Yafft: Trade offered to me

[Doboji]

14 team league
1QB, 2RB, 3WR, 1TE, 1K, 1DEF
10yds / 1 pt recieving or rushing
25yds / 1 pt passing
6 pts per TD
1 Sack / -1pt

My team:
QB: Brees
QB: Frye
RB: Jackson
RB: Jordan
RB: Droughns
RB: Jones-Drew
RB: Washington
WR: Coles
WR: Evans
WR: Williamson
WR: Parker
TE: Gates
K: Scobee
DEF: Philadelphia
DEF: Dallas

Again the trade offer is:
Gates

for

Mcallister+Miller

 

[Sqube]

Big Ben seems kinda off this year (IMO side-effects of the accident and the appendectomy), which will be reflected in Heath Miller's stats. On the other hand, the loss of Antwaan Randel El might make Miller a target more frequently for midrange third down passes.

On the other other hand, Deuce McAllister is going to be a workhorse all season and will get you solid yardage and probably a touchdown. In the end, I'd probably do it. I'd take Deuce over Reuben Droughns any day.

 

[darkswordsman17]

Didn't McAllister just get injured? Must be wrong because I'm not seeing it anywhere. Maybe it was a different player with the same last name.

 

[dbk]

I'd do it. RB > TE

 

[Doboji]

Originally posted by: ornament
I'd do it. RB > TE

Thats not really the question though...

The question is...

Which difference is greater...

Deuce's weekly point totals - my current RB corps

or

Gates weekly point totals - Heath Miller's point totals...

 

[Slew Foot]

Jackson is really your only good RB at this point, Id go for McCallister. TE's can be very erratic.