• We should now be fully online following an overnight outage. Apologies for any inconvenience, we do not expect there to be any further issues.

Z68 Perspectives Please

Johnbear007

Diamond Member
Jul 1, 2002
4,570
0
0
Hi!

It's been awhile but I'm building again and I've been reading forums and reviews about Z68. I plan on doing an i5 2500k, 16 GB of ram (I work with some very large RAW files in lightroom etc.) and will carry over my HD 4890 (which may get upgraded later and I'd like the posibility of crossfire). Already have a Corsair AX750 and it's going into a Corsair Carbid 500R. 1 64GB Samsung SATA 3 SSD boot drive, and 120 GB Kingstons HyperX SATA3 general drive. I'll have a SATA2 DVD burner and that's it. I won't be loading up on more SATA devices. My day to day computing/media consumption etc will all be done on my macbook pro. This machine is all about gaming and some photo editing. I don't care at all about the sound options as I'll be using an external USB DAC/AMP with headphones.


I keep all of my music and backups etc on an external drive and timecapsule.. I don't need any more storage in this machine as it's primary use will be gaming + photo editing with the finished photos being archived to a network or USB drive.

I will overclock the i5 to whatever it will easily take but I have no plans to tinker endlessly in the bios to squeeze out tiny bits of performance :)


So after all that here is my problem. I've read some good reviews of many boards. Oddly Anandtech is VERY sparse on Z68 reviews. Each time I decide on a board I check the reviews on newegg and there are many AWFUL reviews for all of the boards, which is unusual to me....

Gigabyte seems to boot loop, Asrock has DOA issues, Asus has an extreme number of customer complaints about their customer service to which they add canned responses to over and over again on newegg, MSI doesn't seem to offer anything compelling and I wasn't really all that impressed with the stability of the p35 platinum I have right now.

It doesn't seem to matter if it's a 300$ board or a 120$ board there are problems everywhere more than I've ever seen when researching a build before.

My question is, am I missing something? Or do all of these products have awful quality control this time around on this chipset?

I don't want a p67 board because I'd like the option of PCIe 3.0 and Ivy bridge in the future and I'd like to be able to take advantage of the Sandy Bridge GPU, because it's there. Which is why I wanted to go z68 but they all look like garbage.

I narrowed it down to the way too expensive asus pwhatever deluxe for 269$ or the Asrock Extreme3 Gen 3.

I don't really need the features of the Asus board but it's the only board on newegg that has consistently good reviews. (although only 17 of them).

Thoughts? Am I missing a source of information?

Thanks for any input.
 

Magusigne

Golden Member
Nov 21, 2007
1,550
0
76
I like my board:) Booted up right away.

My friend is on his second board (I'm posting about it now..could be operator error) which is a Asus P8Z68-V Pro

Don't be too afraid of the Asrock...I love mine.

Edit: And yes all these boards have been having QA issues...no clue on that one.
 
Last edited:

Johnbear007

Diamond Member
Jul 1, 2002
4,570
0
0
I've had an Asrock board in the past and it did work well for me. I suppose that any of these current gen boards are a bit of a gamble but I think I'll go with one of the Asrock boards. The price premium of the Asus boards just doesn't seem to be worth it considering that (from what I can take from newegg reviews) the Asus and other big name boards don't seem to be any more reliable.
 

Johnbear007

Diamond Member
Jul 1, 2002
4,570
0
0
And as I think of it more.... We see a lot of reviews of new hardware and that's great. But many of the boards I'm sure I sent by the manufacturer, maybe hand picked. It would be nice to see reviews that are done with boards bought from retail. Even if that's not feasible it would be nice to see updates about reliability etc. Sure, it's nice to see reviews of all these boards but they get tested and that's that. Is there anywhere on the web that does reliability updates I wonder?

As I browse the first page of this forum I notice most of the posts are about problems with Asus boards... The last time I built (which has been maybe 2 or three years) There were reliable products out there. It's sad to see that seems to have changed. I'm not looking to go cheap, I'm looking for reliable.... maybe an intel board?
 

cantholdanymore

Senior member
Mar 20, 2011
447
0
76
Maybe there are a lot of newbs out there, and we tend to complain a lot. I had no a single issue with my first rig below
 

Meghan54

Lifer
Oct 18, 2009
11,684
5,228
136
As I browse the first page of this forum I notice most of the posts are about problems with Asus boards... The last time I built (which has been maybe 2 or three years) There were reliable products out there. It's sad to see that seems to have changed. I'm not looking to go cheap, I'm looking for reliable.... maybe an intel board?



Honestly, I'd not give reliability another thought with an Asus board. Been using them for years and almost without exception they've been rock solid. My current board is a Maximus Gene-Z and love it. Again, not a single problem. Wife's board is an AsRock Z68 Pro-M and again, solid. Had a Gigabyte Z68-UD3H also set up and no problems, but the BIOS is dated in comparison to the AsRock and Asus boards.
 

Mem

Lifer
Apr 23, 2000
21,476
13
81
Maybe there are a lot of newbs out there, and we tend to complain a lot. I had no a single issue with my first rig below

No issues with my Asus z68 V/Gen3 board,you always find some people posting issues infact you can find issues with every brand if you use Google,just remember brands like Asus/Gigabyte sell more boards due to being popular brands so are more in the spot light when things go wrong.
 

Johnbear007

Diamond Member
Jul 1, 2002
4,570
0
0
Thanks for the input, I suppose I was just suprised. I'm thinking it may be that there are more novices in the hobby these days? That would explain some of it. I imagine many boards that are thought to be DOA are not actually DOA, they're being shorted out by a bad mounting job etc. etc. etc. I decided to go with the Asrock Extreme 3 Gen 3 and I'm really looking forward to it.
 

Meghan54

Lifer
Oct 18, 2009
11,684
5,228
136
Good choice from what I've read and heard. I really think a lot of user error is going on....of course, there is hardware failure, but with that, I tend to judge on how the company handles the problem, not discount the company because a part failed.

For instance, just because the wife's Asus mb had a slot fail didn't dissuade me from buying a Maximus IV Gene-Z motherboard. And my Gene-Z is percolating along fine, running my 2600k at 4.6GHz without breaking a sweat.