Originally posted by: mindless1
Originally posted by: ThisIsMatt
After buying two from newegg refurbs and having both arrive as pieces of crap, I went ahead and picked up one of these. I have a lot more faith in this than those at newegg, which have most likely been OC'd to death as one of the ones I recieved obviously had been. You won't find a 128MB 8x DVI/VGA/TV version at newegg for $70 anyways. They're normally at least $85.
You sound a little unfairly biased... many people report no problems from Newegg refurbs, and after all you know what the card is, so if it's "crap" it's not a surprise, it would've been crap new. Some Asus and MSI cards depart from the nVidia reference design by a lot, but for the most part all the cards are pretty much the same except for the heatsink, type of capacitors used, and the memory speed. We already know that the Asus card has an inferior heatsink (if it is as pictured) but no detail yet about the memory. The caps look ok but there are only enough of them to qualify as the low-end TI4200 part, not the larger count associated with "higher-end" 4800, 4400 or 4600 cards.
What's the significance of "OC'd to death"? They only take RMAs for 30 days, right? So IF it's been OC'd for <30 days, that's hardly much wear if you're also going to o'c the card, rather IF the card still works I'd see it as proof that the card (so far) can tolerate a little o'c. BTW, what evidence do you have that these cards were o'c ? If anything, I would expect any knowledgeable user to o'c the card somewhat, as part of a burn-in to see if the card is worth keeping.