YAGT: How to choose between 2 equally attractive chicks

RagingBITCH

Lifer
Sep 27, 2003
17,618
2
76
Just curious. Lately since the GF and I have broken up a month or so ago, I've had a lot of dates with a lot of chicks. On fire, you could say. Right now I have a dilemma between two chicks, one which I went out on a date with last night, one tonight. (I have like 4 other chicks who also want to go out on a date this next week, 1 of which I've ruled out, 1 of which I'm so-so interested in, the other two I'd definitely go out with if it wasn't for this dilemma)


Anyway here goes:


Girl 1: She's 19, about to turn 20. (I'm 23, will turn 24 a few days after she turns 20) She's a horse trainer, has her own business, is about to publish a book. (She's gonna be somebody someday, it's easy to tell) A little bit more on the reserved side - not too too much, but a tiny little bit. She's great - super sweet, sexy as hell, and from our date on Friday I know she's totally into me. We're going out again Sunday. (We just saw a movie and hung out at the mall Friday night) (I was going to blow off Girl 2 to go out tonight with Girl 1, but I thought I better keep my options open) Probably a 8/10 on looks. She also offers to pay for half of everything we go out and do, wants us to be complete equals. Loves to cook and treats her guys like kings.


Girl 2: She's 21, about to turn 22. Right now she's about to start studying to become a
registered nurse. She's the cutest girl I think I've ever seen, I'm surprised she wanted to go out with me. On a looks scale, probably a 8.5/10. Just straight up pure cuteness. (Half Hispanic, half white) We go see a movie, head out to this Taste of Addison event and see Smashmouth, grab some dinner and get a drink or two. Really great time, she's been burned in the past (as has #1, not exclusive to #2) and thought I was sooo nice and great to her. The bad thing is she has a daughter whose 3.5, has down syndrome. I have no problem with her having a kid, just might hinder some things. She doesn't seem like the type of person who pays for half or anything on dates, not too sure about that though.


Both Girl 1 & 2 say I'm the nicest guy they've ever dated, I'm great, sweet, sexy, have a great body/chest, all that jazz. I like both and don't want to lead either on. Any ideas? Honestly, I'm leaning more towards 2 but I think either or could turn into something really really great. Both are just absolutely amazing women, I'm just having a hard time figuring out who to choose. I don't expect you guys to pick, just any suggestions on how to choose the "right one" would be nice. TIA

EDIT: Regarding the no brainer w/ girl 1 - I guess her age (not being able to get into bars and do adult stuff) is kind of a hang up, and maybe maturity level. That and she could make it huge into horse training in a few months (Olympic related stuff) - maybe I'm afraid of being left behind in the dust with her long term.

While the thought of her having a kid kinda scares me a little bit, I don't see it as a huge factor. She has a huge extended family all living in the metroplex, the kid is well taken care of and loved by everyone. She's a great mom but has her space in relationships from the kid.

http://www.melvinchu.com/images/girl2.jpg

Pic of girl 2 - that's a bad pic of her - in person she is the cutest person I've ever seen. 10/10 on a cuteness scale. None of you guys would kick her out of bed. :p
 

Actaeon

Diamond Member
Dec 28, 2000
8,657
20
76
Girl 1. Girl2 is looking for a daddy for the kid. You don't want baggage.

It sounds mean, but its probally the truth.
 

jagec

Lifer
Apr 30, 2004
24,442
6
81
has a kid = DANGER WILL ROBINSON!!!

If you go with #2, you'll essentially be skipping the entire dating, engagement, marriage stage and going straight to fatherhood.
 

RagingBITCH

Lifer
Sep 27, 2003
17,618
2
76
Originally posted by: Actaeon
Girl 1. Girl2 is looking for a daddy for the kid. You don't want baggage.

It sounds mean, but its probally the truth.

Girl2 def. isn't looking for a daddy for the kid. From talking to her she's not looking for that. Her kid is old enough and has enough family to not need a father figure in that aspect. The "baggage" aspect does scare me a tiny little bit though, can't lie and say that it doesn't. She's a great woman though.
 

mchammer

Diamond Member
Dec 7, 2000
3,152
0
76
Originally posted by: Actaeon
Girl 1. Girl2 is looking for a daddy for the kid. You don't want baggage.

It sounds mean, but its probally the truth.

Why should she be penalized for having a kid rather than evaluated for her own merits?
 

SSP

Lifer
Oct 11, 1999
17,727
0
0
If this was bizarro world, you'd be StormRider.

oh... I'd say girl ___* has the best potential.


*I'll update this when i'm sober.
 

notfred

Lifer
Feb 12, 2001
38,241
4
0
Skip over girl #2. Kid with down syndrome = WAY TOO MUCH work. Go for #1, you'll be happy you did.
 

Acanthus

Lifer
Aug 28, 2001
19,915
2
76
ostif.org
Originally posted by: jagec
has a kid = DANGER WILL ROBINSON!!!

If you go with #2, you'll essentially be skipping the entire dating, engagement, marriage stage and going straight to fatherhood.

bingo.
 

RagingBITCH

Lifer
Sep 27, 2003
17,618
2
76
Originally posted by: notfred
Skip over girl #2. Kid with down syndrome = WAY TOO MUCH work. Go for #1, you'll be happy you did.

Ehh well I don't really plan on getting myself involved too too much with her kid. She seems pretty content with letting us be us. Like I said before, she has a huge extended family, all of whom watch her kid quite often. Yea I said the kid did kinda scare/pop into my mind but I don't see it as a huge/big problem.
 

Lonyo

Lifer
Aug 10, 2002
21,938
6
81
Originally posted by: amcdonald
Originally posted by: notfred
Skip over girl #2. Kid with down syndrome = WAY TOO MUCH work. Go for #1, you'll be happy you did.

QFT

It is kinda harsh, but also true. I mean, people may think it's nasty to say no just because of this problem, and maybe heartless, but it's not your problem, and you shouldn't feel you have to take it on just because you feel sorry for the mom.

I would go with #1 because
1) She's pretty much as hot
2) She's rich
3) No kid
 

isasir

Diamond Member
Aug 8, 2000
8,609
0
0
Maybe it's just me, but from your descriptions alone, it's no contest, I'd go for girl #1.
 

gopunk

Lifer
Jul 7, 2001
29,239
2
0
i dunno, this seems like a no-brainer...

1. has own business, publishing book, in your words "going to be somebody someday"
2. has kid with down syndrome, nothing special in terms of career, "been burned in the past"
 

RagingBITCH

Lifer
Sep 27, 2003
17,618
2
76
Originally posted by: gopunk
i dunno, this seems like a no-brainer...

1. has own business, publishing book, in your words "going to be somebody someday"
2. has kid with down syndrome, nothing special in terms of career, "been burned in the past"

Number 1 has been burned in the past too. Pretty much every woman has at one point in their life. I didn't mean to make it sound like it was exclusive to #2. #2 doesn't have the "perks" that maybe #1 does but she's a really great gal, affectionate and sweet and kind. I just dont' want to judge her b/c she has a kid and b/c #1 looks better on paper than #2 does.