2003.5 MazdaSpeed Protege to Hit Dealerships in April

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

vi edit

Elite Member
Super Moderator
Oct 28, 1999
62,484
8,345
126
where were you people when the 1.8T was pumping out 150?

This is true. But VW/Audi wasn't trying to compete with other pocket rocket cars with it either. Well, that and everybody knew you could be pumping out 200HP/250 ft/lbs with a simple $300 mod too :)
 
Jun 18, 2000
11,219
783
126
Originally posted by: LH
Uh, are they really selling that well? I mean all the dealers in my area still have last years models that they were aloted to sell.
The 2001 and 2002 Mazda MP3's were manufactured in limited numbers and sold out extremely quickly. I haven't seen volume numbers for the the 2003 Mazdaspeed Protegé.
 

StageLeft

No Lifer
Sep 29, 2000
70,150
5
0
Originally posted by: gregshin
all you guys talk is HP...this car isnt made for the strip...this car is made for autox and tracks...this car can handle just as good or better then a Integra Type R. I dont bash FWD until you tried a Integra Type R on the tracks. IMHO this car R0x...
Yeah but in that arena the srt4 will spank it!
 

ElFenix

Elite Member
Super Moderator
Mar 20, 2000
102,407
8,595
126
Originally posted by: vi_edit
where were you people when the 1.8T was pumping out 150?

This is true. But VW/Audi wasn't trying to compete with other pocket rocket cars with it either. Well, that and everybody knew you could be pumping out 200HP/250 ft/lbs with a simple $300 mod too :)

how long before similar mods are out for this car?
 

Deeko

Lifer
Jun 16, 2000
30,213
12
81
If you ask me, it looks like a nice car. Sure, it is lacking in hp, but that's it, it looks great, has a great sound system factory, handles great...so it isn't the fastest car on the block. You can't win em all.
 
Apr 5, 2000
13,256
1
0
Originally posted by: Skoorb
Looks nice and not too bad for $20,500. The srt4 still spanks the protege's ass till it's read, but then the protege has other things going for it as well. RagingbitchThe mad indian lives in Canada.

Stupid worthless Canadian money ;)
 

Purgatory-Z

Senior member
Jan 17, 2000
270
0
0
Originally posted by: Gulzakar
WRX is a 24,000$ car... the Mazda still out handles it...


Subaru WRX is a very poorly made car much like the SVT Focus.


Sorry, have to defend my car here. Where can you find a review saying that the WRX is a poorly made car? Every single review I've read is mostly positive. And the WRX is $22k base... That said, you don't see me knocking any cars before I actually get behind the wheel and test drive them....

Cheers to the misinformed,
Purg-Z
 

KokomoGST

Diamond Member
Nov 13, 2001
3,758
0
0
Originally posted by: Skoorb
Originally posted by: gregshin
all you guys talk is HP...this car isnt made for the strip...this car is made for autox and tracks...this car can handle just as good or better then a Integra Type R. I dont bash FWD until you tried a Integra Type R on the tracks. IMHO this car R0x...
Yeah but in that arena the srt4 will spank it!

That's debatable especially for autoX... the Neon's lack of a front LSD means it'll be slower through turns as it can't harness the insane power advantage it has.

Whereas the Protege is able to put down power effectively and rotate the car under throttle pretty friggin well... something an open diff can't really do that well considering it'lll just spin the inside tire. The Neon does handle really well though, and add some Mopar handling mods and it'll prolly keep up quite well.

On a track, the open diff prolly won't hurt as much since the Neon will prolly more than be able to pick up time lost on the straights. I definitely think of the Mazdaspeed as a better TypeR... not quite as gutless in the lower rpm ranges (ie no VTEC).

The reason why it's 170hp and not more is because it's a "hack"... all Callaway did was take the regular NA engine and add boost to it. They didn't rework the internals, etc... so if you turn up the boost with a controller, you'll prolly blow up your engine.

I'd still buy a Miata or SRT4 before the Mazdaspeed though, it's a good buy, but doesn't seem to have much potential without making a "built" engine.
 

vi edit

Elite Member
Super Moderator
Oct 28, 1999
62,484
8,345
126
Heh. Know what would be cool? The MazdaSpeed Protege with the drivetrain from the European Focus RS :D
 
Apr 5, 2000
13,256
1
0
Originally posted by: vi_edit
Heh. Know what would be cool? The MazdaSpeed Protege with the drivetrain from the European Focus RS :D

Bah...I'd rather have the Focus RS itself than a Protege + drivetrain.
 

KokomoGST

Diamond Member
Nov 13, 2001
3,758
0
0
Originally posted by: vi_edit
Heh. Know what would be cool? The MazdaSpeed Protege with the drivetrain from the European Focus RS :D

Bah!!! Just import the whole Focus RS :D
Or even better, the Focus Cosworth... VW Golf R32??? Whut R32?
 

MemnochtheDevil

Senior member
Aug 19, 2001
521
0
0
Originally posted by: ElFenix
Originally posted by: vi_edit
where were you people when the 1.8T was pumping out 150?

This is true. But VW/Audi wasn't trying to compete with other pocket rocket cars with it either. Well, that and everybody knew you could be pumping out 200HP/250 ft/lbs with a simple $300 mod too :)

how long before similar mods are out for this car?

Do we know if this engine can handle the extra boost of a chip? With the 1.8T you could see that an Audi with the same engine was capable of handling the strain, but I don't know of another car that uses this same engine generating more hp. So after market chips capable of delivering big gains might never show up...

 

KokomoGST

Diamond Member
Nov 13, 2001
3,758
0
0
Originally posted by: MemnochtheDevil
Originally posted by: ElFenix
Originally posted by: vi_edit
where were you people when the 1.8T was pumping out 150?

This is true. But VW/Audi wasn't trying to compete with other pocket rocket cars with it either. Well, that and everybody knew you could be pumping out 200HP/250 ft/lbs with a simple $300 mod too :)

how long before similar mods are out for this car?

Do we know if this engine can handle the extra boost of a chip? With the 1.8T you could see that an Audi with the same engine was capable of handling the strain, but I don't know of another car that uses this same engine generating more hp. So after market chips capable of delivering big gains might never show up...

Actually, like I stated before, we know that the Mazdaspeed engine will NOT be a VW 1.8T. It's just too friggin weak of an engine. It'd hole a piston, throw a rod, and then blow the headgasket and finally detonate the crap out of itself or any myriad of boost induced death scenarios.

It's a hack standard NA engine with a turbo slapped on it with low boost to make it live longer. Methinks Mazda might lose money if it turns out that owners keep on blowing up their engines, just like with the RX7s.
 

geno

Lifer
Dec 26, 1999
25,074
4
0
Why the hell are all these pocket rockets 4 doors only? Cmon, give us a 2 door option! :|
 

Gulzakar

Diamond Member
Oct 9, 1999
3,074
0
0
Actually, I did test drive the WRX...and not only did I test the car, my friend works on them. Aside from the rattles and squeaks, the oil leak isn't that big a deal
rolleye.gif


Lets see, first, the engine will start leaking oil... then comes the rattles and squeaks...and then, oh my, the interior pieces seem to start coming off...

oh yeah, that particular WRX was owned by a middle aged man who had about 20,000 miles on the car. I have many more stories if you like... or do you believe everything you read? It's obvious you know very little of cars except "give it gas, go vroom vroom"... so I'll shed some light on the subject:

When your close friend is a car mechanic, you hear many, many stories of the day (to the point your about to scream) and I can tell you the top canidates for cars to avoid:

1. of or pertaining to Ford (this is a given)
2. of or pertaining to Dodge (another given)
3. of or pertaining to Mazda ( mazdas aren't bad cars, but when something goes wrong prepare to file bankruptcy)
4. of or pertaining to Subaru (a car PRONE to oil leaks, blown gaskets, and body "droop")
5. VW (another given, electrical problems like you wouldn't believe) <---- I have some funny stories about this one :)
6. Chevy... just prone to cheap interior materials, boring design, and poor fit and finish. Engines are quite good.

There are more, like Mitsubishi, but I wont go any further.



Cheers to the blind
 

NFS4

No Lifer
Oct 9, 1999
72,636
48
91
Originally posted by: Gulzakar
Actually, I did test drive the WRX...and not only did I test the car, my friend works on them. Aside from the rattles and squeaks, the oil leak isn't that big a deal
rolleye.gif


Lets see, first, the engine will start leaking oil... then comes the rattles and squeaks...and then, oh my, the interior pieces seem to start coming off...

oh yeah, that particular WRX was owned by a middle aged man who had about 20,000 miles on the car. I have many more stories if you like... or do you believe everything you read? It's obvious you know very little of cars except "give it gas, go vroom vroom"... so I'll shed some light on the subject:

When your close friend is a car mechanic, you hear many, many stories of the day (to the point your about to scream) and I can tell you the top canidates for cars to avoid:

1. of or pertaining to Ford (this is a given)
2. of or pertaining to Dodge (another given)
3. of or pertaining to Mazda ( mazdas aren't bad cars, but when something goes wrong prepare to file bankruptcy)
4. of or pertaining to Subaru (a car PRONE to oil leaks, blown gaskets, and body "droop")
5. VW (another given, electrical problems like you wouldn't believe) <---- I have some funny stories about this one :)
6. Chevy... just prone to cheap interior materials, boring design, and poor fit and finish. Engines are quite good.

There are more, like Mitsubishi, but I wont go any further.



Cheers to the blind

LOL, that list sounds about right :p
 

Purgatory-Z

Senior member
Jan 17, 2000
270
0
0
Originally posted by: Gulzakar
Actually, I did test drive the WRX...and not only did I test the car, my friend works on them. Aside from the rattles and squeaks, the oil leak isn't that big a deal
rolleye.gif


Lets see, first, the engine will start leaking oil... then comes the rattles and squeaks...and then, oh my, the interior pieces seem to start coming off...

oh yeah, that particular WRX was owned by a middle aged man who had about 20,000 miles on the car. I have many more stories if you like... or do you believe everything you read? It's obvious you know very little of cars except "give it gas, go vroom vroom"... so I'll shed some light on the subject:

When your close friend is a car mechanic, you hear many, many stories of the day (to the point your about to scream) and I can tell you the top canidates for cars to avoid:

1. of or pertaining to Ford (this is a given)
2. of or pertaining to Dodge (another given)
3. of or pertaining to Mazda ( mazdas aren't bad cars, but when something goes wrong prepare to file bankruptcy)
4. of or pertaining to Subaru (a car PRONE to oil leaks, blown gaskets, and body "droop")
5. VW (another given, electrical problems like you wouldn't believe) <---- I have some funny stories about this one :)
6. Chevy... just prone to cheap interior materials, boring design, and poor fit and finish. Engines are quite good.

There are more, like Mitsubishi, but I wont go any further.



Cheers to the blind


Firstly, this will be my last post on this subject, regardless of how witty the impending reply will be =). I'm sure you've known someone who had a Subaru breakdown on them.. I'm also sure you have a friend who is a mechanic that has bad experiences with many cars (he's a mechanic, ALL they see is broken cars, all day). However, I own a WRX (and not only can I drive it well, I perform most of the work/mods myself). I disagree with you, because they aren't known for blown gaskets. It's called operator error. Stick a n00b driver and a MBC(the cheapest bang for the buck in terms of pure HP gain, around $40) on a WRX and kiss the engine goodbye when he runs lean from PTFB. I'll agree with you on the rattling part, eventually the white plastic connectors that hold the upper part of the dash together start to wiggle, fixable with $4 in parts. You mistated the price, though. A WRX sells for $22.7k, according to kbb invoice (I paid $200 over invoice myself). Clearly you have a knowledge of cars, and I respect that. But instead of lashing out in a quasi insulting "you don't know jack about cars, and I do + here's why" post simply because I stated my opinion, take slightly less offense and shrug it off =).

Cheers,
Purg-Z
 

CraigRT

Lifer
Jun 16, 2000
31,440
5
0
Originally posted by: Tiles2Tech
Originally posted by: vi_edit
Hate to say it, but there really is no reason to buy this over the new Neon SRT-4 :(

The dodge whoops it's ass.
Yes, but the Neon is a Dodge. Have you recently owned a Chrysler product? For anyone considering the Neon SRT-4, just ensure you buy the extended warranty to protect you until 100,000 miles. Also, ensure that there is a loan car provision in the warranty, because I have a feeling you're going to need it.

you obviously haven't owned a Dodge. Neons are very reliable cars.
 

fyleow

Platinum Member
Jan 18, 2002
2,915
0
0
You guys do realize that the A4 only has 170 hp and 166 lb of torque right? It's a turbo 1.8 as well. I don't care though, I'd still hit...err I mean driver the A4
 

isildur

Golden Member
Jan 3, 2001
1,509
0
76
Just picked up an 03 msp on Saturday, paid the 20,500 msrp.

Sure its not as fast as a WRX, but its a good $5k cheaper (if you want to have ANY options on the WRX), I prefer both the interior and exterior styling, and it comes with a MUCH better audio system.

Sure its not as fast as an SRT, but I don't care for the look of the neon either and by all accounts it's handling is better than the dodge.

Plus, at 1200# cw, those 170 horses go a pretty long way - I'm only at 220 miles so we're taking it easy on that t25, but she'll pick up and go nicely and holy sheyit is it fun to drive.

If you can find someone to let you drive one and you're looking at this type of car in this price range (i.e. STI/Evo VIII are out of range) DEFINITELY give this guy a chance, the whole is VASTLY greater than the sum of its parts.

;)
 

NutBucket

Lifer
Aug 30, 2000
27,179
649
126
You guys bashing Subarus for having oil leaks should look a little more into it. Coming from a very reputable Porsche/BMW/Benz shop I was told that they only guarantee no leaks on 911s (air cooled). If there's a drip, then there's a drip. Its a problem inherent to boxer motors as far as I can tell. Flame me if you like or just tell me Porsche can't design a motor
rolleye.gif
 

BigSmooth

Lifer
Aug 18, 2000
10,484
12
81
Originally posted by: isildur
Just picked up an 03 msp on Saturday, paid the 20,500 msrp.

Sure its not as fast as a WRX, but its a good $5k cheaper (if you want to have ANY options on the WRX), I prefer both the interior and exterior styling, and it comes with a MUCH better audio system.
Congrats on the new car... paying full MSRP, though? Yikes! :Q

You could have easily gotten a pretty loaded, lightly used '02 WRX for that. Sounds like you like the Protege more anyway, though, so I am sure you'll be happy with it. :) A neighbor has one in that bright orange color, definitely an attention-getter.
 

prodigy

Lifer
Oct 9, 1999
14,822
1
0
Congrats on the new ride, which color did you get?

Originally posted by: isildur
Just picked up an 03 msp on Saturday, paid the 20,500 msrp.

Sure its not as fast as a WRX, but its a good $5k cheaper (if you want to have ANY options on the WRX), I prefer both the interior and exterior styling, and it comes with a MUCH better audio system.

Sure its not as fast as an SRT, but I don't care for the look of the neon either and by all accounts it's handling is better than the dodge.

Plus, at 1200# cw, those 170 horses go a pretty long way - I'm only at 220 miles so we're taking it easy on that t25, but she'll pick up and go nicely and holy sheyit is it fun to drive.

If you can find someone to let you drive one and you're looking at this type of car in this price range (i.e. STI/Evo VIII are out of range) DEFINITELY give this guy a chance, the whole is VASTLY greater than the sum of its parts.

;)