• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

2020 census to include citizenship question

K1052

Elite Member
WASHINGTON — The 2020 census will ask respondents whether they are United States citizens, the Commerce Department announced Monday night, agreeing to a Trump administration request with highly charged political and social implications that many officials feared would result in a substantial undercount.

In a statement released Monday, the Commerce Department, which oversees the Census Bureau, said Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross had “determined that reinstatement of a citizenship question on the 2020 decennial census questionnaire is necessary to provide complete and accurate census block level data,” allowing the department to accurately measure the portion of the population eligible to vote.

But his decision immediately invited a legal challenge: Xavier Becerra, California’s attorney general, plans to sue the Trump administration over the decision, a spokeswoman for Mr. Becerra said late Monday.

Critics of the change and experts in the Census Bureau itself have said that, amid a fiery immigration debate, the inclusion of a citizenship question could prompt immigrants who are in the country illegally not to respond. That would result in a severe undercount of the population — and, in turn, faulty data for government agencies and outside groups that rely on the census. The effects would also bleed into the redistricting of the House and state legislatures in the next decade.

https://nyti.ms/2pN40b5


This plus the lax preparation for the census itself pretty clearly indicates the intention of the administration to manufacture an undercount for political gain. Also the uses of accurate census data are basically infinite for both the government and business. Not having accurate data is actually a threat to the economy via the decisions that get made in both worlds.
 
From a political point of view, wouldn't undercounting illegal immigrants hurt the GOP? It would remove a lot of population from Texas, Arizona and Florida plus all the smaller southern states, while California is the only big blue state that would be really hurt.
 
From a political point of view, wouldn't undercounting illegal immigrants hurt the GOP? It would remove a lot of population from Texas, Arizona and Florida plus all the smaller southern states, while California is the only big blue state that would be really hurt.

Yes, which is another reason it's so shortsighted. AL for example would be thought to lose a house seat which for a state of that size is kinda a big deal. Some Republicans will benefit at the expense of other Republicans.
 
From a political point of view, wouldn't undercounting illegal immigrants hurt the GOP? It would remove a lot of population from Texas, Arizona and Florida plus all the smaller southern states, while California is the only big blue state that would be really hurt.
Depends on whether most of those would be voting Dem or Rep?
 
It's not just between states, it's within states. Census data would likely be used to shift power even more disproportionately from urban to rural areas.
 
It's not just between states, it's within states. Census data would likely be used to shift power even more disproportionately from urban to rural areas.

It seems that they'll never be satisfied until anybody who lives in a city is entirely disenfranchised. Because even though most people live there it's not Real Merica.
 
It seems that they'll never be satisfied until anybody who lives in a city is entirely disenfranchised. Because even though most people live there it's not Real Merica.

I am always amazed at the entitlement of people who think they deserve to have a greater voice in government simply because they live in a low density zip code.
 
It's not just between states, it's within states. Census data would likely be used to shift power even more disproportionately from urban to rural areas.
Aren't most undocumented immigrants in more rural areas for access to farm jobs?
 
These politicians in their games are failing to realize that a lot more than just house seats comes from the US census. That data is used to allocate all sorts of resources on the state and local level as well as for research purposes. They are basically saying "hey we don't mind medical researchers and public health specialists and civil engineers who will build your bridges and roads not having the best data to do their work"
 
These politicians in their games are failing to realize that a lot more than just house seats comes from the US census. That data is used to allocate all sorts of resources on the state and local level as well as for research purposes. They are basically saying "hey we don't mind medical researchers and public health specialists and civil engineers who will build your bridges and roads not having the best data to do their work"

It's a faith-based post-truth way of doing things. Keep voting Republican for more of the same.
 
oh the horror of the government taking a census of CITIZENS for voting. on and FYI this has been asked in one form or another for a long time. its not new. Its a common-sense question on how many representatives each state gets and money.

also why no outrage on race, sex, marital status. what does that matter to voting?
 
oh the horror of the government taking a census of CITIZENS for voting. on and FYI this has been asked in one form or another for a long time. its not new.

also why no outrage on race, sex, marital status. what does that matter to voting?

Its unsurprising, despite the previous comments explaining it, that you don't understand the point of the census.
 
For those of you constantly bitching about following the constitution, it says census will count people living in the country not just citizens.
Why Jefferson, Madison and the Founders Enshrined the Census in our Constitution
The U.S. Constitution empowers the Congress to carry out the census in "such manner as they shall by Law direct" (Article I, Section 2). The Founders of our fledgling nation had a bold and ambitious plan to empower the people over their new government. The plan was to count every person living in the newly created United States of America, and to use that count to determine representation in the Congress.
 
I didn't see where they were not going to count people that marked the census as a non citizen or where they didn't answer the question at all. I'm pretty sure they are still counted.
They won't be counted if they are hiding from the census takers. They might be hiding because they wouldn't trust the Dept. of Commerce not to share personal information of non-citizens (including last known address) with ICE.
 
Back
Top