Thanks for the suggestions guys. I'm not 100% sure, but at the advice/assistance of my family, the decision between:
(1) a mid-90s $5,000 import that will have 120ish thousand miles and no warranty versus
(2) a late-90s $8,000 import that will have 80ish thousand miles and includes a warranty
is an easy decision. They said my payment on $9000 will $200 / month for 4 year financing... I'll also be getting a 2 year power train warranty. So, by making double payments (pretty much the cost of my single car payment now) I'll be able to pay my car off in 2-3 years and it will be covered by a power train warranty at that time. Also, I'll be getting a car I want, with features I want, rather than making an impulse buying decision like I did with the Civic. I'll never do that again.
I'll be sure to check out the G20, ES300, the CLs, and look for more Accords.
Surprised noone recommended the Maximas / I30s like I thought they would.