YACT: turbo?

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

Calin

Diamond Member
Apr 9, 2001
3,112
0
0
Originally posted by: Shockwave
Originally posted by: LordSegan
Originally posted by: Shockwave
The problem is the turbo generates the Sinusoial Wave Effect on the intake. Most factory boosted engines come with Anti-Fundamental Dampeners to deal with the extra vibration pulses of the turbo. Since your car probably wasnt engineered to withstand these pulses it may have a negative impact on your piston velocitic cyclical time.


Was that real, or did you make those words up?

Oh no, its real........ ;)

It does sound very real... except that the turbo will create very high frequency Sinusoidal wave effect, which is easily dampened

:laugh:

"Every problem has a simple, logical solution... which is wrong"

Calin
 

Calin

Diamond Member
Apr 9, 2001
3,112
0
0
I heard that (well, for heavy trucks and so on) the life of the engine can be "measured" by the fuel consumed: an engine will resist half a million gallons of diesel fuel no matter if you idle it of drive to the floor. A turbo will increase fuel consumption, so the "normal" wear will be increased.
Also, if you put the turbo to increase the maximum RPM, the moving parts of the engine will be forced over the normal functioning regime, causing excessive wear. The wear caused by the increased pressure and forces in the engine (which are also over the engineering specification) also decrease the lifespan

Calin
 

Tiembo

Senior member
Aug 25, 2002
528
0
0
Originally posted by: Calin
I heard that (well, for heavy trucks and so on) the life of the engine can be "measured" by the fuel consumed: an engine will resist half a million gallons of diesel fuel no matter if you idle it of drive to the floor. A turbo will increase fuel consumption, so the "normal" wear will be increased.
Also, if you put the turbo to increase the maximum RPM, the moving parts of the engine will be forced over the normal functioning regime, causing excessive wear. The wear caused by the increased pressure and forces in the engine (which are also over the engineering specification) also decrease the lifespan

Calin

This only applies to mass transit engines, where they are on almost all the time.

Back on topic - a small turbo with relatively low boost should be fine. Just make sure you stay on top of your maintenance, always run the highest grade gas possible, and be responsible with the boost (don't crank it up past the safe limit unless you're running race gas and know what you're doing).

You'll probably also want to upgrade the fuel system (injectors, pump, FPR/FMU).
 

PowerMac4Ever

Banned
Dec 9, 2000
5,246
0
0
Originally posted by: Buickbeast
Originally posted by: Buttzilla
Originally posted by: Xiety
if you get a turbo, please get a turbo timer.

yup, and a blow off valve.


turbo timers' a waste and you don't need a BOV if you have an auto.
If the turbo is not water-cooled, then a turbo-timer is very beneficial. Also, not all turbo setups with automatics hold boost between shifts, so a bov would still be necessary.
 

NutBucket

Lifer
Aug 30, 2000
27,154
635
126
Originally posted by: shady06
Originally posted by: NutBucket
What turbo kit are you looking into?


acutally, its already installed in my friends Integra that i am considering buying. i dont know all the details yet

btw, blow off valve, intercooler, and turbo timer all included :p

Don't buy cars from friends. Just a small piece of advice. That, and make sure you can pass smog with this "kit" if its not CARB certified like the Greddy kit.
 

halik

Lifer
Oct 10, 2000
25,696
1
81
Originally posted by: Buickbeast
Originally posted by: Buttzilla
Originally posted by: Xiety
if you get a turbo, please get a turbo timer.

yup, and a blow off valve.


turbo timers' a waste and you don't need a BOV if you have an auto.

WRONG AND WRONG

with turbo timer you wont kill your bearings/shaft after hard boosting (the oil wont boil and gunk up) and blow off valve is needed unless you like blowing your IC and intake piping off

<-owned 280hp DSM
 

andylawcc

Lifer
Mar 9, 2000
18,183
3
81
Originally posted by: NutBucket

Don't buy cars from friends. Just a small piece of advice.

why not? isn't that still far better than buying a car from somebody you don't know..?
 

NutBucket

Lifer
Aug 30, 2000
27,154
635
126
Originally posted by: halik
Originally posted by: Buickbeast
Originally posted by: Buttzilla
Originally posted by: Xiety
if you get a turbo, please get a turbo timer.

yup, and a blow off valve.


turbo timers' a waste and you don't need a BOV if you have an auto.

WRONG AND WRONG

with turbo timer you wont kill your bearings/shaft after hard boosting (the oil wont boil and gunk up) and blow off valve is needed unless you like blowing your IC and intake piping off

<-owned 280hp DSM

Actually, if you're not going high boost you don't necessarily need a BOV. Early Volvo turbos didnt' have them, for example.
 

Demon-Xanth

Lifer
Feb 15, 2000
20,551
2
81
Originally posted by: andylawcc
Originally posted by: NutBucket

Don't buy cars from friends. Just a small piece of advice.

why not? isn't that still far better than buying a car from somebody you don't know..?
Tends to stress friendships.
 

NutBucket

Lifer
Aug 30, 2000
27,154
635
126
Originally posted by: andylawcc
Originally posted by: NutBucket

Don't buy cars from friends. Just a small piece of advice.

why not? isn't that still far better than buying a car from somebody you don't know..?

I'll come find you then when the uber accord is up for sale:p You can duke it out with OS;):p
 

andylawcc

Lifer
Mar 9, 2000
18,183
3
81
Originally posted by: NutBucket
Originally posted by: andylawcc
Originally posted by: NutBucket

Don't buy cars from friends. Just a small piece of advice.

why not? isn't that still far better than buying a car from somebody you don't know..?

I'll come find you then when the uber accord is up for sale:p You can duke it out with OS;):p

i w1ll 0wnz him with one spark plug taken out. :)
 

kaizersose

Golden Member
May 15, 2003
1,196
0
76
fundamental issues with turbo
1. more heat and pressure reduce the life of your engine. some engines have 'room to spare' and some dont, but you should check how well you particular engine does with forced induction.

2. as described above, turbos vibrate your drivetrain in ways it wasnt designed to. i know a guy who upped his turbos boost too much and the weld in the exhaust system just fell apart because of the vibrations

3. turbos spin extremely fast (much greater than 10,000 RPM). this generates a lot of heat and wear/tear. proper cooling helps but you have to idle your car for a few minutes before you turn it off so that the turbo can cool properly. in general turbos have to be rebuilt or seriously overhauled at about 70K miles.

if installed, driven and maintained properly, turbos can be a great way to boost power. they just require extra vigilence and more care.
 

NutBucket

Lifer
Aug 30, 2000
27,154
635
126
Originally posted by: andylawcc
Originally posted by: NutBucket
Originally posted by: andylawcc
Originally posted by: NutBucket

Don't buy cars from friends. Just a small piece of advice.

why not? isn't that still far better than buying a car from somebody you don't know..?

I'll come find you then when the uber accord is up for sale:p You can duke it out with OS;):p

i w1ll 0wnz him with one spark plug taken out. :)

Fat chance;)
 

halik

Lifer
Oct 10, 2000
25,696
1
81
Originally posted by: NutBucket
Originally posted by: halik
Originally posted by: Buickbeast
Originally posted by: Buttzilla
Originally posted by: Xiety
if you get a turbo, please get a turbo timer.

yup, and a blow off valve.


turbo timers' a waste and you don't need a BOV if you have an auto.

WRONG AND WRONG

with turbo timer you wont kill your bearings/shaft after hard boosting (the oil wont boil and gunk up) and blow off valve is needed unless you like blowing your IC and intake piping off

<-owned 280hp DSM

Actually, if you're not going high boost you don't necessarily need a BOV. Early Volvo turbos didnt' have them, for example.

neither did grand nationals (or intercoolers if i remember correctly), but if you close the throttle the pressure will definitely put strain in the intake piping. It might not matter in low boost cars, but as you turn the boost up, things will start blowing off.
 

NutBucket

Lifer
Aug 30, 2000
27,154
635
126
Originally posted by: halik
neither did grand nationals (or intercoolers if i remember correctly), but if you close the throttle the pressure will definitely put strain in the intake piping. It might not matter in low boost cars, but as you turn the boost up, things will start blowing off.

I agree halik:)
 

blahblah99

Platinum Member
Oct 10, 2000
2,689
0
0
Three words for you: fuel, ignition, and maintanence. Get those controlled and it'll be reliable.

<= almost finish turboing up his 97 240SX.
 

halik

Lifer
Oct 10, 2000
25,696
1
81
Originally posted by: kaizersose
fundamental issues with turbo
1. more heat and pressure reduce the life of your engine. some engines have 'room to spare' and some dont, but you should check how well you particular engine does with forced induction.

2. as described above, turbos vibrate your drivetrain in ways it wasnt designed to. i know a guy who upped his turbos boost too much and the weld in the exhaust system just fell apart because of the vibrations

3. turbos spin extremely fast (much greater than 10,000 RPM). this generates a lot of heat and wear/tear. proper cooling helps but you have to idle your car for a few minutes before you turn it off so that the turbo can cool properly. in general turbos have to be rebuilt or seriously overhauled at about 70K miles.

if installed, driven and maintained properly, turbos can be a great way to boost power. they just require extra vigilence and more care.


mighty nice collection of misconceptions....

1) forced induction will upp the compression in the engine, thats why most turbocharged cars have relativley low compression (8.5 to 1 on a DSM if i recall correctly). Turbocharging an NA car raises the compression even more, so it will put more *strain* on the components. However that doesnt tell you much about how long it w ill last. B18 at 4psi will be absolutely safe, just make sure you put premium in it...


2) Turbos dont vibrate anything... complete BS. The compressor and turbine are ballanced and will at most produce a gyro effect taht negligible compared the the weight of the engine. The turbo is BOLTED DOWN to the exhaust manni - please explain how a 10lb turbo would shake a 500lb engine...

3)turbos dont break down afte 70 or XX number of miles. their lifetime is directly related to how the owners took care of em. HEAT is what kills a turbo and makes the shaft wobble and leak oil. If you time your turbo down and use synthetic to minimize the oil gunk, they will last as long as the car.


MY BROTHER IS BUYING ANOTHER DSM WOOO
i figured i'd share, it's gonna be fun playing with the car. It's a 95 tsi FWD (boo), but hes getting a good deal on it and most of the car has been rebuilt.
 

Apex

Diamond Member
Oct 11, 1999
6,511
1
71
www.gotapex.com
Originally posted by: halik
MY BROTHER IS BUYING ANOTHER DSM WOOO
i figured i'd share, it's gonna be fun playing with the car. It's a 95 tsi FWD (boo), but hes getting a good deal on it and most of the car has been rebuilt.

I'm jealous. :( I loved my 90 GSX, before someone stole it.
 

Buickbeast

Platinum Member
Feb 9, 2003
2,459
0
0
Originally posted by: XietyCOM
buickbeast: please don't talk outta your ass.

taking out my ass? What kind of turbo car do you own?

Originally posted by: PowerMac4Ever
Originally posted by: Buickbeast
Originally posted by: Buttzilla
Originally posted by: Xiety
if you get a turbo, please get a turbo timer.

yup, and a blow off valve.


turbo timers' a waste and you don't need a BOV if you have an auto.
If the turbo is not water-cooled, then a turbo-timer is very beneficial. Also, not all turbo setups with automatics hold boost between shifts, so a bov would still be necessary.


Turbo timers are just marketing BS, that's a FACT. Being that the turbobuick community is generally older experienced car guys, not ONE of them use turbotimers. I've seen countless buicks with 250k on the turbos and still running fine. In fact, I've never heard of someone losing a turbo under 100k. Yeah, oil gaskets will sometimes leak early and need to be replaced but nothing a turbotimer would fix.

And all turbobuicks are just oil cooled, not water! The water just cools down exhaust temps and slows spools and power. Great for that extra nudge of reliability.

And talking about turbododges' of the 80's where you could get ANY dodge car with a turbo, non of those owners where "ricers" who needed timers. In fact, most had no clue what a turbo was and alot of them where lower income or family people. I know of a couple people running >200k on turbos.

And one final example, look at all of the 3/4 ton trucks pulling work trailers/tracters/mowers etc... Non of those guys have turbotimers for the turbodiesels.

So, in other words, like thedarkwolf said, " The true purpose of the turbo timer is the "Look at me I am cool cause I have a turbo timer" feature."
 

Zenmervolt

Elite member
Oct 22, 2000
24,514
44
91
Originally posted by: NutBucket
Installed and maintained properly there should be no reason that the engine doesn't last as long.
Define "properly". The intercooler and all may not matter if the bottom end can't handle the higher compression. But if you mean beefing up the bottom end of the engine too, then yeah, it should be just fine.

ZV
 

Eli

Super Moderator | Elite Member
Oct 9, 1999
50,419
8
81
Originally posted by: Buickbeast
Originally posted by: XietyCOM
buickbeast: please don't talk outta your ass.

taking out my ass? What kind of turbo car do you own?

Originally posted by: PowerMac4Ever
Originally posted by: Buickbeast
Originally posted by: Buttzilla
Originally posted by: Xiety
if you get a turbo, please get a turbo timer.

yup, and a blow off valve.


turbo timers' a waste and you don't need a BOV if you have an auto.
If the turbo is not water-cooled, then a turbo-timer is very beneficial. Also, not all turbo setups with automatics hold boost between shifts, so a bov would still be necessary.


Turbo timers are just marketing BS, that's a FACT. Being that the turbobuick community is generally older experienced car guys, not ONE of them use turbotimers. I've seen countless buicks with 250k on the turbos and still running fine. In fact, I've never heard of someone losing a turbo under 100k. Yeah, oil gaskets will sometimes leak early and need to be replaced but nothing a turbotimer would fix.

And talking about turbododges' of the 80's where you could get ANY dodge car with a turbo, non of those owners where "ricers" who needs timers. In fact, most had no clue what a turbo was and alot of them where lower income or family people. I know of a couple people running >200k on turbos.

So, in other words, like thedarkwolf said, " The true purpose of the turbo timer is the "Look at me I am cool cause I have a turbo timer" feature."
Idiot alert.
 

apac

Diamond Member
Apr 12, 2003
6,212
0
71
Originally posted by: Shockwave
Originally posted by: LordSegan
Originally posted by: Shockwave
The problem is the turbo generates the Sinusoial Wave Effect on the intake. Most factory boosted engines come with Anti-Fundamental Dampeners to deal with the extra vibration pulses of the turbo. Since your car probably wasnt engineered to withstand these pulses it may have a negative impact on your piston velocitic cyclical time.


Was that real, or did you make those words up?

Oh no, its real........ ;)

Might as well call it bistromathics :D.
 

JulesMaximus

No Lifer
Jul 3, 2003
74,586
986
126
Originally posted by: Buickbeast
Originally posted by: Buttzilla
Originally posted by: Xiety
if you get a turbo, please get a turbo timer.

yup, and a blow off valve.


turbo timers' a waste and you don't need a BOV if you have an auto.

Actuall, you don't need a BOV unless you are making over 20lbs of boost. I doubt a stock Integra motor could handle 20lbs of boost without blowing up.