Your top games of all time

Kabob

Lifer
Sep 5, 2004
15,248
0
76
I'm sure this has been done a million times on the forums but I figured I'd make my list and check yours as well. These are PC and console games mixed in.


My top 10 games:

10. Goldeneye 64 ? The first FPS I ever played at any length (sure I played Doom and Wolfenstein, but not much). Wonderfully designed (even if the textures were really bland) and it was fun to play! While the aiming was a bit rough everything else was great.

9. Star Wars Jedi Knight: Jedi Outcast/Academy ? One of my most played multiplayer games ever. Every Star Wars geek?s dream, you make your own Jedi and duel! The biggest fault is that it might have been overly simple but that didn?t stop me from loving it.

8. Mario Kart 64 ? Quite possibly the best party game ever. Wonderfully simple racing at its best, and it was the kind of game that anyone, video game savvy or not, could enjoy.

7. Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare ? Probably the best multiplayer FPS game I?ve played. After playing CoD 3 I wasn?t expecting much and it blew me away. Perks are a brilliant idea, fantastic fast paced action through the entire game, and even starting at level 1 in multiplayer I never felt horribly outgunned.

6. Lords of the Realm II ? A RTS mixed with a turn based strategy game that plays much more into economy and politics. An excellent strategy game and probably my first ever video game addiction.

5. Tekken 3/Tag ? The best fighting games ever. After Tag the series got WAY too technical.

4. Resident Evil 4 ? I HATE horror games but this one was so well designed and so much fun to play that I couldn?t put it down. The first over the shoulder TPS that I know of only sucked you more into the action. Played through the game 5 to 6 times.

3. Gears of War ? One of the games that didn?t blow my expectations away simply because my expectations were so high. It easily matched them though, fantastic graphics, great single player, fun multiplayer, still a favorite. A few weapon power balance issues IMHO (how many people actually use the hammerburst?) but easily looked past. Cover system is a great idea and was one of the few games I felt it worked correctly.

2. Medal of Honor: Allied Assault ? Possibly the only WWII game I?d consider to be great. The last of the dying run and gun genre with no aiming and no recoil to worry about. Fantastic SP and MP.

1. Diablo II ? The ultimate addiction. This to me is what WoW is to everyone else. My entire freshman/sophomore year of college was devoted to this game, which I?ve played for thousands and thousands of hours I?m sure. Fantastic story and game play make up for so-so graphics. This will never get old?ever.


Others I loved:

11. Unreal Tournament ? Had trouble deciding between Goldeneye and this as my #10 game. Went with Goldeneye as I think I enjoyed it a little more and I?d consider it more ?revolutionary? to the gaming world.
t12. Mario 64 ? One of the best platform games ever, the first ?3d? adventure game I got into.
t12. Zelda: A Link to the Past ? Probably put this as my favorite action adventure game ever.
14. Marvel vs. Capcom ? Mayhem in the form of a fighting game.
15. Final Fantasy VIII ? My favorite RPG game. Better story/fighting than FF7
-Castlevania: Symphony of the Night ? Another great action adventure/RPG.
-Super Smash Bros ? So far from the traditional fighter game yet a great party game.
-Metroid Prime ? Wonderfully designed FPS with unique gameplay and controls.
-Warcraft III ? My favorite pure RTS game. Heroes made this game stand out.
-Soldier of Fortune II ? Not well known or heavily played but I played lots of MP. Very realistic compared to the typical shooter out there.
-Prince of Persia: Sands of Time ? Wasn?t expecting this game to be so great. Combat was overly simple but story and gameplay made up for it.
-SSX3 - Not huge into sports games but I thought SSX3 was fantastic. Love the huge amount of moves that you could mix and match and the fact that you could board from the top of the mountain to the bottom seamlessly.
-America?s Army ? The best free game you?ll ever find.
-Max Payne 2: The Fall of Max Payne - Fantastic graphics for it's time and great slow-mo combat.
-Powerstone ? I only got to play this once or twice, wish I?d had more time. I love the 4 player open ended combat.
-Soul Calibur ? Tekken with weapons?sorta. Not quite as enjoyable and ?masterable? as Tekken was but great nonetheless.
-Counter Strike/Source ? Probably not ranked as high as it would be for most people. I played it a lot but really it wasn?t all that mind boggling. Didn?t bring anything new to the table other than having to purchase your own equipment.
-Vagrant Story ? A unique combat system and fun story made this a great game.
-Gran Turismo ? The first true tuner game with lots of cars and lots of mods.
-Viewtiful Joe ? Another game made great by an interesting combat system.


Games that dissappointed me:

-Metroid Prime 2 ? Paled in comparison to the first.
-World of Warcraft ? I tried SO hard to like this game, it just didn?t do anything for me.
-Guild Wars ? Actually played this game for a while, although I think the title MMO is a bit of a stretch. Just not that great.
-Unreal Tournament 2003/4 ? Considering how much hype 2K4 got I was expecting an awe inspiring experience. I was sadly disappointed.
-Half Life ? A definite ?meh? for me.
-Prince of Persia: Warrior Within almost as bad as Sands of Time was good.
-Quake 3 ? I figure you have to like either Unreal Tournament or Quake 3, you can?t like both. I loved UT, just couldn?t get into Quake.
-Starcraft ? Not a bad game but just not up to par with the Warcraft series.
-Zelda: Windwaker ? Cell shading disappointment.
-Final Fantasy VII ? I?m sure I?ll take more flak for this than anything. I thought that FF8 was simply a better and more entertaining game. Iffy graphics, so-so combat, and a decentish story (Granted Materia was fantastic). Was a fun game, but greatly over-hyped.
-Halo (1/2/3) - Another game I could just never seem to get into. The story/combat/graphics just didn't do much for me.
 

JoPh

Diamond Member
Aug 8, 2002
7,312
1
76
quake
subspace
diablo2
quakeworld teamfortress
quake 3 teamfortress
cs (back in beta)
halo 2

these are the games i played the most out of anything.
 

xboxist

Diamond Member
Jun 25, 2002
3,017
1
81
The problem with topics like this is that I dwell on what I think my favorites are. Then I pull a few of them out and start playing them for eleven days straight. I forget about this thread.
 

xboxist

Diamond Member
Jun 25, 2002
3,017
1
81
Originally posted by: erwos
Picking 10 and then listing thirty is a serious cop-out.

Sorry, but that's absurd. He chose his 10, and then went onto his honorable mention list. What, you're not allowed to like games past your favorite 10 or something?
 

Drekce

Golden Member
Sep 29, 2000
1,398
0
76
In no particular order (other than platform)

PC:
Half Life 1/2 (+ Episodes)
Psychonauts (out of nowhere; such a killer game)
Command & Conquer
Tie Fighter
Grim Fandango

X360:
Rock Band (sorry, but it beats out GH)
COD: 4

Wii:
Super Mario Galaxy

GC:
RE: 4

SNES:
Super Mario World (almost put SMB:3 for NES)


I am shocked that there are no PlayStation 1/2 games on there. I'm sure if I could actually recall every game I have ever played this would change some, but alas, my memory sucks.
 

oznerol

Platinum Member
Apr 29, 2002
2,476
0
76
www.lorenzoisawesome.com
All-time, probably Rock Band. If not that, then Tetris.

For nostalgia purposes, I might be inclined to say Chrono Trigger, FF II/III (US), or Earthbound. Though my tastes have changed a bit since the SNES JRPG days.

For sheer playing time, I'd go with WoW (haven't played in years, though), Counterstrike, Advance Wars, or Madden.

Recently, Dead Rising just made me very satisfied every time I played it for some reason. Crackdown had a similar effect.
 

erwos

Diamond Member
Apr 7, 2005
4,778
0
76
Originally posted by: xboxist
Originally posted by: erwos
Picking 10 and then listing thirty is a serious cop-out.

Sorry, but that's absurd. He chose his 10, and then went onto his honorable mention list. What, you're not allowed to like games past your favorite 10 or something?
Yes, because it's hedging. Not to mention that he actually numbered 11-15, too.

Picking 10 means you make a decision about which ones you liked best. Picking 10 and listing 30 means you really don't have firm beliefs on your favorite games.
 

Kabob

Lifer
Sep 5, 2004
15,248
0
76
Originally posted by: erwos
Originally posted by: xboxist
Originally posted by: erwos
Picking 10 and then listing thirty is a serious cop-out.

Sorry, but that's absurd. He chose his 10, and then went onto his honorable mention list. What, you're not allowed to like games past your favorite 10 or something?
Yes, because it's hedging. Not to mention that he actually numbered 11-15, too.

Picking 10 means you make a decision about which ones you liked best. Picking 10 and listing 30 means you really don't have firm beliefs on your favorite games.

Or it means I like more than 10 games but listed what my top 10 were plus a few others. Is it really that hard to interpret? xboxist didn't seem to have that problem.

Notice the title is "your top games" not your top 10...

If ya can't handle it then go suck a popsicle (mmmmmm, popsicles)
 

CasioTech

Diamond Member
Oct 1, 2000
7,145
9
0
the usual... most capcom games, re4, metroid gba games, yoshi's island, metal slug maybe, doa2.

I don't really have favorites, just mood swings which control my gaming tastes.
 

Kabob

Lifer
Sep 5, 2004
15,248
0
76
Originally posted by: CasioTech
I don't really have favorites, just mood swings which control my gaming tastes.

Hehe, half the games I play are for that reason. Enter Viva Pinata.
 

mxyzptlk

Golden Member
Apr 18, 2008
1,888
0
0
In no particular order and with no justification for any of them...


Castlevania: SOTN,
Super Mario World 1 and 2
Earthworm Jim
Quake 3
Unreal Tournament
Road Rash
Mario Kart (any of them, as far as I'm concerned they haven't made a bad one yet)
Super Mario Galaxy (the other 3D mario games between SMW and SMG are probably good, but I've never owned any of them)
Final Fantasy 3 (US) and 9
Max Payne 1 and 2

And finally Wing Commander Prophecy Gold: Special Ops. <-- This shit was seriously fun. Are there any modern, easily accessible, space shooter/dogfighting games? I have no interest in grinding in anything that even resembles an MMO and I don't want something to fly with a mouse.. gamepad or joystick only please. I don't want to trade or farm or do anything other than shoot bullets, lasers and/or missiles at aliens. Something as easy to pick up as the blazing angels games.. but set in space, not ww2.



ninja edit: also, that list is in order and there is a reason why SOTN is at the top of it.
 

ggnl

Diamond Member
Jul 2, 2004
5,095
1
0
I hate to say it but WoW wins out for me. Even though I could fill many pages writing about its many flaws, I still spent thousands of hours playing it. I doubt I'll ever play another game where I get so invested in the character development.

Sadly though, WoW addiction got the best of me, so I've sworn off MMORPGs entirely. I guess you could say it was too good.
 

FuryofFive

Golden Member
Sep 7, 2005
1,544
9
71
in not set order, and im at work so its all of the top of my head

PC titles i can think of
Quake 2(PC) - need i say more.. edge
UT2004(PC) - Team arenamaster ruled this game
R6 (PC) - old school matches on xl2000
Doom series(PC,SNES) - its doom
Starcraft/Broodwar(PC) - BGH maps and money maps
command + conquer series(PC,PS1) freakin NOD
COD4(PC) - well its COD
Half-life series(PC) - silent but deadly

Earthworm jim(SNES) - snot a problem
Streets of rage(Sega genesis) hit the floor?
tony hawk 1 (PS1) soundtrack anyone?
zombies ate my neighbors(SNES) awesome top down horror movie spoof game heh


the list could go on....
 

Kabob

Lifer
Sep 5, 2004
15,248
0
76
Originally posted by: ggnl
I hate to say it but WoW wins out for me. Even though I could fill many pages writing about its many flaws, I still spent thousands of hours playing it. I doubt I'll ever play another game where I get so invested in the character development.

Sadly though, WoW addiction got the best of me, so I've sworn off MMORPGs entirely. I guess you could say it was too good.

I've had a friend's marriage almost end due to WoW, so you're not alone there. He was turning "it" down to play WoW with his clan mates.

I'm glad I didn't get into it, it would utterly consume me I'm sure.
 

Yreka

Diamond Member
Jul 6, 2005
4,084
0
76
10. Mass Effect - Very immersive + fun.. Would have scored much higher if there was more variety on the level design and side quests.

9. Golden Eye - Would have forgotten it if it werent for the other lists, but this was our ( my group of friends at the time ) first forrey into a fragfest. I had played games like it on my PC, but none of my other personal friends were into PC gaming. Something infanatly more satisfying about fragging people you actually know ;)

8. NFL 2K5 - Because I love football games, and this is the best one they have made to date. Runner up to the 3rd tecmo bowl though, we had tons of fun with that one.

7. Bioshock - There were millions before it, this game somehow managed to feel different and fun throughout the game. I actually played through it a 2nd time for achievements ( this NEVER happens with me)

6. Civilization - My first "holy shit, is that the sun coming up?" experience

5. Half Life 1 - Completely blew me away when it came out.. HL2 actually did the same thing, so it gets a runner up here.

4.Zelda 1 - My first "rpg"

3. Diablo 1 - My first online game.. Popped my cherry by a high level char taking me down in the dungeon to "help me out", then WTFPwning me. Aaah good ol newb days.

2. Final Fantasy 7 .. Most immersive game up until this point.. Even my "non rpg" friends were playing it.

1. Everquest 1 & 2 - Gonna list them both since 2 felt like it grew and continued from. I acutally miss places I used to hang out and level / raid when I think back on them.. Like a favorite park, or camping spot you remember as a kid. The people, the interaction... Amazing fun.. I don't play anymore, I just dont have the time to dedicate, but I will always hold fond memories. My wife even talks about starting up again once the kids get older.
 

FuryofFive

Golden Member
Sep 7, 2005
1,544
9
71
Originally posted by: kabob983
Originally posted by: ggnl
I hate to say it but WoW wins out for me. Even though I could fill many pages writing about its many flaws, I still spent thousands of hours playing it. I doubt I'll ever play another game where I get so invested in the character development.

Sadly though, WoW addiction got the best of me, so I've sworn off MMORPGs entirely. I guess you could say it was too good.

I've had a friend's marriage almost end due to WoW, so you're not alone there. He was turning "it" down to play WoW with his clan mates.

I'm glad I didn't get into it, it would utterly consume me I'm sure.

my ex-gf left me because her wow addiction got the best of her... too bad heh she found a lovely wow guy to take my place...FYI i played wow haha :)

wow is solid though
 

JPB

Diamond Member
Jul 4, 2005
4,064
89
91
Top 10 ALL TIME

1) Final Fantasy 2 ( U.S Version ) (SNES )

2) Devil May Cry 4 ( PS3 )

3) Legend Of Zelda A Link To The Past ( SNES )

4) Legend Of Zelda: Ocarina Of Time ( N64 )

5) Super Mario RPG Legend Of The Seven Stars (SNES )

6) Super Mario 64 ( N64 )

7) Final Fantasy 3 ( U.S Version ( SNES )

8) Legend Of Zelda Twilight Princess ( Wii )

9) Marvel Ultimate Alliance ( PS3 )

10) Super Mario All-Stars ( SNES )



Honorable Mention

Double Dragon ( NES )

Double Dragon II ( NES )

Double Dragon III ( NES )

Mike Tyson's Punch Out ( NES )

Resident Evil Zero ( Gamecube )

Eternal Darkness ( Gamecube )

Star Fox Adventures ( Gamecube )

Gears Of War ( Xbox 360 )

Resident Evil 4 ( Wii )

Ninja Gaiden Sigma ( PS3 )

Heavenly Sword ( PS3 )

Uncharted Drakes Fortune ( PS3 )

Sonic The Hedgehog ( Genesis )

The Legend Of Zelda: The Wind Waker ( Gamecube )
 

GarfieldtheCat

Diamond Member
Jan 7, 2005
3,708
1
0
Not in order:

Civilization - enough said

Alpha Centauri - Civ I with customizable units in the future

Doom I - First of a kind

Falcon 3.0 - Ultimate combat flight sim

Pacific War - classic Gary Grigsby WWII strategy game

F-19 Stealth Fighter - Loved the promotion/medal scheme, and having to avoid radar to bomb anything

Red Storm Rising - wire guided torpedoes and 688 class subs!

Wing Commander I and II - First real space sim for me

Jedi Knight II - Didn't like the first JK, loved this one with the story of KK.

Knights of the Old Republic - First RPG I played (and played, and replayed, etc...)

 

potato28

Diamond Member
Jun 27, 2005
8,964
0
0
I never have any order to these:

Diablo 2 - Holy crap this consumed me for a long time

Counter Strike Source - Still play it, for some reason I can't put it down

Team Fortress 2 - It's just too much fun on my main servers....

Battletoads - I had to.

Rise of Nations - Best RTS that I've played in a long time, played a lot of it last year

StarCraft - RTS love ;) I love the Blizzard games, and the balance is still great in this game to this date

Sonic 1 - One of the first games that I ever beat, I will never forget that day at 3:31 when I beat it myself

REZ - Self explanatory if you've played it, I just suck at it lately.

Pokemon Blue/ Red - I can't remember a time in a 2 year period where I didn't play this game at all, I even think that old Gameboy was broken from my long periods of playing

Audiosurf - Great visualization game for music, but not very interpretive of the actual music. Really fun and crazy on the higher difficulties :p
 

Kev

Lifer
Dec 17, 2001
16,367
4
81
In order of how they pop into my head:
Counter-Strike... I remember all nighters playing this in college
Super Mario 64
TIE Fighter
Call of Duty 4
Metal Gear Solid 4
Battlefield 1942
Half-Life
Mechwarrior 2 - Even though my computer sucked and I needed a boot disk just to play it
Mass Effect
WoW
 

JPB

Diamond Member
Jul 4, 2005
4,064
89
91
Wasn't this thread intended for console games only ?

If PC games can be added, I had quite a few of those as well.
 

skace

Lifer
Jan 23, 2001
14,488
7
81
How impossible it is to create a single list of all the games across all time and only pick 10. I tried, yet I'm not sure I even agree with myself...

10. Quest for Glory: So you want to be a Hero
09. Shining Force 2
08. Street Fighter 2
07. Everquest
06. Jagged Alliance
05. Counter-Strike Beta (CS was in beta for a very, very long time. It was a different game back then too)
04. Legend of Zelda: A link to the Past
03. Starcraft
02. Final Fantasy 6
01. Quake 1
 

Shadowknight

Diamond Member
May 4, 2001
3,959
3
81
Not in any particualr order:
1. Planescape: Torment
2. Fallout
3. Fallout 2
4. Final Fantasy
5. Metal Gear Solid
6. Half-Life
7. Vampire the Masquerade: Bloodlines
8. Baldur's Gate II
9. Icewind Dale
10. Final Fantasy Legend