YAFFT: K. Barlow or K. Jones?

[canadianpsycho]

Barlow's the established back, but the 49ers suck, and he's slumping badly. They're playing a Seahawks team at home that won't have D. Jackson, and their D is in no way playing as well as they did last time they played (shut out) the Niners.

Jones has scored in back to back games, the Lions get Schlesinger and Roy Williams, helping the offense. BUT, they're playing a Redskins team that only gives up 90 yards a game. Upside is that they can't put many points on the board, so the Lions may run more.

Please help? I'm about to flip a coin.

 

[aplefka]

Jones is freaking pro in ESPN NFL 2K5

 

[canadianpsycho]

Yeah, and I went 15-1 with the Lions in Madden 2k5... My entire offense made the Pro Bowl

Unfortunately I can't translate those results into real life

 

[aplefka]

Hahaha well Madden isn't as realistic as NFL 2k5, everyone knows that

 

[canadianpsycho]

omg, LIES.

Madden just feels and plays more realistic. ESPN looks sweet, but feels too arcade to me. And the ESPN franchise mode sucks.

Anyways, NO THREAD HIJACKING!

 

[Feldenak]

I dunno. I'm stuck with Barlow b/c the Packers have a bye week. I'm hoping Curtis Martin can cover the difference.

 

[canadianpsycho]

Well, I have Jamal Lewis as my #1 RB... But stuck with these two for the rest of the season.

 

[Glitchny]

Originally posted by: canadianpsycho
omg, LIES.

Madden just feels and plays more realistic. ESPN looks sweet, but feels too arcade to me. And the ESPN franchise mode sucks.

Anyways, NO THREAD HIJACKING!

ESPN NFL 2k5 >>>> Madden

I may be opinionated though cause I hate John Madden.
and go with Jones, Barlow hasnt done anythign recently.

I've got Tiki, and McGahee going, cause Ahaman has a bye, and Dillon might not play. Somehoe nobody in my leauge drafted good HB's

 

[PoPPeR]

BARLOW FVCKING SUCKS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

If you couldn't tell, i drafted him and have been sorely dissapointed with his constant 20 carry, 60 yard games.