YAGT: mutual breakups are the worst

apac

Diamond Member
Apr 12, 2003
6,212
0
71
Well, my gf of 2 years and I just split. She's always been on shaky terms with the long term commitment, probably due to family history and her divorced parents. Long story short, she said that she can't handle the stress of not knowing whether she wants this relationship to be more permanent or not, and pretty much decided to end the relationship rather than make the decision. This is something she came to after many months of thinking about it, so it wasn't any spur of the moment emo sh!t. We both agreed that we still love each other, but I told her I needed to know if she was in this for the long haul before she graduated and went off to work/med school/etc.

:beer:s with the mates last night was good, but man does that morning after a breakup kick you in the balls.
 

FlamingDouchebag

Junior Member
Mar 9, 2007
20
0
0
That's what I was thinking.

Though I can see the op's point... If there's no defining breakup moment, you kind of wonder if maybe you didn't really breakup? Just separated? Could mayabe get back together?
 

rocadelpunk

Diamond Member
Jul 23, 2001
5,589
1
81
aren't they the best?

Don't have to deal with unecessary crying and telling the girl "oh we'll still be friends."
 

amish

Diamond Member
Aug 20, 2004
4,295
6
81
Originally posted by: rocadelpunk
aren't they the best?

Don't have to deal with unecessary crying and telling the girl "oh we'll still be friends."

yes, i think they are the best. there is a strong possibility for breakup sex too when the breakup is mutual.
 

sixone

Lifer
May 3, 2004
25,030
4
61
She sounds like she really cares for you, even though her personal stuff is a huge problem. It is much easier to give up the other person when you have anger to help you deal with the loss.

rose.gif

 

Mucho

Guest
Oct 20, 2001
8,231
2
0
I strongly disagree, my 2nd ex and I talk on the phone at least 3 times a week and its unusual for us to have dinner together.
 

xtknight

Elite Member
Oct 15, 2004
12,974
0
71
Wasn't in your control, dude. You've saved yourself some future trouble. Love is always troublesome especially in that sort of situation. Thankfully she loved you enough that she had the courage to do the right thing to save you from even more stress in the future. As long as your relationship doesn't have any other barriers I don't see this as a reason to permanently stay apart. She's prolly just saying that so you don't get your hopes up or anything but she'll want to talk to you again sometime in the near future. Honesty is true love.
 

RichardE

Banned
Dec 31, 2005
10,246
2
0
Originally posted by: shortspanishguy
I don't know about that. Would you rather walk in on your girl with some dude's pecker in her mouth?

Will she share at least?
 

apac

Diamond Member
Apr 12, 2003
6,212
0
71
Originally posted by: sixone
She sounds like she really cares for you, even though her personal stuff is a huge problem. It is much easier to give up the other person when you have anger to help you deal with the loss.

rose.gif

She does, it really tore her apart to say all of the things she did. Every time I try to turn to anger and spite all of that just comes right back.

Originally posted by: xtknight
Wasn't in your control, dude. You've saved yourself some future trouble. Love is always troublesome especially in that sort of situation. Thankfully she loved you enough that she had the courage to do the right thing to save you from even more stress in the future. As long as your relationship doesn't have any other barriers I don't see this as a reason to permanently stay apart. She's prolly just saying that so you don't get your hopes up or anything but she'll want to talk to you again sometime in the near future. Honesty is true love.

You're probably right, unfortunately. One thing she said with utter sincerity was that she thought doing might be making the biggest mistake of her life. But part of not getting my hopes up means severing all my emotional ties. I'm sure she'll notice some of the things I've done to break those ties, and will probably take that as me never wanting to talk to her again. How can I deal with my optimistic side still loving her, and that sickening feeling in my stomach knowing that there's no way I can expect anything?
 

sixone

Lifer
May 3, 2004
25,030
4
61
Originally posted by: apac
How can I deal with my optimistic side still loving her, and that sickening feeling in my stomach knowing that there's no way I can expect anything?

Distract yourself: work out, read a book, play a computer game. Don't just sit around brooding about her. It's going to take some time, but things will get better.
 

Accipiter22

Banned
Feb 11, 2005
7,942
2
0
yah the morning after sucks...when you first wake up and for a micro-second think maybe it was just a dream...but it's not. and it's your first full day of being single again. ugh
 

IronWing

No Lifer
Jul 20, 2001
71,104
30,488
136
Originally posted by: RichardE
Originally posted by: shortspanishguy
I don't know about that. Would you rather walk in on your girl with some dude's pecker in her mouth?

Will she share at least?

You want some pecker?
 

mugs

Lifer
Apr 29, 2003
48,920
46
91
That is one of the stupidest reasons I've ever heard of for breaking up. It may not be spur of the moment, but it sure as hell is emo.
 

xtknight

Elite Member
Oct 15, 2004
12,974
0
71
Originally posted by: apac
Originally posted by: xtknight
Wasn't in your control, dude. You've saved yourself some future trouble. Love is always troublesome especially in that sort of situation. Thankfully she loved you enough that she had the courage to do the right thing to save you from even more stress in the future. As long as your relationship doesn't have any other barriers I don't see this as a reason to permanently stay apart. She's prolly just saying that so you don't get your hopes up or anything but she'll want to talk to you again sometime in the near future. Honesty is true love.

You're probably right, unfortunately. One thing she said with utter sincerity was that she thought doing might be making the biggest mistake of her life. But part of not getting my hopes up means severing all my emotional ties. I'm sure she'll notice some of the things I've done to break those ties, and will probably take that as me never wanting to talk to her again. How can I deal with my optimistic side still loving her, and that sickening feeling in my stomach knowing that there's no way I can expect anything?

It could be that she's just implying she needs some time to think. Doubt she really wants to break all connections from you. Sounds like a knee jerk reaction/preemptive strike.

I just think of it this way: God prevented something worse from happening in the future. This is as good as it gets. Be a realist about it, everything's relative anyway, the thought of a "true love" is just an unfounded belief. Or, put it this way: she'd be there for you in almost any situation despite this. For awhile I think the best thing to do is to realize that she does NOT want to be away from you forever. While it may be a reason not to get in to long-term commitment (i.e. marriage), a situation like this is not a reason to cut off ties. Often times people exaggerate their feelings in a plead for sympathy or help, and that's all she's doing right now. Unfortunately, she had to rub it off on you, but the future won't be so bad. People that are married get in fights quite often even.

Simply put, the more you're with somebody the more you can't stand them until you're away from them for awhile. Your mind was unfortunately in a utopian state that needs time to descend before you can see who she really is.

Drink lots of coffee too, it stimulates dopamine release==feel-good. :eek: Watch some comedy, do whatever, just realize it's really not your problem nor was it in your control. It's very likely that she was being completely honest with you.

P.S. I thought I'd add another thing: it does not mean severing all emotional ties. Feelings don't just evaporate after two years of being together, nor will they just go away for the rest of your life. Chill a little as right now you may feel like you're in a time machine (i.e. panic). Realize there's nothing to truly panic about. Just be yourself and be happy. You need to get the feelings out somehow, but do something like work out or write a novel if you need to. Best thing to do is leave her alone for awhile (probably months). If/when you do talk to her next, don't act overly hurt, just slightly as people can sense exaggeration easily and you'll get the maximum empathy/sympathy if you don't make it worse than it is and just stay true.
 

apac

Diamond Member
Apr 12, 2003
6,212
0
71
Originally posted by: pontifex
mutual? sounds like she broke up with you, otherwise why would it be bad?

Because even though we still love each other we both knew that this was inevitable.
 

FilmCamera

Senior member
Nov 12, 2006
959
1
0
Originally posted by: apac
Originally posted by: pontifex
mutual? sounds like she broke up with you, otherwise why would it be bad?

Because even though we still love each other we both knew that this was inevitable.

So when you realized it was "inevitable" as you say, why didn't you just dump her and try to find someone who actually fit with what you want out of a relationship?
 

apac

Diamond Member
Apr 12, 2003
6,212
0
71
Originally posted by: FilmCamera
Originally posted by: apac
Originally posted by: pontifex
mutual? sounds like she broke up with you, otherwise why would it be bad?

Because even though we still love each other we both knew that this was inevitable.

So when you realized it was "inevitable" as you say, why didn't you just dump her and try to find someone who actually fit with what you want out of a relationship?

Love has a way of screwing with everything. It's hard to treat someone who's been your best friend for 2 years like yesterdays trash. Her life just got to a certain point where we both knew something had to give, and unfortunately her insecurity with commitment meant we weren't going to make it.