Whats your age, driving record, do you have any other policies with the agent, male/female?, did you take driver ed, do you qualify for good grade discount (if you're still in school), how many miles per year, how many miles per day, what kind of insurance do you want...just liability, collision, comprehensive, what deductables do you want.
I own 3 cars:
1991 Mazda protege
1999 Ford Mustang
2005 Ford Mustang GT
I have 2 life insurance policies and my home insurance and I pay maybe $300/month. All cars are fully insured with low deductables (except the Mazda), I am male @ 27 yrs.