YAFFTT

[bignateyk]

I am trying to get plaxico from someone, so heres what I am offering:

Joseph Addai
Joey Galloway
Wes Welker (or any other player from my bench)

for

Frank Gore
Plaxico Burress

Does this seem like a pretty equal trade? Addai is quite a bit better than Gore, and Burress is quite a bit better than Galloway, plus im throwing in Welker.

 

[Deeko]

Why on earth would you do that? Have you been watching football this year? Addai is about 10x better than Gore, and a good RB is way more valuable than a good WR.

 

[bignateyk]

Because i'm lacking at WR, and am pretty good in RB

I have Westbrook and Barber as well.

 

[mugs]

I think you should manage your own damn team, and I don't follow pro football, but it annoys me when someone offers me a trade with an extra player to "sweeten" the deal. Yeah, I got an extra player, but now I have to drop one... So offering me someone who isn't significantly better than my scrubs doesn't sweeten the deal at all.

 

[skrilla]

Wait a few more games when Plaxico's ankle and back and whatever else he wants to complain about hurts. He will be sitting out or a game time decision every week.

 

[skrilla]

Originally posted by: bignateyk
Because i'm lacking at WR, and am pretty good in RB

I have Westbrook and Barber as well.

Yeah? How did Westbrook do last week? Do ou feel comfortable with Jones taking carries from Barber? Stick with Addai, hopefully his shoulder isn't bad.

 

[bignateyk]

Originally posted by: mugs
I think you should manage your own damn team, and I don't follow pro football, but it annoys me when someone offers me a trade with an extra player to "sweeten" the deal. Yeah, I got an extra player, but now I have to drop one... So offering me someone who isn't significantly better than my scrubs doesn't sweeten the deal at all.

Except most people have a few players on their bench who are more than scrubs. I'd love to have an extra player of my choice off someones bench as icing on the cake of a deal.

I am a little worried about plax's ankle though.

 

[bignateyk]

Originally posted by: skrilla

Originally posted by: bignateyk
Because i'm lacking at WR, and am pretty good in RB

I have Westbrook and Barber as well.

Yeah? How did Westbrook do last week? Do ou feel comfortable with Jones taking carries from Barber? Stick with Addai, hopefully his shoulder isn't bad.

I actually benched westbrook as it was getting near gametime and put sammy morris in. Just my luck, morony also gets injured and morris has a great game. :laugh:

Unfortunatly the dude I was playing against had Brady and Moss, and I lost 114 to 105 :thumbsdown:

 

[Deeko]

No dude, just no. Addai is an absolute fantasy MONSTER. He's a stud, and he'll never face an 8 man front. Gore has been a HUGE bust. Plaxico has been solid, but he only had one HUGE game...kinda like Galloway.

If you're gonna trade Addai, you'd better be getting someone in the Chad Johnson/Randy Moss realm of WRs.

 

[Kev]

That trade is ridiculous. Plaxico is a 2nd tier WR at best, and Addai is a top 5 RB.

 

[bGIveNs33]

do NOT do that.

Addai >>> Gore

Burress > Welker/Gallaway

But with Caddy hurt, they might start throwing the ball more... and the NFC South is awful this year.

 

[Mill]

No.