• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

$400 budget. need suggestions on new comp

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.
Originally posted by: Tostada
Originally posted by: hurtstotalktoyou
$79 Sempron 64 2800+ (ewiz.com)
$76 1GB PC3200 (ms4me.com)
$72 Maxtor 160GB PATA hard disk (supergooddeal.com)
$64 Biostar GeForce 6100-M7 (ewiz.com)
$40 NEC ND-3550A (computer3g.com)
$27 Broadway Com 204SGA (supergooddeal.com)
$12 A4tech KBS-720 & MS-333PB keyboard/optical mouse (supergooddeal.com)
$10 TEAC FD235HFC291 (computer3g.com)
$9 56K v.92 PCI modem (pcimicro.com)
$389 total

Is this a joke?

No.

You're suggesting ewiz.com when ZZF is cheaper?

What can I say? I missed it. Subtract $3 from the total.

You're getting totally generic memory from ms4me.com -- a Yahoo store? Newegg has generic memory cheaper than that.

Yes they do. Subtract another $8.

You're getting a motherboard that comes with a single short PATA cable. If you're lucky you can make it work by mounting the burner in the bottom 5.25" bay and the hard drive in the top 3.5" bay.

No luck required. It is plenty long enough.

You're suggesting a burner from Computer3G? Their 3.06 overall six-month rating is one of the lowest I've seen.
http://www.resellerratings.com/seller1664.html

Yup, you're right. Go with newegg, instead, then, and spend about $3-$4 extra.

You're suggesting a modem when he likely has broadband to play WoW?

Yes. A modem is very nice to have if the DSL or cable goes out.

A totally generic $27 case? Look how cheap the inside is. It has no CPU vent. It has no fans. Even if you buy fans, the vents are just pinholes, so they will barely work. And there's not a shred of info on the PSU.

First of all, the case doesn't add anything to performance. I really doubt you're going to need any fans. If it gets too hot, back off the OC 100-200 MHz and buy one later for $4. As for the PSU, even a basic name-brand unit is going to cost upwards of $45. If he's on a $400 budget, where do you suggest he make room?

A totally generic $12 keyboard/mouse?

Yes. I own three of those mice, myself, and they're all great. I'm sure the keyboard is fine, too.

A floppy drive when he probably doesn't need one?

Again, this is something he'll thank himself for getting if he ever happens to need it. Say he wants to flash his board BIOS, or get some files from a friend without a CD-RW; a floppy drive is a very handy item, and it's only $10 or $11.

Ewiz.com and supergooddeal.com both have very low ratings for "return or replacement" on resellerratings.com. I don't think you want to be buying generic dirt cheap stuff from them.

They do? The ratings look just fine to me. I've personally dealt with supergooddeal.com several times over the last two or three years.

I'm not saying the system I listed is the best someone can do, but it's just irresponsible to throw together a POS like that and suggest someone spend money on it.

My build wasn't the best, either, but it is perfectly acceptable. The only real problem was the computer3g.com suggestion, but even that would have been fine as long as the drives worked.

Come on. You didn't even spell it right. It's Biostar, and it's a good brand for cheap motherboards. That's the only good recommendation he had (except it's stupid buying any motherboard from a place with a 2.79 "return or replacement" rating on resellerratings.com).

Biostar boards get just about the best reviews you'll see on cheap boards, except in this case the ASRock board is a little cheaper and has better reviews.

I was wondering about the ASRock board, but I can't seem to pin down what kind of voltage and FSB controls it has. All of the reviews talked about a FSB at 250 or less, and he should get a board that can reach 300 minimum.
 
Originally posted by: dogmir
i have used alot of biostar in the past and i think they work just fine for people that arent going to be doing alot of overclocking and just want the basic pc.....and it helps that they are cheap...lol the tforce boards i hear are great you can get one with a sempron 2800+ off newegg and get $10 off....moboand you should be able to overclock a good bit....

I didn't notice that combo special. It's an $11 discount with the Sempron 64 2500+. If you wanted to try and play around with overclocking:

CPU: AMD Sempron 64 2500 Retail $69.99 (newegg)
mainboard: Biostar TForce6100 754 mATX $73.24 (newegg)
combo special: $-11
HDD: Western Digital 80GB SATA WD800JD $55.8 (ZipZoomFly)
RAM: G.Skill 1 x 1024MB DDR500 $104.8 (newegg)
CD: Samsung black combo drive $32.14 (newegg)
case: Foxconn TLM624 350W mATX $48.49 (newegg)
input: Logitech black keyboard, mouse $19.99 (ZipZoomFly)

That's $393.45


It'd be nice to run with the FSB at 250 with DDR500, since the RAM is the biggest bottleneck with onboard video, and you know that Palermo isn't actually "overclocked" when it's running at 1.75 GHz.

25% faster integrated graphics would be cool. I'd like to see some benchmarks on running the GF6100 on a higher bus speed with synchronous memory.

You might want to pay another $7.50 and get the Sempron 64 2800+ and overclock it higher synchronously, but I'd certainly prefer to have a name-brand PSU, and I'd rather just see how fast you can run the memory.

I still think I'd pay another $10 for the NEC DVD-RW and another $10 for the Microsoft keyboard/mouse.
 
** DO NOT BUY THAT DELL **

It does not have an AGP nor PCIe slot, and will never be even a decent gaming system.

All low-end dells are like this. Only their mid and high-end desktops have PCIe slots (older have agp slots).

And if you are looking for suggestions, I suggest you find a way to increase your budget for a gaming system with 1GB of ram. No way you're going to find all that for $400 without getting a total piece of junk.
 
Originally posted by: hurtstotalktoyou
Originally posted by: Tostada
A totally generic $27 case? Look how cheap the inside is. It has no CPU vent. It has no fans. Even if you buy fans, the vents are just pinholes, so they will barely work. And there's not a shred of info on the PSU.

First of all, the case doesn't add anything to performance. I really doubt you're going to need any fans. If it gets too hot, back off the OC 100-200 MHz and buy one later for $4. As for the PSU, even a basic name-brand unit is going to cost upwards of $45. If he's on a $400 budget, where do you suggest he make room?

Just to make sure we're on the same page here... You're talking about this case?

http://www.supergooddeal.com/Broadway_C..._Micro_ATX_PC_Case_5_b_p/bcc204sga.htm

A $27 case. Not a single thing is mentioned about the PSU other than "350W". It has no fans. It has almost no ventilation whatsoever. It has tiny little holes on the back. And you're talking about overclocking with it?

I can absolutely appreciate trying to get the best deal, but not a case with no fans that isn't even going to let air in over the CPU, and not 1987 beige (but I guess the black one's only $1 more).

Looks have to matter at least some. $400 might be dirt cheap for a computer, but it's still $400 and you don't want something that looks terrible.

Keep in mind that you're also suggesting a "non-overclocker" model motherboard with a smaller north bridge heatsink and a totally missing south bridge heatsink. That's pretty much the only complaint anybody has with that motherboard is heat. Probably not the best choice of board/case.



Originally posted by: hurtstotalktoyou
Yes. I own three of those mice, myself, and they're all great. I'm sure the keyboard is fine, too.

I just don't see why you would get a totally generic keyboard/mouse when you don't have to. Generic keyboards usually feel terrible.



Originally posted by: hurtstotalktoyou
floppy drive is a very handy item, and it's only $10 or $11.

You don't need a floppy drive to flash the BIOS. You can use WinFlash. And I don't think he'll be running a RAID. I haven't had a floppy in any of my systems for 7 years. I think we've gotten to the point that it's a waste.

You really can't say "it's only $10 or $11." That money would be much better spent improving something like the case.



Originally posted by: hurtstotalktoyou
Ewiz.com and supergooddeal.com both have very low ratings for "return or replacement" on resellerratings.com. I don't think you want to be buying generic dirt cheap stuff from them.

They do? The ratings look just fine to me. I've personally dealt with supergooddeal.com several times over the last two or three years.

Ewiz.com has a 2.79 out of 10.
SuperGoodDeal.com has a 3.06 out of 10.

ZipZoomFly has a 4.70 out of 10, and I've had nothing but good experiences with them, but I wouldn't get a motherboard from them or anybody else below a 5.



Originally posted by: hurtstotalktoyou
I was wondering about the ASRock board, but I can't seem to pin down what kind of voltage and FSB controls it has. All of the reviews talked about a FSB at 250 or less, and he should get a board that can reach 300 minimum.

Well, I really don't think you should emphasize overclocking too much. Obviously you're going to have to run the memory asynchronously when you've got the FSB over 250, which is only going to hurt the onboard graphics performance, and that's the weakest part of the system.

It's really pretty unbelievable that you would suggest turning up the FSB beyond 250 with no case fans, no legitimate ventilation, the stock CPU heatsink, generic RAM, and a motherboard that runs hot and needs a BIOS hack to even overclock at all.
 
your options are quite limited at $400. See if you can nitpick some goodies in the FS/FT forum I'm pretty sure that would brings costs down
 
Originally posted by: Tostada
Just to make sure we're on the same page here... You're talking about this case?

http://www.supergooddeal.com/Broadway_C..._Micro_ATX_PC_Case_5_b_p/bcc204sga.htm

A $27 case. Not a single thing is mentioned about the PSU other than "350W". It has no fans. It has almost no ventilation whatsoever. It has tiny little holes on the back. And you're talking about overclocking with it?

Yes. I'm not sure what the problem is, here. I use nothing but cheapo cases, mostly because I don't care what my PC looks like on the outside. Only one of them has a case fan--ironically, the one that isn't overclocked--and I've had no problems, ever. In fact, let me count how many $20-$40 case/PSU combos I've used... 1, 2, 3... seven generic case/PSU combos. The only problem I've had with any of them is that I left one of the PSUs on the floor one day and my cat chewed through the wires. Now, I know seven is too small of a sample to make sweeping judgments, but I am a believer in at least trying the cheap-o route before upgrading.

I just ordered my seventh case/PSU combo from supergooddeal.com last week--that $29 LCT 400W number. Works like a champ so far. Check it out here.

I can absolutely appreciate trying to get the best deal, but not a case with no fans that isn't even going to let air in over the CPU, and not 1987 beige (but I guess the black one's only $1 more).

I don't have any case fans, and my Sempron is overclocked to 2.4 GHz on retail cooling. I've also got two hard disks, two opticals and some ATI GPU. Yeah, it gets a bit hot in there, but nothing outside of the CPU specs.

Looks have to matter at least some. $400 might be dirt cheap for a computer, but it's still $400 and you don't want something that looks terrible.

I don't think it looks bad at all.

Keep in mind that you're also suggesting a "non-overclocker" model motherboard with a smaller north bridge heatsink and a totally missing south bridge heatsink. That's pretty much the only complaint anybody has with that motherboard is heat. Probably not the best choice of board/case.

Maybe I've been misinformed, but I was told the M7 was a fantastic overclocker, with voltage controls, FSB to 300 and adjustable RAM and HT ratios. With a 2800+, you'll have the HT at 900, which should be fine without a heat sink.

I just don't see why you would get a totally generic keyboard/mouse when you don't have to. Generic keyboards usually feel terrible.

They do? I like them just fine. I don't have that exact model keyboard, but the one I do have is also a cheapie. And those three mice are several years old. I've never have any problems with anything--except I ruined a keyboard once by spilling alcohol all over it. Go figure.

You don't need a floppy drive to flash the BIOS. You can use WinFlash. And I don't think he'll be running a RAID. I haven't had a floppy in any of my systems for 7 years. I think we've gotten to the point that it's a waste.

I still use mine for school. And isn't WinFlash somewhat less reliable?

You really can't say "it's only $10 or $11." That money would be much better spent improving something like the case.

See, I disagree. All the case does is improve looks, and I would much rather have greater functionality. I guess the OP can decide for himself.

Ewiz.com has a 2.79 out of 10.
SuperGoodDeal.com has a 3.06 out of 10.

Sorry; I wasn't clear in my last post. What I meant to say was that ewiz.com and supergooddeal.com seem to have good overall ratings. Any return process is going to be a hassle if the vendor is dozens (or hundreds) of miles away.

Well, I really don't think you should emphasize overclocking too much. Obviously you're going to have to run the memory asynchronously when you've got the FSB over 250, which is only going to hurt the onboard graphics performance, and that's the weakest part of the system.

Are you sure about that? The 2800+ runs fine at 2.4GHz, FSB300, HT900 and DDR200.

It's really pretty unbelievable that you would suggest turning up the FSB beyond 250 with no case fans, no legitimate ventilation, the stock CPU heatsink, generic RAM, and a motherboard that runs hot and needs a BIOS hack to even overclock at all.

With the exception of the motherboard--I have an Epox EP-8KDA3J--I have done just that with my system.
 
Originally posted by: bamacre
I've bought over a dozen mobo's from ZZF within the past 3 weeks. Every one of them were fine.

And they usually will be, but every now and then you get one DOA.

I mean, look at any of the motherboard reviews. All the best motherboards have about 100+ comments on NewEgg, and there are always a few saying, "Hey, this thing sucks! Didn't even work!" or the thing died within a week. It's always a good idea to buy from a place that will work with you on an RMA, but the motherboard moreso than any other component. ZZF is great, but it's just a real hassle to deal with customer service, and they charge you 15% restocking. NewEgg, on the other hand, is great with RMAs.
 
hurtstotalktoyou:

Well, I'm glad everything's working out for you. I would hope you can't fault a guy for being skeptical of generic cases with no PSU info from a place called SuperGoodDeal.com. To be fair, they have decent ratings for a place that's pretty new as long as you don't have to return anything. I'm impressed that you're having good luck overclocking with $26 cases with no fans and no side duct. I'm sure as hell not going to recommend it, but I'm impressed. 🙂

I mean, I'm not one of those guys (like many on here) who is fanatical about recommending 9-million-watt modular $500 PSUs to people who would be fine with the free 350W they got in their Antec... but you're living on the edge.
 
please please please please please please please please please

consider spending just 100 dollars more, you will actually be able to build a system worthy of WoW

Below 500, it is VERY hard to build a machine, it's almost always better to go prebuilt.

500 is the point at which you can actually build something worthwhile.

Oh, and also, OP, use the search function.
 
Originally posted by: dmw16
cant beat dell prices for budget comps

Not for this budget. Not for gaming. The GMA900 on a Dell is worse than the GF6100, and those cheap Dells don't have a PCI-E x16 or an AGP slot. Not to mention that they get you on tax and shipping, so it's not even that good a deal.



Originally posted by: Lasthitlarry
please please please please please please please please please

consider spending just 100 dollars more, you will actually be able to build a system worthy of WoW

Below 500, it is VERY hard to build a machine, it's almost always better to go prebuilt.

500 is the point at which you can actually build something worthwhile.

Oh, and also, OP, use the search function.

I don't think there's anything wrong with a $400 system with a GF6100 board. There are many reviews of the various 6100 boards saying WoW plays fine on low settings with the integrated graphics. So you can have something that plays WoW, and it's perfectly upgradable to a good video card later. You've got a free DDR slot and a free PCI-E x16 slot.

What would you suggest for a $500 system? It's probably going to be about the same as a $400 system with a $100 video card. He wouldn't be losing anything by building the system now for $400 then upgrading the graphics later (as opposed to just waiting till he has $500 or more to build something with better graphics initially).

Besides, video cards get outdated faster than anything. Seems like a very good solution is to build a $400 system now and get a new video card and monitor later on.
 
Originally posted by: Tostada
Originally posted by: bamacre
I've bought over a dozen mobo's from ZZF within the past 3 weeks. Every one of them were fine.

And they usually will be, but every now and then you get one DOA.

I mean, look at any of the motherboard reviews. All the best motherboards have about 100+ comments on NewEgg, and there are always a few saying, "Hey, this thing sucks! Didn't even work!" or the thing died within a week. It's always a good idea to buy from a place that will work with you on an RMA, but the motherboard moreso than any other component. ZZF is great, but it's just a real hassle to deal with customer service, and they charge you 15% restocking. NewEgg, on the other hand, is great with RMAs.

The only thing I've ever had to rma with ZZF was memory, and I have never been charges a restocking fee, and they have always been relatively quick in response. I dunno, I have heard others say the same about rma's with ZZF, and I never have that problem. But I spend a lot of $$ at ZZF, and I've always wondered if that's why I get better service than others say.
 
Originally posted by: bamacre
The only thing I've ever had to rma with ZZF was memory, and I have never been charges a restocking fee, and they have always been relatively quick in response. I dunno, I have heard others say the same about rma's with ZZF, and I never have that problem. But I spend a lot of $$ at ZZF, and I've always wondered if that's why I get better service than others say.

I've had to spend a lot of time on hold with ZZF, and I've tried to call them many times that I just got dumped to a voicemail box. I like them, I'm just saying that when it comes to something like an RMA I think it's worth an extra buck or two to go with NewEgg.

Now a lot of this is probably because I've spent a lot at NewEgg and they totally kiss my ass. Last board I had that died was 45 days after I bought it ... they sent me a replacement and refunded my money. Sounds like you're in about the same boat with ZZF. 🙂

I know a guy who spends about $10K/mo at Newegg and they let him RMA a motherboard that he broke in half (well, it was broken before he broke it in half). They did charge him a restocking fee for that, though.
 
Originally posted by: Jhhnn

Building your own is not cheaper, at all- the purchasing power of the big OEM's and the commoditization of computers makes that a fact...

Uh-huh
There are several people in this thread who did just that. And we won;t even talk about heading over to hot deals and getting $30 HDD's and such.
 
Originally posted by: Tostada
Originally posted by: bamacre
The only thing I've ever had to rma with ZZF was memory, and I have never been charges a restocking fee, and they have always been relatively quick in response. I dunno, I have heard others say the same about rma's with ZZF, and I never have that problem. But I spend a lot of $$ at ZZF, and I've always wondered if that's why I get better service than others say.

I've had to spend a lot of time on hold with ZZF, and I've tried to call them many times that I just got dumped to a voicemail box. I like them, I'm just saying that when it comes to something like an RMA I think it's worth an extra buck or two to go with NewEgg.

Now a lot of this is probably because I've spent a lot at NewEgg and they totally kiss my ass. Last board I had that died was 45 days after I bought it ... they sent me a replacement and refunded my money. Sounds like you're in about the same boat with ZZF. 🙂

I know a guy who spends about $10K/mo at Newegg and they let him RMA a motherboard that he broke in half (well, it was broken before he broke it in half). They did charge him a restocking fee for that, though.

I'm in the same boat as your buddy. 😉
 
Originally posted by: Zebo
Originally posted by: Jhhnn

Building your own is not cheaper, at all- the purchasing power of the big OEM's and the commoditization of computers makes that a fact...

Uh-huh
There are several people in this thread who did just that. And we won;t even talk about heading over to hot deals and getting $30 HDD's and such.

We've all been through this before with dell. If you know what you're doing with Dell Outlet, you can always find systems cheaper than building.

That said, I'd spend more $$ on a BYO than buying one of Dell's low-end systems. Junk. Their mid to high-end desktops though are great.
 
Originally posted by: bamacre
We've all been through this before with dell. If you know what you're doing with Dell Outlet, you can always find systems cheaper than building.

Key point here is that you have to know what you're doing.

I have a cousin (about 14 years old) who loves to play Sims, so her parents got her Sims 2. Then she was complaining that it was pretty much unplayable on their Gateway P3. I told them that for under $700 I could make them a really good machine that could play it. Well, they immediately go out and spend $750 on some old-ass IBM with Intel Extreme Graphics 2 and 256MB RAM. Then of course they ask me why their new computer still can't play Sims 2 for sh*t. All it has is two PCI slots. At that point I couldn't do anything for them but drop another 512MB in it. At least now the game loads in under 5 min.

I guess that little rant is getting OT...
 
Originally posted by: Tostada
Originally posted by: bamacre
We've all been through this before with dell. If you know what you're doing with Dell Outlet, you can always find systems cheaper than building.

Key point here is that you have to know what you're doing.

I have a cousin (about 14 years old) who loves to play Sims, so her parents got her Sims 2. Then she was complaining that it was pretty much unplayable on their Gateway P3. I told them that for under $700 I could make them a really good machine that could play it. Well, they immediately go out and spend $750 on some old-ass IBM with Intel Extreme Graphics 2 and 256MB RAM. Then of course they ask me why their new computer still can't play Sims 2 for sh*t. All it has is two PCI slots. At that point I couldn't do anything for them but drop another 512MB in it. At least now the game loads in under 5 min.

I guess that little rant is getting OT...

😀 Some people are just bad shoppers.
 
My advice-post on the for sale forum what you are looking for. My current(in the porcess of being replaced) system would go for about 350-400 shipped and it is better than any dell you would find for near that price.

Abit nF7-V2
Athlon XP 3200+
1 gig pc 3200 ram
G4 Ti 4600

MUCH better than any dell. Look for a gaming rig for sale on the forums,
 
Originally posted by: Niege
A tech writer friend of mine has this guide to buying an adequate, but cheap PC, on his site.

All of those machines come with 256MB, so by the time you upgraded the RAM you'd be up to about $400 and have much worse graphics than a GF6100.

And that site is a total referral link farm.
 
Back
Top