YAFFT: Plummer or McNabb

jammur21

Golden Member
Nov 1, 2004
1,629
0
0
McNabb @ Giants
or
Plummer at home vs Raiders

I started Plummer last week b/c I was scared of Washington's Defense, and ended up losing by 4 points. Mcnabb would hav given me 10 more points. PhoenixOrion had the winning lineup last week, but I ignored his advice on QB and paid for it.

QB?

RB
Edge
Tiki

WR
Wayne
Owens

Flex
Stokley

TE
Gonzales

D
Denver

K
Stover
 

marcello

Golden Member
Aug 30, 2004
1,141
0
0
It's a tough one. Broncos will be running against a crappy Raiders run defense. But Plummer has been one of the best fantasy QB's this year..... I'd say McNabb because they aren't such a running team like the Broncos
 

SuRgEoN

Senior member
Oct 20, 1999
690
0
0
You're welcome, I just think at this point in the season you gotta stick with him. If Peyton wasn't having the season of his career McNabb would be the MVP. Good luck this weekend.
 

Muadib

Lifer
May 30, 2000
18,127
912
126
Originally posted by: SuRgEoN
You're welcome, I just think at this point in the season you gotta stick with him. If Peyton wasn't having the season of his career McNabb would be the MVP. Good luck this weekend.
What about Daunte? He's having a great year!!!
 

wkabel23

Platinum Member
Dec 7, 2003
2,505
0
0
Originally posted by: Muadib
Originally posted by: SuRgEoN
You're welcome, I just think at this point in the season you gotta stick with him. If Peyton wasn't having the season of his career McNabb would be the MVP. Good luck this weekend.
What about Daunte? He's having a great year!!!

Except when it counts.
 

Muadib

Lifer
May 30, 2000
18,127
912
126
Originally posted by: wkabel23
Originally posted by: Muadib
Originally posted by: SuRgEoN
You're welcome, I just think at this point in the season you gotta stick with him. If Peyton wasn't having the season of his career McNabb would be the MVP. Good luck this weekend.
What about Daunte? He's having a great year!!!

Except when it counts.
What do you mean?

 

spanky

Lifer
Jun 19, 2001
25,716
4
81
Originally posted by: Muadib
Originally posted by: SuRgEoN
You're welcome, I just think at this point in the season you gotta stick with him. If Peyton wasn't having the season of his career McNabb would be the MVP. Good luck this weekend.
What about Daunte? He's having a great year!!!

if the season ended today and peyton was never born.... i would have to pick mcnabb as mvp becuz the iggles are just a better team. dante's performance has tailed off recently (probably due to moss being out), and the viking's record shows it.
 

hpkeeper

Diamond Member
Jun 30, 2000
4,036
0
0
The only game this year that McNabb hasn't been choking up points in, was the steelers game. While Plummer has thrown a bunch of touchdowns, he's also thrown a bunch of interceptions.

Not to mention, when was the last time that the Denver Brocos had an ineffective running back?

Philly doesn't have much of a running offense, wether they're playing the Giants or not, I think McNabb would have to be your week in and out quarterback... no question. He's more consistant.