sure there are people that are interested in getting the most out of their money, and if they're like me, I couldn't find a 4200 under $75, but I could find 5200 ultras for under $75. Anyways, thats why I posted this, to try to help people out instead of just being an ass.

p.s. I have an Athlon 2200+, must have missed the first 2 on the previous post.
 

kylebisme

Diamond Member
Mar 25, 2000
9,396
0
0
It just doesn't have the power to get things rendered. In 3D Mark 2003, all the tests looked absolutely stunning, but in the Nature test, I was down to like 6 fps...



you are being a bit critical there, i mean my 9700pro hits as low as 13 fps in that test and a geforce4 can't even run it.
 

spongebobfan

Member
Feb 7, 2003
85
0
0
I have a 5200 Ultra in my LAN party machine and I couldn't be more satisfied. It plays all of the games that are typically @ LAN parties with good framerate and good resolutions without breaking the bank. I run it with a P4 2.8 (533 bus) and get ~9200 in 3dMark01 with ~1700 in 3dMark03. Very good card for what I paid for it. I would never expect this card to run HL2 or DOOM3 at anything more than a fast slideshow. I got it strictly for the here and now...

my .02

Sponge